3 ms·
"The speed of light" is probably not what you think it is. This constant, c, is actually about how time (one of our four dimensions, often labelled t) is relat
by tialaramex 4y ago
"The speed of light" is probably not what you think it is.
This constant, c, is actually about how time (one of our four dimensions, often labelled t) is related to the three spatial dimensions (often x, y, z).
Light goes that fast (in a vacuum) because from the light's point of view that's how those dimensions are related, it's not really a "speed limit" it's up against, any more than you'd consider it a "time limit" that hours have sixty minutes in them. The light is just moving through time as well as space, and that's how it has to work.
So, because it's about the relationship between time and space, what you're talking about with "faster than light" is actually a time machine.
Now, you might notice that before the aeroplane there were birds (and bats, and insects, but lets focus on birds). Clearly flying is possible, a sparrow can do it. But you may have noticed from the lack of time travelling visitors that time travel does not seem to be possible.
- jedberg 4y agoI knew that about the speed of light (but thank you for writing it out). My knowledge of entanglement is limited, but haven't we observed entangled particles seemingly communicate faster than light? While time travel may not be possible, maybe time traveling data is?
- dsr_ 4y agoNo, we have not. We have observed that we can generate a pair of particles and separate them, and when we look at the close one, we now know that the far one has the complementary property. You can't use that to send information. You could use it as a shared secret, but you still had to move the particle out where your recipient is for them to use it. You can take a flashlight and shine it at the moon, and if you sweep the beam back and forth, you can make the notional front of illumination move faster than the speed of light -- but you can't modulate the signal faster than the propagation velocity c. Time travel into the future is easy. Time travel into the past doesn't work in this universe.
- ynik 4y agoEntanglement doesn't involve any form of communication. Only the imaginary "wave function collapse" is faster than light. But collapse isn't actually part of quantum mechanics: there's no formula that would tell you when collapse is triggered. The many world interpretation doesn't have any wave function collapse at all; and it's a valid interpretation of the underlying maths. Any "wave function collapse" is merely an interpretation trick to map the quantum world back to the classical world as experienced by humans. You can't build technology out of imaginary physics.
- tambourine_man 4y agoNope, it’s a common misunderstanding. While the particles are entangled regardless of distance and the action is instantaneous (at least, that’s one way of interpreting it) there’s no way to actually transmit information. You may try to come up with clever encodings for electron spins, but you’ll see that you end up having to know a priory what the other end had. It’s a long topic to discuss on a HN thread but a quick YouTube search will get you interesting videos.
- nly 4y agoIf time travel isn't possible how come we're all moving in to the future right now?
- dekhn 4y agopersonally, I think it's easiest to just think of the speed of light actually being the maximum speed of information propagation.
- vbezhenar 4y agoTime travelling data leads to paradoxes. It’s unlikely to be possible. Think of entanglement as pair of boots. You’ve got one boot with you and unwrapped it on the mars. Voila, you know that one left on Earth is left one. This analogy is wrong but good enough to understand why entanglement does not help with communication.
- didgetmaster 4y agoThe lack of time travelling visitors may only indicate that 'backward' time travel is not possible. It could be that 'forward' time travel will be possible sometime in the future. (And by 'forward', I mean faster than the normal movement through time we all do every nanosecond)
- gpderetta 4y agoThat's relatively trivial by going at relativistic speed.
- AnIrishDuck 4y agoThis is even a thing at non-relativistic speeds. Proper operation of GPS requires a time correction [1] because the system's satellites are moving at significant speed from the perspective of ground observers. Their onboard clocks are therefore moving relatively faster through space, and thus relatively slower through time. This is measurable at the nanosecond scale, and must be taken into account every time something uses GPS. 1. https://www.astronomy.ohio-state.edu/pogge.1/Ast162/Unit5/gps.html https://www.astronomy.ohio-state.edu/pogge.1/Ast162/Unit5/gp...
- tialaramex 4y agoI mean, technically what's going on is that satellites move at relativistic speed. "Relativistic speed" doesn't mean some particular speed, like 0.1c or something, it just means any speed where your measurements don't make sense without accounting for relativity, if your measurements were good enough this just doesn't have to be that fast really. However, do you remember simple school spring balance experiments which show Newtonian mechanics? Greg Egan's "Incandescence" is a novel about some people who live somewhere where those type of experiments need relativity to explain them, so, when they develop physics they go from "I dunno, it just always does that" straight to relativity because Newtonian mechanics don't explain what they already know about the world.
- dagss 4y agoEntering and awakening from a coma comes pretty close...