4 ms·
I don't understand the the objection. Public TV licensed content. If they wanted to own the IP, they should have bought the content. What the revenue was used
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
I don't understand the the objection. Public TV licensed content. If they wanted to own the IP, they should have bought the content.
What the revenue was used for is irrelevant. If I pay an employee a salary, I dont get part of their house. If I pay a Mcdonalds for a burger, I dont get shares of the corporation.
- prepend 4y agoI think it’s because a non-profit receives tax subsidies in that donations are tax deductible and they don’t pay income tax and frequently pay reduced property tax. If they make millions or billions from licensing to HBO then they don’t pay taxes on that. They can also distribute those gains to employees and management in the form of bonuses or featherbedding. And they don’t pay taxes on the sale. So it seems more like a tax dodge than just a moral argument that government shouldn’t fund private enterprises. Or at least claim that it’s for public good.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThats just an argument that Non-profits should exist. I think this misunderstands that the entire point of having a non-profit tax status is to create a tax dodge. We want them to avoid taxes because we want to promote the products they generate. >If they make millions or billions from licensing to HBO then they don’t pay taxes on that. They can also distribute those gains to employees and management in the form of bonuses or featherbedding. Why should we care that they don't pay taxes? If they give it to employees, then they have to pay income tax at a much higher rate than a for profit would. At the end of the day, the public wanted high quality educational content produced, we set up tax incentives to support it, and the content was made.
- MereInterest 4y ago> Why should we care that they don't pay taxes? If they give it to employees, then they have to pay income tax at a much higher rate than a for profit would. Can you provide a source for this? I'm not finding anything that suggests that an employee of a non-profit organization would be taxed at a higher rate than an employee of a for-profit organization.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThat's not what I'm saying. I'm saying that lavish employe salaries are taxed more than for profit corporate profits.
- prepend 4y agoBut isn’t than an argument for not having corporations pay taxes? Or for letting revenue to corporations be tax deductible for consumers? Why should the Sesame Street production company get tax benefits over any Hollywood production?
- s1artibartfast 4y agoFor profit companies can and do deduct employee taxes as a cost of business before calculating their corporate tax liability. >Why should the Sesame Street production company get tax benefits over any Hollywood production? Specifically because we decided as a society that we wanted to encourage companies making educational content and not Hollywood blockbusters. There are strings attached to being a nonprofit. These include limits on employee compensation so that the CEO of a nonprofit can't take a billion dollar salary as a workaround for corporate profit. They have to be paid a salary that the IRS thinks is reasonable, and any excess Revenue made by the nonprofit has to go back into its beneficial purpose
- ghaff 4y agoEmployee salaries and benefits (costs generally) not employee taxes. But agree in general. US 501c3 status is based on a variety of things that the federal government has determined are worth encouraging--including education--that it has historically deemed the private sector was not sufficiently interested in funding. This in turn comes with strings. Which is not to say there aren't large and wealthy institutions that benefit from this status or that donors to those organizations don't benefit as well from certain tax benefits such as donating appreciated assets.
- 4y ago
- MereInterest 4y agoThe difference between subcontracting and embezzlement is the closeness of the relationship. If I receive public funds with the goal to advance public education and I use it to set up public schools, that is a valid pursuit of that goal. If I receive those same funds and use them as grants for private schools meeting specific goals, that can also be a valid pursuit of the goal. But I choose to direct those funds to private schools, and I sit on the board of some of those private schools, then that makes a strong case for it being embezzlement. Where the close relationship comes from may differ. It may even be from trying to avoid conflicts of interest (e.g. an agency whose policy forbids holding assets, and therefore has been the sole funding of a nominally independent production company). Requiring publicly funded would to enter the public domain would be a way to prevent this entire class of misdeeds.
- KerrAvon 4y agoThis is a fine position to advocate for, but it’s not the way the licensing worked here.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI don't think closeness or relationship really has anything to do with it. A much simpler definition is if all the stakeholders were aware and consenting of the contract, and did you deliver on your obligations. Are you insinuating that the producers of Sesame Street failed to deliver or tricked those purchasing the broadcast license
- Retric 4y agoI am proposing that public TV has overpayed for Sesame Street. It can be illegal when a nonprofit does that when paying rent on a building, but it is more difficult to value IP transactions. Sesame Workshop did nothing wrong, public TV did by agreeing to such a contract at the beginning of their relationship.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoWhy do you think public TV overpaid? If they didn't like the terms they could always not renew the license, and ultimately I guess they did. Similar arrangements are quite common in the startup world were you invent something novel. You then make a second company with a license for a specific purpose and sell the second company with the license and retain the core IP. There's nothing fraudulent about it as long as the buyers know they're getting a license and not the core IP