9 ms·
Capturing carbon from the air will always be expensive (2020)
- Maursault 4y agoMaybe we could use atmospheric carbon for currency, turning an expensive process into a lucrative process.
- gruez 4y agoSo basically cap and trade and/or carbon taxes?
- imtringued 4y agoCap and trade is an example where speculation and hoarding would be good for humanity, instead housing gets more expensive and CO2 certificates get allocated to coal plants for free completely undermining the purpose of the program.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThat's a premise of Kim Stanley Robinson's book Ministry for the Future. Financially the process might create real returns. Thermodynamically, however, it's still a losing game. It's costing you more in energy to remove the carbon than you gain energetically by creating it in the first place.
- Maursault 4y ago> It's costing you more in energy to remove the carbon than you gain energetically by creating it in the first place. Isn't this also true of mining gold and everything else? Doesn't it cost you more in energy to work for a living than it does to not work and live in poverty? Atmospheric carbon is not gold, of course, but neither is intrinsically valuable. But assuming we could somehow identify the source of the carbon and foil carbon counterfeiters that try to pass coal off as atmospheric carbon, if all currency-issuing authorities and all world governments arbitrarily name atmospheric carbon valuable and exchangeable with currency such that the value of the currency trade is more than it costs to extract the carbon, even with thin margins, if the margins are arbitrarily made to exist, that's the ballgame: we have a rush on atmospheric carbon, and everyone and their brother is trying to get rich quick extracting carbon from the atmosphere. Though it would be simpler all around to tax the living hell out of carbon producers... tax them into extinction. The market and society will adjust to not having concrete, glass, shipping, ice vehicles, etc. But this can't happen in the US until we rescue our country being held hostage by the conservative minority.
- mikewarot 4y agoRegenerative agriculture is a great way to build soil while capturing massive amounts of carbon from the atmosphere, and growing food.
- CHY872 4y agoThe mistake of this article is that it assumes that the cost of energy would be constant for such a large user of electricity. Firstly, the $0.07 industrial price for energy is driven by grid consumption. You're paying for some very cheap, bulk, steady usage production (e.g. nuclear), some very cheap but intermittent energy production like wind, and a lot of very expensive gas/coal production that can be turned on and off. If the load is extremely predictable, or the consumption can be switched off at various times, it should be possible to dramatically reduce the overall price of electricity. For a simple example, it's usually assumed that installation of 1kW of solar power costs $1000 (of which $200 goes into the panel). Well located, it'll produce at least 5kWh per day over its lifespan of about 20 years. This would produce you power at 1/3 the rate quoted by the article. But, if you were installing thousands of such things, the labour would likely go down a huge amount, and the panels would, too. Imagine the panel costs the same and the labour costs $400 instead of $800. You'd suddenly be at about $0.01-0.02 per kWh. Let's take this further. Imagine you laid down a 100km/100km area with solar panels - every inch, and somehow you could feed that into your CO2 vacuum cleaner. This would cost you about $50B/year to build and then maintain, but after 20 years you'd have a (average) 2TW power station. Let's say that sounded like too much work, and you wanted to go nuclear instead. It's claimed a new nuclear power station costs about $5k per kilowatt. That would cost a _lot_ more to build - $160B per year of expenditure to build up over 60 years and not 20 - but the result is the same, you'd have a 2TW power station. Arguably with a nuclear power station, if you were building a really big one, you'd use the same designs and it'd get much cheaper as a consequence. According to the calculations in the article, that would be enough (with the carbon vacuum cleaner) to suck up about 1.5 megatonnes of CO2 per hour, or roughly the same amount as the US produces each year. It'd be a frighteningly complex project, but at least the cost in terms of power alone comes out cheaper than covid or the Ukraine war, right?
- CHY872 4y agoPlants could also hit the amounts required. If worldwide, 10% of all farmland was used to grow bamboo, you'd be able to harvest enough carbon each year to cover the rest of the world's emissions. That's still a frighteningly large amount (really it's a frightening amount of agriculture that the world does) but given the supply chains that already exist for agriculture it's believable that it could be turned into a carbon sequestering supply chain.
- abrax3141 4y agoHmmm. The ocean phytoplankton do it for free. All we need to do is warm the oceans up a couple degrees, dump in a few million tons of old car carcasses for iron, and the resulting algae blooms will suck all the CO2 you want out of the air. As a side effect you get free infinite algae- based oil, plastic, and garden burgers. If you wanted to do this in a slightly more controlled way, you could flood the Sahara about a foot deep and turn it into a giant algal carbon sink and energy (garden burger) generator.
- janef0421 4y agoYou are proposing to solve a massive ecological crisis by intentional causing another massive ecological crisis.
- tuatoru 4y ago> a few million tons of old car carcasses for iron * powdered car carcasses, so the iron stays in the photic zone.
- robomartin 4y ago…and nobody stops to ask: How much energy is required to collect and deliver a million tons of car iron? How much energy will it take to strip down cars so you don’t dump massive amounts of contaminants into the ocean? Do paint and coatings have to be stripped off? How much energy, chemicals, water will that take? Do we have to build processing, staging and distribution plants? How much energy and resources will that take? Do we have to build specialized ships? Same questions. How much petroleum will all of the above require and burn in the form of derivatives, lubricants, gasoline and diesel for transportation and related construction projects? How many million tons of super-dirty bunker fuel will the thousands of ships used for this have to burn? How much fuel, energy, materials and resources will have to be expended for decades in order to just monitor and manage this? Oh, wait, we want to powder the iron? How much energy and resources are required to powder a few million tons of metal? And then, once that accounting is done: How much CO2 and other pollutants will all of the above produce. This is what I sometimes refer to the self-righteousness of hand-wavy “solutions”. In quotes, because they never are. Yet, they sound great. Politicians and those making money through the insanity climate change has become can use this hand-wavy stuff to great benefit and appear righteous when, in reality, they are in a range between ignorant and scam artists. At the same time, those who dare question the validity of such claims are vilified. “You don’t want to save the planet? You evil bastard!” How about: No! I want you to stop and fully support the nonsense you are trying to float with the aid of a little thing called science. The problem is, you can’t. These do-called solutions are far more likely to kill all life on earth than to save it.
- DangitBobby 4y agoIf you're filtering air right as it comes out of the plant, the CO2 concentration will be much higher, right? So if filters attached directly to the plant have a much lower theoretical energy cost to reverse the associated entropy, it could still be possible that plants are able to power their own emissions capture with a surplus. The surplus can be used to drive the more expensive carbon capture from the atmosphere.
- robomartin 4y agoIt is impossible to clean anything with less energy and/or matter than what went into creating the problem. Period. This isn’t something that is up for discussion. It’s the way the universe works.
- DangitBobby 4y agoSomeone should tell that to the author of the article > A typical coal power plant emits a tonne of CO₂ for every 1,000 kWh of electricity it generates. Meanwhile, we learned that the energy needed to recapture 1 tonne of CO₂ from the air is at least 1,400 kWh. This means that recapturing the emissions of a coal power plant takes more energy than the coal plant produces! And those calculations are based on the much harder to filter concentrations of CO2 in the atmosphere. Anyway, CO2 isn't the only byproduct, nor is it the only source of entropy. So we aren't trying to reverse all of the entropy for free, just part of it.
- rcxdude 4y agoThat isn't the hard law of the universe (the universe cares little about 'clean' or 'problem'). You can't put it back the way it was, but you may be able to put it into a better position than it was before. Thermodynamics doesn't prevent carbon sequestration from working because the carbon dioxide is still carbon dioxide, not the hydrocarbons it was before (also there's a general presumption that even if you don't manage a cheaper sequestration than the original energy gained when producing it, you can still effectively 'pay back' some of the costs of fossil fuel generation with renewable generation, with interest).
- robomartin 4y agoI can’t think if a single proposal to “save the planet” that does not grotesquely violate the most fundamental laws of physics, like Conservation of Energy. And yet they gain traction because they are of use to politicians to gather people behind issue they turn emotional and those making money with the profanity the entire climate change industry has become.
- DangitBobby 4y agoFortunately there's a constant supply of energy into the earth system, so conservation of energy is not violated! Unfortunately, that fact means you need much more complex calculations than "there's no such thing as a free lunch" to decide if the problem can be solved, now.
- robomartin 4y ago> Fortunately there's a constant supply of energy into the earth system, so conservation of energy is not violated! I read versions of this argument all the time. What I find amazing about it is that proponents dismiss conservation of energy without realizing that without it, there would be nothing to talk about. CoE is at the CORE of global warming and is THE relevant scientific principle that rules it. Why? Earth could be thought of as an isolated system in space. Energy-in, energy-out. If the planet emits less energy than it receives, it gets hot. If the planet emits more energy than it receives, it freezes. Everything we are talking about has to do with the principle of conservation of energy and its application at a planetary level. If, for example, we somehow capture 20% more of the solar energy we receive on the surface and do not return it to space, we will cook ourselves. In other words, any so-called solution that seeks to transform solar energy into magical beans to precipitate CO2 from the atmosphere has provide solid accounting of how it will affect energy balance. After all, a CO2 reduction solution isn't so unless it can operate at a planetary scale. And, because of that, it will require an astronomical amount of energy and matter to work. Something --anything-- of that scale that is claimed to work in decades, rather than tens of thousands of years, will require energy and matter at probably an unimaginable scale (is that larger than astronomical?). This places it between impossible and fucking dangerous. At one end of the scale we just can't pull it off, end-up causing more damage and pollution than we ever imagined and waste decades and resources that could have been put to good use. At the other end of the scale we deploy something that might kill half (or more) the life on earth, permanently damage ecosystems, food supplies, weather and more. Do nothing, then? No. Just don't do stupid.
- neilwilson 4y agoCapturing carbon from the air is what plants and rain already do. And have been doing for a considerable amount of time. Almost certainly that will already be the optimum solution, or evolution would probably have found a better one by now. What we need are ocean based limestone creating factories. That's the solution nature uses.
- rcxdude 4y agoWhy would evolution be optimising for capturing carbon? It doesn't seem related to the survival of the trait.
- neilwilson 4y agoHow do plants make their food?
- Asraelite 4y agoHistorically, evolution's solution to drastic ecological changes has been mass extinction events followed by recovery periods of millions of years. There are plenty of easy solutions to climate change, but none of them are fast.
- imtringued 4y agoThe problem we are trying to solve is keeping the co2 stored somewhere. In the past there were no wood eating fungi which meant forests were really good at co2 sequestration. That is no longer true, plants alone cannot get rid of excess CO2 anymore so we need humans to do something.
- neilwilson 4y agoCome on, think about it a bit. How does limestone form?
- cschwarm 4y agoThe article fails to mention the costs of reducing carbon emissions. Compared to that, US$100 per tonne of CO₂ can be cheap. The shutdown of the economy during Covid-19 provided a case study for the costs of reducing emissions by reducing consumption and production. According to the Rhodium group [1]: > the emission reductions achieved this year as a result of COVID-19 are incredibly costly. We estimate the US will spend between $3,200 and $5,400 of lost economic output per ton of emissions avoided, depending on the shape of the recovery scenario. In my opinion, only a market for CO2 emissions can find the least-cost solution for a net-zero society (both terms should be understood within the capabilities of human beings). As long as the revenue is actually used to pay for actual negative emissions (not offsets, or hypothetical social costs), climate change will stop (getting worse) as soon as supply equals demand, and a market clearing price is reached. Let's say, this turns out to be about US$300 per tonne. If so, the article only demonstrates that there's money to be made using carbon capture from the air. [1] https://rhg.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Taking-Stock-2020-The-COVID-19-Edition.pdf https://rhg.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Taking-Stock-2020...
- picsao 4y ago