3 ms·
Interesting example: In the UK, we're seeing a huge increase in the number of payday lenders, offering small loans for less than a month, for a fee of about 10
by jdietrich 15y ago
Interesting example:
In the UK, we're seeing a huge increase in the number of payday lenders, offering small loans for less than a month, for a fee of about 10% of the loan amount. Our financial regulations require all credit products to prominently state the effective APR, so most of these lenders are forced to advertise a rate of circa 3000%. This is obviously a shockingly high figure, so there has been some amount of campaigning to set a cap or outlaw payday lending altogether.
What has been fascinating is that many poverty campaign groups have opposed a ban, on the basis that it would be bad for the poor. A loan at 3000% APR may well be cheaper than going overdrawn for a day and incurring a £30 fee, or having their electricity disconnected for non-payment and having to pay for reconnection. Most payday lending customers have no other access to legitimate credit; Such high rates are the only way to lend to them and still make any sort of profit. A ban would probably be good news for illegal loan sharks, who would become the lender of last resort.
Idealism is all well and good, but the solutions that offer practical change here and now often feel deeply uncomfortable. Needle exchange and supervised injection services spring to mind - providing addicts with clean injecting equipment seems like a really shabby band-aid, but the only alternatives are unimaginably horrible.
- Dylan16807 15y agoI think it would be simpler to regulate ridiculous overdraft fees. Plenty of banks do just fine without charging them. There's no healthy reason for a bank to charge a very large overdraft fee or to charge an overdraft fee more often than once a month.
- fennecfoxen 15y agoWhen the City of San Francisco tows your car it's something like $60 a day in storage fees. Those will outweigh your interest costs pretty quickly.