3 ms·
> It would have been far better to risk naysayers’ ridicule and dive in earlier and stronger. It wasn't ridicule, it was propaganda intended to get people to v
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
> It would have been far better to risk naysayers’ ridicule and dive in earlier and stronger.
It wasn't ridicule, it was propaganda intended to get people to vote against their own best interests (and therefore stop politicians from acting, by threatening them with consequences)
And it worked, really well. Still does.
If you're treating these issues as if it was a bunch of misled but ultimately well meaning individuals then you are in trouble before you start.
For example, "we need new tech to solve this", which is both true and dangerous. True in the sense that a million little fixes have made things better, dangerous in that climate change deniers will use it to divert time, energy and money from known fixes:
> Green energy cannot meet Germany’s need for reliable electricity. That is why Germany still needs copious amounts of fossil fuels; German CO2-emissions have risen since the nuclear power phase-out of 2011, despite the incredible subsidies for renewables.
> Germany is an example of how not to do green energy. Instead the solution is to research and develop better green energy technology.
That was Bjorn Lomborg during the previous Ukraine gas crisis in 2014. Better technology than Wind and Solar, which are the two winners of a global, 4 decade race to produce cheap, clean energy. That's what he thinks we need. While at that time Wind energy was the cheapest source of energy available, and Solar was rapidly catching it up.
And here he is on twitter a few months ago doubling down on that:
> The idea that the Ukraine war could be fixed by choosing Western dependence on Chinese solar panels and batteries over Western dependence on Russian oil and gas reveals just how unserious the environmental movement really is
So, it's a real problem, and we really need to do something about it, but what the consensus solution is, isn't a solution after all, we just need to invest in future tech that will solve the problem. We can't rely on the the Chinese manufactured solar panels that he himself claimed did not work. Now they work, they're just too Chinese.
That's the depressing lesson of Climate Change and COVID, if right-wing politicians can buy a few votes and stall some regulations via attacking science, reason, fact etc., then they will.
- codexjourneys 4y agoYes, we need to take massive action now with what we have, while also developing future tech like better transport for solar energy. Pushing for further delays based on “future tech will save us someday” isn’t anything I support. It’s disheartening but unsurprising that some factions are framing it as either/or instead of both/and. Interesting background about Lomborg, thank you!
- scottLobster 4y agoTo be fair, he's making two separate points. One technological and one political. Germany is neither sunny nor windy nor has a long coastline. It's a poor candidate for those forms of energy regardless of who's making the panels and windmills. If they want zero emissions from power production they'll have to go nuclear or build out the infrastructure to import clean energy from countries with better renewable options. Solar and Wind as we know them are part of the solution, but aside from a few areas that are abnormally sunny or windy by global standards there's no way they can even theoretically be the entire solution, and that's not even touching on the inadequacy of current battery technologies and mineral inputs needed to manufacture all this stuff. From a political perspective, I'd say he's right that being beholden to China is little better than being beholden to Russia, only practical difference being China lacking options for military invasion. Simple fact is there is no solution to climate change at the moment. We're working on a number of things that might one day become pieces of the solution, but I see too much "we just have to do X, Y and Z and climate change will be solved!" rhetoric that is wishful thinking at best, and ivory tower edicts ignoring all externalities of said decisions at worst. The world isn't a computer model.
- marcosdumay 4y agoBuying photovoltaic panels does not make one beholden to anybody. What is completely different from buying fuel.
- ISL 4y agoIn the short term, yes, but in the long term, panel-production capacity will be a key pillar of a country's independence. Buying panels from another country helps that other country realize both enduring expertise and aides their economy of scale. Also, should solar-powered countries ever go to war, I suspect single airbursts of comparatively small conventional munitions will be sufficient to shatter large swaths of panels, making production capacity important.
- marcosdumay 4y agoThe long term contains plenty of time to grow internal industry or find another seller. And yes, productive capacity of everything is important when you consider a war. Still, fuel supplies are much more fragile than solar generation.
- froh 4y agoyes! and the "Germany can't go green" BS is such a blatant disinformation. fact is the Bavaria has de facto prohibited new wind turbines near by enforcing a minimum distance of 10x the height ("10H rule"), and some pseudo ecologists rally against wind farms systematically. fact is the the 100000 roofs program, Turing private homes into profitable local photovoltaic micro powerplants was absolutely successful and was.stopped after a government change, the "conservatives" were more into conserving coal and gas profits than into conserving gods.creation, nature. the plain lie that Germany "doesn't have enough coastline, sun and wind on shore" which is perpetuated also in some sibling comment serves only fossil and nuclear traditional energy. the resistance of that fossil lobby forced photovoltaics and wind turbine.planta out of business in a world wide growth market. they manipulate opinion and thus the market. oh I'm so angry.