12 ms·
Lessons I wish I had learned before I started teaching differential equations [pdf] (1997)
- funstuff007 4y agoMy major did not require DE, but I took it anyway as a senior--mostly to test my mettle. Most of the time, I was just like why won't they just let me solve this via the Trapezoidal Rule (or similar, my memory is hazy on this), or Monte Carlo methods.
- nyc111 4y ago"Why is it that no one has undertaken the task of cleaning the Augean stables of elementary differential equations? I will hazard an answer: for the same reason why we see so little change anywhere today, whether in society, in politics, or in science. Vested interests dominate every nook and cranny of our society, even the society of mathematicians." How true! I wonder why humans are unable to devise a society where useful change occur swiftly when necessary.
- NhanH 4y agoBecause people can’t agree on which change would be the most useful (we have limited capability to change things, regardless of how easy the change would be), nor when it is necessary.
- st-keller 4y agoAnd in addition to the fight against vested interests, we have to invest a lot of energy against stupidity and to jump through artificial loops set up by lawyers, administrators and managers. Which leaves so litte to actually do something!
- atemerev 4y agoThe vi editor was designed for slow terminals and a particular keyboard without arrow keys (ADM-3A terminal keyboard), yet after 46 years there is no shortage of vi fans that insist that modal editing (an adaptation for slow terminals) and hjkl (an adaptation for a keyboard that used to have no arrow keys) are inherently superior for all modern editing needs. :)
- chongli 4y agoTerminals remain dreadfully slow compared to the speed of thought. People prefer vi because it's the best editing paradigm discovered so far which achieves one thing: reduce, as much as possible, the delay between a thought in mind and a corresponding change in the document. Other paradigms put too many context switches between my thoughts and the changes I want to see. I do not want to take my hands off the home row to reach the cursor keys, or God forbid the mouse. I also do not want to destroy my pinkie finger with endless usage of modifier keys. So that leaves me with vi (and kakoune).
- dragandj 4y agoWhy would anyone use pinkie for modifier keys? Nowadays you can reconfigure positions of CTRL and Meta and Shift to your taste. I happily us Emacs without ever stretching my fingers, because all these keys sit happily under my thumbs (literally).
- chongli 4y ago"First you need to buy a custom keyboard that puts all the modifier keys under your thumbs" is not a very enticing pitch for a text editor. Doubly so for those of us on laptops where the idea of carrying around an external keyboard is a non-starter.
- atemerev 4y agoWell, for me, to record my thought as quickly as possible, it is vitally important for the editor to always be in the input mode, I can’t lose time to remember the modal context I am currently in (and emacs is hardly better, as it can suddenly switch its focus to some command buffer, and not come back unless some specific action is taken).
- Lio 4y agoI don’t want to advocate for you to use something that doesn’t fit your preferences but for the record Vim/NeoVim can work that way too. You can start it in Insert mode and you can have it stay in Insert mode as you run a single command using C-o. There’s also a plethora of Insert mode ctrl shortcuts which are worth learning in addition to Command mode stuff. If you’re on the emacs path you'll be able to do all the same stuff, just differently. The major point is that terminal based software is fully keyboard driven and you can commit the shortcuts to muscle memory and compose them.
- stoneman24 4y agoIn general, most people hate change. We have divided life, knowledge, every aspect into little known boxes. Change requires us to work, adapt to the alteration. Perhaps reconsider our viewpoints, re-actions and even occupation. Change happens more typically when the new idea slowly seep into main stream society and old ways recede as people retire (or die). Modern technology has vastly increased the rate of change (ideas, lifestyles, jobs etc) by making the transmission of idea much easier and faster. But this places a high demand on anybody reading the news (drinking the firehouse of the internet) and trying to keep up.
- chongli 4y agoI just finished writing a comment in another thread (about macOS) on how I'm tired of all the change in the software industry. There's just a constant churn and change for its own sake. UX designers, especially, seem to love continuously disrupting my workflow by rearranging the interface in ways that surprise me and offer little/no obvious benefit. Here we have the opposite: stagnation, a lack of change. Corruption and nepotism everywhere gumming up the works. To address your point: I believe the reason we cannot devise such societies is because vested interests are more motivated and better equipped to bend the rules to their advantage. That's the whole reason to invest in anything. People want leverage to secure their positions and their possessions against external risks. A society where everyone is equal is like the beginning of a Hunger Games: a deadly rush to either grab a weapon or take cover.
- atoav 4y agoThis is one of the most unnecessary aspects of IT in my opinion. I get that there are some things that require so much foundation that explaining them in technical detail cannot be done, but there are too many people in our profession that get a kick out of making things look needlessly hard, when sometimes they can be explained in a sentence so you grok the idea behind it. Maybe it is also a nerd thing, but I know people who will explain you some minor aspect of the thing in excruciating detail, but totally fail to give you the big idea of what this thing even does, solves, is there for etc. It is the kind of explaination that only makes sense when you are on the same level on that topic as them. This always makes me angry. I can remember how hard it was to grasp concepts and conventions I use blindly nowadays. But back then I was not stupid, there just was a heap of things no documentation or tutorial would explain, because it would just be assumed. Remembering your own struggles is essential when creating explainations for others.
- hackernewds 4y ago> wonder why humans are unable to devise a society where useful change occur swiftly when necessary. It does within free markets. Universities and professiorial societies are notoriously elitist, exclusive and x-poly
- quantum_mcts 4y ago> it led me to realize that I had no idea what a differential equation is I remember how I realized that I had no idea what a differential equation is when reading W.L.Burke book "Applied differential geometry" (highly recommended). Modern differential geometry turned out to be the strict mathematical bedrock for a lot of undergrad math. I was even more surprised to learn that a lot of my former teachers wasn't really aware of that. In my view, the introductory math courses are supposed to just introduce the basic vocabulary, show the big picture and demonstrate the usefulness of the subject by showing algorithms for solving typical problems. It is not supposed to make sense on deeper inspection - and, I believe, teachers should be candid about it.
- mhh__ 4y agoAn education in geometry and it's prerequisites is a very rewarding journey F. Schuller's lectures on this (starting with logic ending with applications of geometry to physics) are very pleasant
- yodsanklai 4y ago> 7. stay away from differentials I always had issues with this. My undergraduate math classes were very formal and well thought, every object was defined, almost all theorems were proved in class. In particular, we were taught differential equations theories, some general theories like systems of differential equations with constant coefficients, Cauchy's theorem, and a bunch of recipes. In a separate class, we were also taught differential forms (e.g. a.dx + b.dy being a linear combination of base elements dx and dy - if I remember well). But then came the physics class, why we could go from dy/dx = f(x) to dy = f(x).dx and integrate both sides remain a mystery. "dx" suddenly became an infinitely small things, when it used to be a notation for a linear form OR a notation for f'(x) === df/dx. Generally speaking, I had a lot of issues in physics because the maths used in that context were not formally defined and seemed to obey to some unwritten set of rules that you were supposed to find out by yourself during your final exam...
- notfish 4y agoTheres definitely a lack of rigor math-wise in physics as a rule. It’s not for everyone. That being said, that lack of rigor is a useful tool sometimes. The dirac delta “function” (functional?) was described in the world of physics first as the only reasonable derivative of a step function/impulse before it was properly defined in the words of mathematics; just because the equational rigor isn’t there yet doesn't mean the argument isn’t solid or the tool is poor.
- ngcc_hk 4y agoIt is not the lack of rigor. It is more using Math as tool. If it fit the purpose
- oplaadpunt 4y agoThis echoes my own experience of differential equations in physics. I once actually asked my teacher directly about the dx schenanigans, and he basically said 'whatever, it's just what it is'. It left me with a rather sour attitude towards the subject as a whole, the idea that you should just manipulate symbols in some arbitrary way
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lemursage 4y agoAfter reading Strogatz, I view past courses I have taken in engineering DEs as a crime on students and lecturers alike. I know there's a substantial difference between pure/applied maths courses and engineering, but a massive failure to make such a broad subject boring with dry, abstract examples is still beyond what I can forgive. That said, the courses did not traumatise me nearly enough to stay away from DEs which I guess is the only positive take I have at the moment.
- ncfausti 4y agoThanks for mentioning Strogatz! I'm watching the first few lectures of his nonlinear dynamics course[1] and love how clear and approachable he makes the subject. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ycJEoqmQvwg&list=PLbN57C5Zdl6j_qJA-pARJnKsmROzPnO9V https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ycJEoqmQvwg&list=PLbN57C5Zdl...
- boppo1 4y agoWhat do you like about Strogatz?
- lemursage 4y agoI enjoy the overall fashion in which he presents the topics — clear, motivating example to start with, building on relevant details etc. His textbooks read like a good popsci book, yet they are of course much more detailed. I’m not sure how suitable his e.g. « Nonlinear dynamics and chaos » are for math students, since it feels a bit informal, but for developing intuition, interest and the scope of the subject, I haven’t seen anything better.
- raverbashing 4y agoGreat writeup It's amazing (in a bad way) how most professors couldn't care less about how/why they teach something. Didactical thinking is nowhere to be seen. And yes even a lot of youtubers just repeat the same unsufferable self-pleasuring of "solve this problem here like it's the 1900s". Or how professors will throw a fit whenever you solve a limit problem using L'Hospital instead of their farcical show-and-dance about limits. It's appaling. Pro-tip: Nobody cares. > Allow me to state another controversial opinion: existence theorems for the solutions of ordinary differential equations are not as important as they are cracked up to be. Correct. See point above > will list a number of disconnected tricks that are passed off as useful, such as exact equations, integrating factors, homogeneous differential equations, and similarly preposterous techniques. Since it is rare – to put it gently – to find a differential equation of this kind ever occurring in engineering practice, the exercises provided along with these topics are of limited scope: Ugh. This is so Dickensonian it hurts. See the point above about "Nobody cares" Learn what they care about, learn how to best explain the point in question (it's hard)
- hackernewds 4y agoL'hopital*
- alimw 4y agoDefinitely not. Either l'Hôpital or l'Hospital
- raverbashing 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guillaume_de_l%27H%C3%B4pital#/media/File:L'Hospital_-_Analyse_des_infiniment_petits_pour_l'intelligence_des_lignes_courbes,_1715_-_1425244.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guillaume_de_l%27H%C3%B4pital#... Though it seems people write it both ways (it is pronounced without the S though) > In the 17th and 18th centuries, the name was commonly spelled "l'Hospital", and he himself spelled his name that way. However, French spellings have been altered
- effie 4y ago> Or how professors will throw a fit whenever you solve a limit problem using L'Hospital instead of their farcical show-and-dance about limits. They are teachers, they want you to think and practice mathematical way of thinking, using minimal set of assumptions. Exercising this discipline in thought to some extent is useful. Using l'Hospital rule to solve simple problems that are easy to solve from first principles is like taking out a fly with a nuke, when you have nukes. Just because you can, does not mean you should.
- nyc111 4y agoHe has other great essays, https://archive.org/details/indiscretethough0000rota/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/indiscretethough0000rota/mode/2u...
- AdrianB1 4y agoWhen I was in college more than 50% of the courses existed for historical reasons only; not that I never used anything, ever, from it but some continue to exist today, decades later. Higher level mathematics in computer science is an exception in the life after college, so teaching it to everyone just because 1 in a million may ever used it is a waste of time, money and brain cells. Note: back then in Eastern Europe some college-level math was done in the last 2 years of high school, so what is considered "higher level mathematics" is a subjective term, please take that into consideration when reading the paragraph above.
- zozbot234 4y ago(1997). Discussed here in 2017: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15163979 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15163979 and previously in 2016 (different link): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11207183 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11207183
- ubj 4y agoOne of the most interesting applications of ODEs (in my opinion) is the field of control theory, which empowers autonomous systems/robots/vehicles to guide themselves. Brian Douglas has some fantastic introductory videos on the subject [1]. I don't think I agree completely with section 5 (Forget About Existence and Uniqueness of Solutions). For an ODE in the form xdot = f(t,x), existence and uniqueness on an interval follows if f is continuous in t and Lipschitz continuous in x [2]. This often isn't too difficult to demonstrate for a given system. In addition, if you can't prove uniqueness of solutions then you likely have to treat the system as a differential inclusion [3]. I personally find differential inclusions fascinating, but the math can be much more dense. [1]: https://engineeringmedia.com/videos https://engineeringmedia.com/videos [2]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Picard%E2%80%93Lindel%C3%B6f_theorem https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Picard%E2%80%93Lindel%C3%B6f... [3]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Differential_inclusion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Differential_inclusion
- mmmmpancakes 4y agoFor those who don't know, the author was one of the best combinatorialists ever.
- jpmattia 4y agoHe was also a very good lecturer: I took a probability class with him (he had stopped teaching the DiffEq course by the time I went through.)
- mmmmpancakes 4y agoLucky you!
- ogogmad 4y agoI find the following remark by Rota interesting: Insofar as the Laplace transform goes, two radically different uses of the word “function” are dangerously confused with each other. The first is the ordinary notion of function as a something that has a graph. The second is the radically different notion of function as density, whether mass density or probability density. For the sake of the argument, let us agree to call this second kind of function “density function.” Professional mathematicians have avoided facing up to density functions by a variety of escapes, such as Stieltjes integrals, measures, etc. But the fact is that the current notation for density functions in physics and engineering is provably superior, and we had better face up to it squarely I've suggested to mathematicians that the notation ⌠ | f(x) dμ(x) ⌡ in measure theory where μ is a measure should be replaced with ⌠ | f(x)⋅μ(x) dx ⌡ where the measure μ is treated as a density function. What I've found is a mixture of either not understanding the logic, or the response "What's the point?" So it's interesting seeing Gian-Carlo Rota suggest the same idea AFAICT. As a bonus, the Radon-Nikodym "derivative" would be written as μ/λ instead of dμ/dλ. The RN derivative then doesn't appear like a derivative - it looks simply like division.
- iamcreasy 4y agoWhat is wrong with the two difference usages of a function? If you treat function as a system that produces an output given an input - does it matter if it is a graph or a probability distribution?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ogogmad 4y ago> If you treat function as a system that produces an output given an input - does it matter if it is a graph or a probability distribution? Because that's wrong. For example, take the Dirac delta function (point mass). You can only integrate it, not evaluate it. GCR was saying that it's OK to use the same notation for both kinds of function. Mathematicians use separate notations, which is ugly and awkward. Engineers and physicists conflate these objects in their terminology, which is misleading. The right answer is to use the same notation but explain there's a difference.
- kcl 4y agoThe differential equations course was one of the most baffling experiences I ever had. The professor on the first day told us the course would be rote, as opposed to proofs, and every day he copied the methods to the chalkboard. He specifically instructed us to copy them verbatim into our notebooks. In this way there was not a lot to discuss, and from time to time the professor would gently steer us back to merely copying and memorizing the methods, even though no one had questioned him out loud. The methods were entirely disconnected. I had no indication of how they were derived or what the original motivation might be. What a differential equation was or why I wanted to "solve" one---this generated a second equation---was a mystery. None of the problem in the physics sequence looked like this. The engineering students claimed to have them, but reminded me that "this was all done by computers now." In the textbook there were no word problems, only formulas, and so I was never able to infer what this might all be about. The problems gave no opportunity for insight beyond recognizing the form. On the homework I manipulated one formula into another. On the test I did the same thing. Through memorization, I got an A in the course. I never encountered a differential equation before or since.
- colordrops 4y agoA class taught like this for me was what got me to quit physics and switch to CS.
- punnerud 4y agoAnd why it took a long time for back propagation to be introduced into machine learning.. Back propagation is (almost) just a fancy word for differential equation, with derivative relative to the error in the output against your training data.
- icedchai 4y agoMy differential equations course was one of my worst undergraduate experiences. Somehow I still passed.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- meltyness 4y agoI was a curve-breaker to the downside, I became convinced since that math is exclusively about plug-and-chug formulas, and that each course would fling these at you. Now I better understand that it's a story about problem solving. I think organizing the course around the complexity of the differential model under inspection is a bad principle. The course should be organized around broadest-applicability solution methods to narrowest. Something like early numerical-methods. This might help lift the veil.
- keewee7 4y agoHow do Electrical Engineering courses in college deal with this? I think differential equations and the Laplace transform is something they learn on the firt semester or year. The dropout rate must be high unless they have found a creative and fun way to teach this stuff.
- lemursage 4y agoAs an undergrad in EE and CS this was a bit of a mixed experience to me. Laplace transform was presented as kind of a nice hack, but I think the actual development of intuition is delegated to non math specific (engineering) subjects like for instance, Field Theory, Circuit Theory, Signal theory or Numerical methods. It seems that it’s expected that the students just blindly learn the basics of DEs which serve as one of sieves for non-math inclined students (here I may controversially say, rightly so!). You’re simply to swallow bunch of dry scones aka theorems and only then learn how to sue them.
- aj7 4y agoThere is zero intuition about the Laplace Transform. It just is. Like English or Chinese.
- photochemsyn 4y agoThe only reason for scientists and engineers (i.e. non-pure-mathematicians) to learn ordinary differential equations is so they can move on to partial differential equations. This is because: > "Most of the natural laws of physics, such as Maxwell's equations, Newton's law of cooling, the Navier-Stokes equations, Newton's equations of motion, and Schrodinger's equation of quantum mechanics, are stated (or can be) in terms of PDEs, that is these laws describe physical phenomena by relating space and time derivatives. Derivatives occur in these equations because the derivatives represent natural things (like velocity, acceleration, force, friction, flux, current). Hence, we have equations relating partial derivatives of some unknown quantity that we would like to find." For the vast majority of people working with DEs, they'll have two major goals: (1) Take a physical problem they wish to model and construct (formulate) the PDE (the actual mathematical model), and (2) Solve the PDE, taking into account the initial value and boundary conditions. Going through a introductory course in ODEs is a valuable process because a common method of solving a PDE is reducing it to an ODE. However, with real-world problems, the actual approach will almost always be computational: > Numerical methods: These methods change a PDE to a system of difference equations that can be solved by means of iterative techniques on a computer; in many cases this is the only technique that will work. In addition to methods that replace PDEs by difference equations, there are other methods that attempt to approximate solutions by polynomial surfaces - spline approximations. A related common approach are perturbation methods, which transform a nonlinear problem into a series of linear ones that approximate the original nonlinear equation, and to which in turn numerical methods can be applied. Wikipedia has a good writeup: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perturbation_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perturbation_theory Quotes from a very good source: "Partial Differential Equations for Scientists and Engineers, Stanley J. Farnow, 1993, Dover" Pure mathematicians tend to oppose the introduction of approximate and computational methods early on, but there's no reason they can't be taught side-by-side with the traditional 'exact solutions' material, and it would probably greatly interest and benefit students.
- meltyness 4y agoAs I read, I begin to share your blame. That what looked so promising in the 19th century really should have been immediately quashed in the 20th when computing theory reared its head. The types of assertions Rota chides -- must have a closed form solution, composed strictly of non-infinite, occasionally wonderfully simple solutions, and asserting that they must exist through deductive route -- all hallmarks. I thought pure mathematics was over?
- t6jvcereio 4y agoWhy are we teaching sums and multiplications? After all, computers can do that these days. /s The complaint that we're teaching something that we never see in engineering, like homogeneous equations is preposterous. It's like saying why teach fractions when in engineering you always see reals. If you want more advanced differencing equations, you can do a more advanced course or self study more advanced material. I have a guy in my company who has a PhD in a very niche topic in differential equations and he can actually solve real world differential equations.
- CamperBob2 4y agoArguably the emphasis on fractions in primary education should have gone away as soon as calculators became common. They are pretty useless except in a few special cases. Put another way: if we had had calculators all along, and someone had recently proposed teaching fractions as important ways to represent (some) real numbers, would that idea have gotten any traction at all in pedagogical circles? I don't see how.
- t6jvcereio 4y agoOh my. I'd rather tell myself that you're trolling, than lose my last scraps of faith in humanity.
- CamperBob2 4y agoWhat would be a good argument against the point that we wouldn't bother teaching fractions if calculators had always existed? Math education is worse than religion when it comes to blind adherence to tradition. A lot of kids who learn calculus in high school should be learning statistics instead, for instance. And a lot of time in engineering school is wasted on worthless analytic techniques that should be spent on numerical methods that the student will actually use. Never mind the holy wars about how linear algebra should be taught. Compared to the ferocity of these debates, fractions seem like low-hanging fruit with few arguments in their defense. Classroom time is limited, so we need to make every minute count.
- steppi 4y agoFor anyone who was subjected to the standard intro ordinary differential equations (ODEs) course and left unenlightened, I’d highly recommend Vladimir Arnold’s book on the subject [1]. It gives a lot of insight into the underlying geometry and can be read profitably by anyone comfortable with Calculus I-III and undergraduate Linear Algebra, and who took intro ODE. It wasn’t until I worked through this that I really got and appreciated ODEs. [1] https://loshijosdelagrange.files.wordpress.com/2013/04/vladimir-i-arnold-vladimir-i-arnold-roger-cooke-ordinary-differential-equations-1992.pdf https://loshijosdelagrange.files.wordpress.com/2013/04/vladi...
- grog454 4y agoI was fortunate to have problem solving based DiffEQ classes as a freshman, and my prior experience in programming meshed well with differential equations. My first published Android app was a differential equation visualizer: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=simplicial.software.Systems https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=simplicial.sof...
- greesil 4y agoThe author is spot on. Linear systems show up everywhere from EE to controls. I've never ever ever had to use a Wronskian, ode with non constant coefficients. Separation of variables is also a fundamental. The only thing I disagree with is what he says about Bessel functions, it's nice to have some exposure to them.
- aj7 4y agoI took 18.034 at MIT, just like all Physics majors. It was absurd, stupid, and the most boring class I ever had. So after the first 3 classes, I never went. Two weeks before the final, I holed up in the Student Center Library and did all the problems. I got like 60 on the final, but the average was 40 so I aced the course. It was criminal (I am less diplomatic than Rota, who by the way, I had had for 18.02, the previous course) not to emphasize differential equations with constant coefficients. I had to take the graduate course in signals and systems (from the famous Communist Jack Kurzweil, no less) at San Jose State to fix this deficiency. After 35 years as a an optics and laser engineer (but most successfully as a salesman), here is what I would teach: 1. LDE’S w constant coefficients, up to systems, poles and zeroes, with the last week on simple control systems and the last lecture on “e to a matrix.” 10 weeks of a 15 week course. I should add that almost every really successful experimental physicist I have known has had to build a control system from scratch to solve a critical problem in his rig. 2. Numerical methods of solution especially Runge Kutta integration. Most scientists and engineers will encounter at least one situation where the company tools won’t be trickable into providing a solution. 3. If there is any time left, or perhaps in an honors class, do something with the Schrodinger equation.
- salomon812 4y agoI loved my differential equation course, and it was a community college course I took senior year of high school. One of the chapters in the book was using diff eqs to solve physical systems and it was an eye opening experience. For a hobby project, I'm writing a video game that requires some unusual behaviors so an off-the-shelf physics library won't cut it, I have to roll my own and most of the math I'm using is directly from that course. One additional note, the author mentions not being able to motivate the Laplace transform. The Laplace transform is really critical when designing robotic control systems. It's to the point that in diagrams, one usually draws "1/s" instead of an integral sign.
- BeetleB 4y ago> The Laplace transform is really critical when designing robotic control systems. It's used all over engineering, but its usage doesn't suggest how Laplace magically came up with it.
- atakan_gurkan 4y agoI really would like to learn Rota's thoughts on Arnold's book on ODEs. I love that book, but I cannot recommend it easily since it has little overlap with our undergraduate curriculum DE course (in a physics department).
- jl2718 4y agoI hated this course, and later taught it at Stanford after enough years of real engineering that I didn’t even remember the topics. By that time I had developed my own way of doing everything: linear algebra notation, ODE and PDE solvers, etc. If you start with the solver, it makes more sense. For instance: let’s say you have something like a driven heat equation in front of you. It is a second-order mess, foreign and unrecognizable. Now discretize it. It becomes stupidly obvious: change in heat occurs at a rate proportional to the sum of differences with the neighbors. Okay, now I get it, and I can write out the solver iteration. How can you speed up the solution? Convolution. Derive that kernel from your solver iteration. We can also do that in a transformed space like Fourier. Okay so, now let’s transform the original equations and then use some magic tricks to simplify. Wow, look how much faster our solution is! Does it give the same result as our simple simulator? Great, now we know why we’re learning this.
- JustSomeNobody 4y agoI loved diffy-q. It made the math real for me, much like physics did. It was still a hard course, but worth it. Now, if only I remembered some of it...
- barkingcat 4y agoI failed my university differential equations course :D I did a lot of homework, but none of it "stuck" and most of my classmates were just memorizing everything which didn't work for me. The pedagogy needed to be updated for sure.
- bikenaga 4y agoPeople have mentioned the use of differential notation in differential equations. It's confusing. In teaching calculus we still use both the prime/Newton notation (y', y", and so on) and the fraction/Leibniz notation ("dy/dx", etc.) for derivatives. They're both useful for writing and for visualizing how things work, and both are used outside math (e.g. in physics and engineering). "dy/dx" was originally thought of as the quotient of two infinitesimal quantities --- arbitrarily small but (not necessarily) zero. Limits became accepted as the foundation for calculus, and infinitesimals were regarded as heuristic or non-rigorous. But if you're careful, "you can get the right answers", and Abraham Robinson's discovery of nonstandard analysis (around 1950 - 1960) showed that infinitesimals could be put on a rigorous basis. Besides Robinson's "Non-standard Analysis" and Jerome Keisler's (now free) calculus book someone else mentioned (and the supplement which provides a lot of the theory), people who are interested in this can check out "Infinitesimal Calculus" by James Henle and Eugene Kleinberg (https://store.doverpublications.com/0486428869.html https://store.doverpublications.com/0486428869.html - a short introduction) or "Applied Nonstandard Analysis" by Martin Davis (https://store.doverpublications.com/0486442292.html https://store.doverpublications.com/0486442292.html - it starts with the logic and set theory and like Keisler's supplement is fairly theoretical). Why aren't infinitesimals used in teaching calculus? After all, we can now make them rigorous, and the notation fits well with differential forms, which are used in differential geometry. Keisler's book (which I think came out in the 1970s) was an otherwise traditional calc book which made the attempt, but there is just too much inertia behind the limits approach. Some people were bothered also by the fact that infinitesimals are definitely non-constructive; the Bulletin of the American Math Society oddly had Errett Bishop, a noted constructivist, review Keisler's book when it came out, and the review was not very positive. (I don't know why they picked him as a reviewer.) But there's still a problem - you're defining the derivative as a limit of difference quotients, but it sure looks like a fraction. What to do? Calc books often fudge this in the following way. They define the derivative f'(x) (note the prime notation) as the limit of [f(x + h) - f(x)]/h as h goes to 0. Then "dx" is regarded as synonomous with "Δx", and both are considered to be simply increments/changes in x --- no infinitesimals. (So, e.g., dx could be 0.3.) Then you define dy to be f'(x) dx., so of course dy/dx = f'(x). In this interpretation, "dy" and "dx" are increments in y and x as you move along the tangent line to the curve. Rather than refer to these as "differentials", calc books will often put this in a section called "linear approximation", which usefully discusses using the tangent line to a curve to approximate the curve. I think it's good to bring up this history in calc courses - I always tried to. Math is rigorous and proceeds according to logic (that's the aspiration, anyway), but the way math develops and is taught is a social thing.
- Syzygies 4y agoSo, what's interesting about differential equations for someone who doesn't find analysis or physics particularly compelling? Say, a computer scientist with a greater love for discrete math? Linear differential equations are a great introduction to eigenvalues. There's a chicken-and-egg problem understanding this, and it would be helpful to take ODEs and Linear Algebra together. As I first read in Feller, generating functions are a formation that runs the full length of mathematics and beyond; the Laplace transform from ODEs is just a continuous version of a generating function. As Marcel-Paul Schützenberger first made clear, the notions of "rational" and "algebraic" from pure mathematics match up with finite state machines and push-down automata from computer science. One studies these most easily using generating functions. As Richard Stanley explains in Enumerative Combinatorics Vol. 2, there's a third class of generating functions beyond algebraic: D-Finite. Roughly, this corresponds to how one learns to expand the solution to a differential equation in ODEs as a power series. The true significance of this class in both pure mathematics and computer science is poorly understood, but there's something clearly out there as significant as rational and algebraic. That is intrinsically fascinating. When I see someone filling a blackboard with equations, I see someone flailing because they don't know what to do. The best math is simple, and can be expressed as philosophy, like recognizing this formation crossing the sky.