9 ms·
Not getting a new computer
- stinkytaco 4y agoIn the comments he mentions he has a mac mini m1 dedicated to music. I realize he's probably in the apple music ecosystem, so he can't just swap them, but it feels like he could be putting that hardware to better usage if he actually had an issue.
- incanus77 4y agoOr the other way around… I’m a developer and hardware engineer and use an M1 Mini as my primary machine.
- polotics 4y agoGeforce Now has been a great experience, running Windows-only games on the M1 Mac Mini just works. Still: many games download content, require you to log in, and generaly annoy on first startup with a new computer. With Geforce Now you get each team an (as) new computer...
- sharkjacobs 4y agoCool, I'm not getting a new computer either
- AlwaysRock 4y agoOne of the best parts about desktops is being able to upgrade pieces at a time. I build my computer about 5 years ago. It's been slowing down a bit over the last six months and I realized that I only had 16 gigs of ram. That was pretty good at the time. Now 32 is much more standard. Upgraded to 32 gigs for ~$120 and its been great.
- waynesonfire 4y agoI have been doing this for over 15 years. The only original component at this point is the case. My strategy has been: 1) buy modern motherboard w/ cpu and memory at mid point 2) year or two later, max out memory 3) another two years later, i buy most powerful cpu that is supported by motherboard 4) repeat from step 1 I also upgrade hdds / video cards as needed. It seems these components are upgraded more frequently than mb / cpu / memory. Though, my video card has been plenty fast for a few years now, probably because I don't play as demanding games any more. I also didn't skimp on the power supply and it's been performing well. I use a UPS to make sure the power stays clean. When upgrading the motherboard, I also evaluate the technology space to see if it makes sense to upgrade any other components. For instance, I may buy into NVMe in the next cycle depending on what my research reveals. I'm still hanging on to Windows 7. I'll probably upgrade that in the next cycle but it's been smooth. I use VMware for software that needs newer version of Windows.
- AlexandrB 4y ago> Windows 7 Last good version of Windows. Possibly ever. I miss being treated as a user/customer and not as eyeballs to be monetized.
- nomel 4y ago> buy modern motherboard The next AMD CPU to be released will almost certainly have a new AM5 socket. I'm waiting for this reason alone, considering the amazing support AM4 has had.
- fomine3 4y agoYeah PC of Theseus.
- wink 4y agoMy wife's PC sits in a case I bought in 1998 and spray-painted around 2002. Back then it matched my car because I used up the surplus paint I had from some small paint job repairs...
- nobodyandproud 4y agoAnd the color of the then car? I’m hoping the truth is a funky color like bright orange.
- wink 4y agoHehe, sadly not. It was one of the metallic blue colors of a '94 Ford Fiesta, 60PS, European model.
- causi 4y agoIf you haven't changed hardware in five years it's more likely SSD degradation or RAM speed than the difference between 16 and 32 GB.
- illuminerdy 4y agoYeah, I do the same. Although my 1070 is very long in the tooth thanks to the last couple of years of GPU madness. And now that prices have come down significantly, it's not really a good time financially for me to buy a new GPU. Murphy's law...
- banana_giraffe 4y agoAnd one of the unwritten things of this article: He's going from a "difficult, but probably doable" scenario when it comes to upgrading piecemeal to "hope you like what you get" scenario with the Alienware he had ordered. It's not 100% non-upgradable, but there are a lot of bespoke oddball parts in them, notably the motherboard and power supply. I do wish these companies were more upfront when it comes to how upgradable systems are. Some may not care, but I'm the go to tech support person for a bunch of people, and I hate having to tell them they can't upgrade their machine like they want to, despite being a desktop in principle.
- deathanatos 4y agoBoth RAM and CPU sockets have changed within the lifetime of a build; any replacement in the set {CPU, Mobo, RAM} necessitates replacing the entire set, now. (Like the author, I'm at the EOL for a machine, and … all of those might have to go.)
- mxuribe 4y agoYeah, maybe i'm old (and/or just have not conducted hardware upgrades as often as i used to years ago), but it feels like nowadays, the lifetime of builds and associated hardware has grown to be...shorter lifespan than in the past. Or, maybe its just me? I almost never play games anymore, and have long switched to linux for my daily com0puting needs, so admittedly that has allowed me to stretch things waaay longer than in the past...but hardware just feels like it needs to get replaced more often and has plain less life than in the past. Oh well.
- deathanatos 4y agoYeah, a bit, but it sort of depends? I have some parts that have lasted quite a while. The CPU in my current build is ~2012 and is fine; even stats wise its respectable, as a lot of the improvements of recent years have been rolled back by Spectre et al. But manufacture warranties are crap these days. Used to be a machine was warranted for 4 years, and a good one would last 10. But these days it seems like they're 1-2 years. Part warranties aren't great, but the stuff I've built seems to hold up. The 10 year old machine above current has a failure. I think it is the PSU, but I'm not sure. But in the 10 years it ran, the only failure it had was a HDD died like 4-5 years in. And that drive was a used datacenter drive, that when sold to me had a "it's been abused in a datacenter, 30 day warranty" on it, so it did fantastic. And I think its replacement is also now out of warranty, too, though I'd like to see it last a few more years, ofc.
- mxuribe 4y ago> ...the only failure it had was a HDD died like 4-5 years in. And that drive was a used datacenter drive... Wow, i have heard that datacenter drives (more than any other datacenter equipment) gets trashed the most...so that's awesome that it lasted even that long! Nice!
- samcheng 4y agoIf anyone out there is in a similar situation, building a new computer, especially if you have a lot of parts from an old computer to cannibalize, is actually quite easy and much less expensive than buying a new pre-built PC. Don't be intimidated! If you can turn a screwdriver, you can build a PC. (For an upgrade, you can often buy just the motherboard with CPU already attached, potentially also upgrading the power supply and RAM. Or upgrade the drive if you're running out of space. Or upgrade the graphics card if you want to play games. Everything else is pretty static and just plugs in.)
- mynameisvlad 4y agoNot if you have a Corsair One like the article author. On that particular model, even updating the SSD is a pain in the ass since (IIRC) the 2.5in one is at the bottom of the case and the m.2 is on the back of the motherboard which has been perfectly engineered to fit in that case. It also uses water-cooling on the CPU and for the upper models the GPU, using a custom loop that was created specifically to fit in the tight dimensions of the case. So good luck upgrading either the CPU or GPU easily.
- deckard1 4y agosounds like every mITX. My m.2 slot is on the back of my motherboard. That drive has been full for more than a year and I don't care enough to take apart my entire PC just to replace the damn thing. Going mITX was a mistake for me. I wanted to build a NAS and reuse parts from my mITX last year. Only thing I could salvage was the CPU and RAM. Now I have an old CPU on a new MB for my NAS and a newer CPU on my old mITX board for my main PC. SFF really limits your upgrade and reuse paths going forward. Limited PCI slots, limited SATA ports usually, limited RAM slots, the case is just too small and horrible to work with. Looks pretty sitting on a desk though.
- flyinghamster 4y agoAnother problem with SFF: proprietary case and/or power supply designs. I got bitten by that one with an old Shuttle cube. Great-looking design, but it was not mITX, it was its own thing. When it became too obsolete, there was no upgrade path.
- alexpotato 4y agoThis post reminds me of two things: 1. You'll own nothing, rent anything you want and be happy I had no idea that you could now rent a cloud video card. We all basically started renting our music from Apple/Amazon, then that moved to movies with Netflix etc but hearing you can rent desktop components feels like a big shift to me. 2. The Second Life GoogleEDU talk There is a talk given by one of the founders of Second Life where he mentioned that they took, at the time, a very bold step of rendering the physics of the game on their server farm and the piping the video feed to the user. He mentions that this happened to be at the same time that cable modems became popular. Had that not been the case, he goes on to say that SL probably wouldn't have happened. At least, not the way it did. Given the above plus the "it's still cheaper to fedex hard drives" etc, what will consumers who need more data that can be streamed but don't want to own hardware will do? (consumers could also include the SOHO folks as well)
- Turing_Machine 4y agoThat's not quite correct, though, at least with classic SL. While a lot of the calculations are done server-side, the actual graphics are rendered on the client. It's not a video feed.
- darknavi 4y agoOff topic but Lock In (by John Scalzi, blog author) is a great listen/read!
- CivBase 4y agotl;dr: You can improve performance by clearing up some space from a full storage device. Also, video game streaming exists and can be a more affordable alternative to buying a boutique PC from Alienware. Counter point: it's okay to turn down the specs on your games. Modern "AAA" PC games are usually pretty good about helping you tune your settings to find a good balance between performance and visual fidelity. It looks like this author has a Corsair One, which I suspect has an RTX 2080 graphics card. He considers that "questionable for a number of new games [he] wanted to play". As someone who has been using a GTX 980 Ti for over six years, I find that very hard to believe. Maybe he's a very competitive gamer who needs high frame rates but doesn't want to completely sacrifice visual fidelity. But then how is the inherent latency and artifact from streaming an acceptable compromise?
- neogodless 4y agoIt seems the Corsair One has been around for ~5 years, and launched with a GTX 1080[0]. Though I agree with the overall point that such a GPU should be sufficient to run modern games, unless you're insisting on 4K and higher quality settings with a certain frame rate target... which seems likely; he espouses GeForce Now, but laments having to play in 1080p. So it's odd that he isn't getting enough performance at 1080p out of a GTX 1080 (or higher). At 1080p, his CPU might even be the bottleneck (Core i7-7700K). [0] https://www.theverge.com/2017/5/11/15216182/corsair-one-review-sff-gaming-pc https://www.theverge.com/2017/5/11/15216182/corsair-one-revi...
- CivBase 4y agoHuh, I didn't realize the Corsair One had been around that long. The GTX 1080 would definitely be a more compelling case for an upgrade. Hard to believe it will be three generations old soon. And yeah, it's odd that a GTX 1080 would struggle enough at 1080p to justify streaming. Latest "AAA" game I've played is Elden Ring and I didn't need to make many visual compromises to get 60 FPS at 1080p. But I haven't played many other recent "AAA" titles so maybe ER isn't very representative. I'm also on an i7-9700K, so your CPU bottleneck theory might hold water.
- illuminerdy 4y agoInstead of cleaning out "some" apps, I would have suggested a complete wipe and clean install of his OS (after backing up, of course). Better yet, an SSD is always a great speed upgrade (I'm assuming he has a mechanical HD), as well as adding/upgrading RAM. They can really breathe life back into old computers.
- mark_l_watson 4y agoI think that some people don't factor in the amount of their time it takes to buy a new computer and get it set up sufficiently so the old computer is no longer needed. In addition to the cost of a new computer and environmental concerns, also remember the value of your time. BTW, the guy who wrote this article John Scalzi is a very good sci-fi/humor author - I have a bunch of his books.
- em-bee 4y agothat is one good reason why i don't rush to buy a new computer. when i replaced my computer the last time, the old one was 10 years old. (and we were moving, so i dropped the old computer before and got the new computer after the move. that way i offset the work on the new computer with not having to bother moving the old one. (i kept the monitors though, and i took the disks with the data)) i built the new one myself. technically i could have reused the case, but i wanted a smaller case anyways. (i really miss the pizzabox form factor. current cases are either to big, or they can only hold one disk (i need two for mirror raid)) but now i am moving again, and this time i can't take the monitors with me. they are just to large, and shipping is not an option. i probably can take the case because it is a smaller one. but instead of buying new monitors, i am considering just getting a laptop instead. i'll need one anyways so i can travel for work. but that means external disks (2x5TB) if i don't take the case too. though choices. John Scalzi: i read redshirts some time ago and recently the kaiju preservation society. very enjoyable!
- Zoo3y 4y agoI've been using the same cloud gpu service as well for about 2 months. It's able to run on Manjaro installed through snap. The service picks up input pretty well, including audio from your mic, but like the author said it will depend on the speed of your internet connection. The audio/video resolution will adjust so sometimes it looks and sounds like a 480p youtube video. It has been very pleasant to use for a city-building game I enjoy playing. I'm more inclined to try other sim-like games since I don't have to worry about storage. It uses Steam and other game marketplace accounts to check if you own the games you want to play. It may not be good for multiplayer games like cs:go or dota; I've been disconnected from a match and since the game is running on cloud I'm still "connected" in-game appearing as afk. Overall, I've been pleased with the service and plan to use it on a laptop for an upcoming vacation. Of course, nothing beats having a bare-metal GPU. I don't play as much as I used to anymore, so it's definitely a viable service for people who are sunsetting their interest in video games and do not want to pay for a gaming rig.
- ketralnis 4y agoWhat's the city building game? I'm always on the hunt for a good one
- Zoo3y 4y agoCities:Skylines is the one. I really love the transport systems it has. Mods take it to the next level https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yITr127KZtQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yITr127KZtQ
- asdff 4y agoThis one is tricky because everything is loaded into memory. If you have DLC that also gets loaded into memory. Same with mods and asset packs. I found with 16gb I had to be quite choosy about how many mods I had installed or else the game would run out of memory and crash.
- rcarmo 4y agoFunny thing: I'm reading this on a thin client (https://taoofmac.com/space/blog/2022/08/14/2030 https://taoofmac.com/space/blog/2022/08/14/2030) that I set up a couple of weeks back, and on the second HDMI port of the monitor I'm using there's a Xiaomi Mi Stick (https://taoofmac.com/space/blog/2022/04/29/2045 https://taoofmac.com/space/blog/2022/04/29/2045) that I've used to play Xcloud on. I have used NVIDIA's service on and off since 2018: https://taoofmac.com/space/blog/2018/09/30/1600 https://taoofmac.com/space/blog/2018/09/30/1600 - I did that because I'm (privately) a Mac user, can't stand fan noise and like to game, but have mostly moved to Game Pass for multiple reasons (full disclosure: Microsoft FTE with kids who prefer Xbox games to PC ones). The experience of streaming a full blown AAA title to anything (provided you have good connectivity) is pretty great these days.
- intrasight 4y agoI'm not a gamer, and this is an honest question. Isn't streaming now just as good as local - assuming you have performant internet? If so, what's the attraction of running locally? Just to ticker with hardware? Running offline? Don't most all games now require an internet connection?
- wccrawford 4y agoNo, not yet, and probably never. I signed up for Stadia and was really impressed with it. I played dozens of hours of Destiny 2 and really enjoyed my time. Then I installed Destiny 2 on my home computer and streamed it to my work computer. (I got permission, it was during lunch, etc.) The lag was noticeably less. Likewise, I had the LOTR Lego game installed on my home PC, and streamed it to a laptop in the same house. The lag on the timing-related events was absolutely noticeable. Sure, you can play from the cloud and have a lot of fun, but it's definitely not as good as playing locally, and can't be because of the lag.
- BearOso 4y agoTo further elaborate on your "probably never," many people like myself live quite a distance from the usual locations of both cloud servers and game servers. If you're not in the east or west coast of the US, it's probably thousands of miles. You can have the fastest gigabit fiber connection and it won't matter. Response time will never be acceptable simply because of distance and the limits of the speed of light. I imagine that many people think internet latency is better than really it is due to the sophisticated predictive technologies currently used in games.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- WorldMaker 4y agoInput lag will likely always be a differentiator between streaming and local. Most games are generally not designed to handle input lag at all, especially input lag at network speeds. The streaming services today have put in extraordinary work into this by using things like input prediction and "input smoothing" and those tools make games more playable than not, but it's certainly not an exact match in play to how the games were designed to be played and sometimes it shows, even when you have performant internet and good quick ping to your nearest streaming server. Of course, it especially shows as network performance degrades. (I tried streaming a game the other week on cell tower tether from a hotel with bad wifi and the input prediction was a bit like trying to semi-blindly navigate a PowerPoint or HyperCard deck of the game. Felt like classic Myst nodes with a worse game play user experience.)
- boardwaalk 4y agoOh please don’t buy an Alienware. Those plastic monstrosities with non-standard (disposable/non-replaceable) components, bad cooling, etc. By all means, buy a pre-built computer, but at least look around a bit.
- deathanatos 4y ago… like the author, I'd like to rebuild most of my current machine. I think I have a bad PSU, and I did the research, settled on what I thought was the replacement and clicked "purchase" and … the site reliably times out. The component has even gone through a sale, in the time I've been checking. The price isn't $70, EVGA, it's $∞.
- shermanyo 4y agoThere's a reason my personal PC's name is 'theseus'