3 ms·
> I think the thing that makes me most sad about the internet is how susceptible it is to control and censorship. To prevent their citizens from listening to o
by tialaramex 4y ago
> I think the thing that makes me most sad about the internet is how susceptible it is to control and censorship.
To prevent their citizens from listening to one man giving a speech, Pakistan needed to organise blocking all access from ordinary customers to the entire Youtube platform.
That's the smallest thing which works. And your reaction is you are sad because of "how susceptible it is to control and censorship" ?
What if Khan instead wrote a letter to a newspaper? Government can just tear up the letter, and tell the newspaper not to publish it - no need to shut every newsagent and corner store in the whole country. Or if he wrote a book? Government just orders the book pulped, there's no need to shut libraries and close every bookstore.
The minimum effective action was to completely cut off their country from this invaluable resource, loads of Pakistanis who had no intention of viewing the speech are now aware because their favourite clip of a guy getting kicked in the nuts was blocked, or the pop video they liked, or a defence of their preferred way to make a common snack. "Hey, why doesn't Youtube work?" "Oh the government are censoring Khan".
- nwiswell 4y agoJust because Pakistan is ham-handedly Streisanding Khan doesn't mean other countries (like China) don't have this down to a science.
- tialaramex 4y agoIs your contention that China is somehow able to censor individual Youtube videos? No, China simply doesn't allow the entire platform. Whether it is a video about how to fix your bicycle, about Hong Kong protests, or a song praising President Xi, you can't see it on Youtube from a Chinese residential connection, everything is blocked.
- dec0dedab0de 4y agoI don't think blocking individual videos would be very difficult.
- bhedgeoser 4y agoWhat about the 781 vloggers reacting to that video?
- ninth_ant 4y agoThey manage ok to censor that type of activity on their approved platforms, and block platforms that don’t comply. Their dystopian control is rather successful so far.
- School-Cotton 4y agoHow do you propose they do that without breaking TLS?
- dec0dedab0de 4y agoWell they don't have to break TLS if they can man in the middle everything and force browsers to use a CA they control.
- School-Cotton 4y agoThat’s hypothetically possible but there’s no evidence that China does that. Nor is there any reason to believe that starting to do so would be “not very difficult”.
- dec0dedab0de 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Firewall https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Firewall I thought it was common knowledge that China has been doing exactly that for decades. I mean, I guess it's possible I've fallen for anti-China propaganda, but I really don't think so. The only hypothetical part on my part is how easy it would be to block a specific video. I know that blocking a single URL, or keyword matching on the title are common features in off the shelf proxy servers. Add some coding from a competent screen scraper, and you should be able to identify every way a specific video is being sent. I wouldn't be surprised if this functionality was already built in to some products.
- ipiz0618 4y agoYet they somehow manage to publish a huge amount of propaganda. They don't simply block the entire platform. They allow a few actors to access it.
- phantomathkg 4y agoIf we put on the authoritarian hat, it should be easy for us to tell how easy it is to implement default blocking for all and whitelist a few source IP to everything. No?
- aliswe 4y agoStreisanding Khan is to me an extremely bad way of putting this.
- sitkack 4y agoShould have simulcast that speech over webtorrent.
- tarakat 4y agoMeanwhile if Youtube/Google decide to downrank something into oblivion, nobody will know, and proving it is near-impossible. A foreign corporation has more control over speech in Pakistan than Pakistan itself.
- selimthegrim 4y agoWas this bothering people when PTA was blocking YouTube for years?
- School-Cotton 4y agoGoogle being able to censor things is indeed bad for freedom of expression in liberal democracies, but less bad than what authoritarian states do. I trust Google’s respect for freedom of speech more than I trust the Pakistani state’s.