3 ms·
A 1MW research reactor. Anyway, why is it always a fluoride salt? Is it because of the melting point or because of some nuclear property? I imagine there is s
by marcosdumay 4y ago
A 1MW research reactor.
Anyway, why is it always a fluoride salt? Is it because of the melting point or because of some nuclear property?
I imagine there is some very relevant reason, because a less reactive anion (even chlorine) would be much easier to work with.
- detaro 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molten_salt_reactor#Fused_salt_selection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molten_salt_reactor#Fused_salt...
- nickpinkston 4y agoGood question - here's a paper and quote on this: "Molten Salt Reactor (MSR) was designed to operate at high temperature in range 700 - 800°C and its fuel is dissolved in a circulating molten fluoride salt mixture. Molten fluoride salts are stable at high temperature, have good heat transfer properties and can dissolve high concentration of actinides and fission product." https://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/1.4972932 https://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/1.4972932
- thereisnospork 4y agoWithout knowing the specifics as apply to nukes, anion reactivity is inversely proportional to atomic reactivity, fluoride is far less reactive than chloride or bromide or iodide, respectively in order of increasing reactivity. Ergo fluoride and fluoride containing anions are quite common in molten salts/ionic liquids. In English: the flouride, having so voraciously devoured that 8th electron it was missing, really doesn't want to give it up, whereas chlorine et al have lots of spares.)
- marcosdumay 4y agoThe concern is not so much about the fluoride losing an electron, but about whatever reacted to it stealing electrons from the reactor.
- thereisnospork 4y agoWhich is less likely with fluorine because what fluorine reacts with to form the salt, say Na as in NaF, wants to give up an electron, not receive one. And with fluorine as a partner, Na will have the hardest* time retrieving that electron to give to something else. This can be easily validated by comparing enthalpy of reaction and formation for the various halide salts. The properties of broad chemical stability are not limited to ionically bonded fluorine either, see PTFE, which also derives its stability from the extreme reactivity of fluorine. Compared to say PTIE (polytetraiodoethylene), which if you could even make would rapidly yellow and degrade in open air/mild sunlight, as iodine compounds are wont to do. *for a loose definition of hardest.
- LatteLazy 4y agoIt is very stable both chemically and atomically.
- PaulHoule 4y agoFluoride salts are good for fissile uranium + fertile thorium. If you want to work with a plutonium/uranium 238 cycle then chloride salts are a better choice. Plutonium doesn't dissolve very well in fluorides. Molten chloride reactors can have performance characteristics right out of science fiction, it seems possible for such a reactor to not only breed more fuel but to destroy the long-lived (500 year) fission products such as cesium and strontium. It never gets upvoted on HN when I link it but I've been following MSRs for a while and even spoke at the first thorium energy conference and I've been watching people's thoughts about designs evolve and this one https://www.moltexenergy.com/ https://www.moltexenergy.com/ is well ahead of the others.
- nine_k 4y agoWhile at it, I never understood the worry about the plutonium surfacing in the MSR cycle. Of course it can be diverted to make nuclear warheads. But countries like the US, or France, or Russia, or China, or India already are able to produce nuclear warheads, even from plutonium extracted from more conventional reactors. I don't understand where is the risk of proliferation. Is this about international treaties and ease of inspection? About currently non-nuclear countries obtaining nuclear weapons more easily?
- colechristensen 4y agoPerhaps it's just how much more careful you have to be with plutonium products because of proliferation concerns, or possibly diplomacy concerns "legitimizing", or perhaps just paranoia. Or the basic concern of a bunch more plutonium hanging around even if secure.
- PaulHoule 4y ago(1) There is fear that any advance in nuclear power technology will lead to corresponding advances in nuclear weapons technology. For instance, if somebody built a perfect system for separating out protactinium from a thorium MSR, that protactinium could be allowed to decay outside the reactor and produce pure U233 that could be used to make weapons. That perfect system is probably not practical, but in general there is fear that any new approach to fuel processing could have unintended consequences. Would it be possible, for instance, to make something like the EBR-II that breeds weapon grade plutonium in a blanket and uses some form of pyroprocessing to produce pure metallic plutonium? Such a system might be able to make enough material to build several weapons a year. (2) The published information about nuclear proliferation is incomplete and the mental models behind it are broken. For instance, the "little boy" bomb was made with uranium produced with a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calutron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calutron but for all the fear that countries like Iran would develop centrifuges, there has been little fear expressed about Calutrons... Except that when Iraq tried to develop a bomb it used the exact same approach used by the US! A scientist at CERN had been contacted by an Iraqi scientist who was interested in a magnet which could have been used for a Calutron and the proliferation authorities just blew him off. See https://nuclearweaponarchive.org/Iraq/andre/ISRI-95-03.pdf https://nuclearweaponarchive.org/Iraq/andre/ISRI-95-03.pdf A country like Japan has large amounts of plutonium which is contaminated with Pu240 and Pu241 and not weapons usable but it's plausible that a modified Calutron could be used to purify non-weapons grade plutonium and make it weapons grade. Although the conventional model is that a threat would make plutonium by irradiating uranium with neutrons from a fission reactor, it's also possible that a fusion reactor or particle accelerator could be used as a neutron source to do the same. The later would actually have less heat output per unit of Pu and might be an easier device to hide. Current particle accelerators aren't reliable or economical enough for this purpose, but this is just one of many paths to proliferation which are ignored.
- pfdietz 4y agoBecause fluorine has a low neutron capture cross section. Chlorine has a rather high capture cross section for thermal neutrons, so it could only be used in fast reactors.
- panick21_ 4y agoThis video has a fair amount of information on exactly that question: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bkZ0ZBAVDu4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bkZ0ZBAVDu4