9 ms·
I personally would love to see Wikipedia sell ads. Nothing crazy, just one subtle and tasteful text ad per page, sold by auction. (The ads would be much small
by nostromo 15y ago
I personally would love to see Wikipedia sell ads. Nothing crazy, just one subtle and tasteful text ad per page, sold by auction. (The ads would be much smaller and more relevant than "a personal appeal from Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales".)
The revenue could allow Wikipedia to take on ambitious projects to further its mission statement, similar to the Mozilla Foundation or NPR.
Unlike most publishers, Wikipedia doesn't need to worry about maintaining a firewall between sales and editorial -- so I think it's a natural fit.
- blinkingled 15y agoThis makes total sense. After all the personal appeal is an ad. Much better to have non-intrusive ads that people might even find useful in some cases.
- simonbrown 15y agoWhy wouldn't they need to worry about advertisers having control over content? A big client would still have a lot of leverage.
- nupark2 15y agoAs someone who very much values the clarity of content without the insidious distraction of advertisements, I would not like to see Wikipedia sell ads. I would rather that they either continue to work through donations, or figure out how to sell their content directly. Ultimately, I think the use of advertising as a proxy mechanism for charging customers is an inefficient historical fall-out of the constraints of magazines, television, and the web. Any use of advertisement to fund modern digital distribution is indicative of one of two things: - A failure find a less round-about, more efficient, and more profitable mechanism for directly charging consumers for what they consume OR - A lack of respect for the customer and an attempt to maximize profit at the expense of their enjoyment of your product. I do not subscribe to Hulu for this reason.
- maximusprime 15y agoYou're an outlier. Most people don't mind ads.
- philwelch 15y agoThe enduring popularity of DVR and Adblock suggest differently.
- rfergie 15y agoMost people do not use Adblock. Although that might be different if everyone knew about it
- maximusprime 15y agoMost people click on ads. Most people buy things based on ads. I'm inclined to think that this means most people find advertising useful, so I'm skeptical that people would want to block advertising if they could. Also it's kind of an antisocial thing to do, depriving free websites of income.
- philwelch 15y ago"Most", or just enough to keep advertising a sustainable business, like spam email? Services like Spotify and Pandora actually make money from people paying them for an ad-free experience. I think you'd be hard pressed to find someone who actually likes most advertising, as opposed to simply tolerating it as a means to an end. If anything it's antisocial for websites to promise me valuable content, only to resell my attention to advertisers.
- TeMPOraL 15y ago> Most people click on ads. Never met one. > Also it's kind of an antisocial thing to do, depriving free websites of income. Personally, it saddens me that we have to put up with all this electricity-wasting advertising crap in order to have free websites. It seems that one of the most useful tools of humanity needs to look ugly just in order to stay alive. I'd be very happy if we ever find a better solution.
- joebadmo 15y agoI disagree. Ads can be detrimental, sure, but they're also in many ways complementary to digital, frictionless distribution. For example, ads encourage sharing. With a paid product, you have to gate access. But then there's a sort of implicit conflict between wanting as many consumers as possible, but wanting to get paid. And especially because it's hard to know the quality of digital media without consuming it, it's hard to know whether it's worth paying for. So there's a ton of friction. That barrier to entry stops virality cold, which limits distribution, and also revenue. There are ways to do ads well. Google is the obvious example. Highly relevant, not particularly distracting, and take advantage of the intentionality of the searcher. I think ads are a naturally better revenue stream for digital content. Not to say that they can't or won't be abused.
- officemonkey 15y agoIf the Wikipedia Foundation can cover their costs by donations from users, than I would resist ads forever. >There are ways to do ads well. Yes there are, And Wikipedia would have to pay gatekeepers to prevent it becoming a spammy "wack-a-mole" fest. Those gatekeepers become a very costly additional expense. One that you very quickly become dependent on, Wikipedia has already grown into a great resource from donations. If they can maintain solvency, I don't see any compelling reason why they should change.
- ceejayoz 15y ago> Yes there are, And Wikipedia would have to pay gatekeepers to prevent it becoming a spammy "wack-a-mole" fest. Those gatekeepers become a very costly additional expense. One that you very quickly become dependent on, Only if they want to sell lots of different ads. If it were "buy the one ad slot on Wikipedia for a day for $150k" (that's supposedly the going rate for Twitter's promoted tweets, IIRC), quality control wouldn't be very hard.
- jwdunne 15y agoI think this would work well just for the homepage and nothing else. The main issue I have is an irrelevant ad plastered across every page would be pretty tacky. Having relevant ads on article pages would work better but there are a few problems with that: a) Each article isn't of equal value in terms of advertising, which would make pricing much more complicated, which would also increase costs involved. b) Pages (or whole topics) with rented ad space could be subject to spammy tactics to increase the amount of visitors, such as dubious SEO techniques (the Wikipedia domain would make this easy). I haven't thought about this deeply enough but it could be a huge problem since it can't really be controlled.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- koko775 15y ago> - A lack of respect for the customer and an attempt to maximize profit at the expense of their enjoyment of your product. I do not subscribe to Hulu for this reason. As someone who works for a different video streaming site (that also has legal content licenses), your ire may be misplaced. Rather than a lack of respect for the customer there's a very likely possibility that the ads must be shown, even for subscribers, due to licensing agreements.
- ggwicz 15y agoAny use of advertisement to fund modern digital distribution is indicative of one of two things: - A failure find a less round-about, more efficient, and more profitable mechanism for directly charging consumers for what they consume OR - A lack of respect for the customer and an attempt to maximize profit at the expense of their enjoyment of your product. I do not subscribe to Hulu for this reason. I think it's more indicative of a website trying to pay its bills. A lot of assholes ruin their content with ads, for sure. A simple text ad or one, small ad, like a Deck Network ad for example, would hardly be so damaging.
- therandomguy 15y agoI get the following services for free: News, eMail, Search, Docs in cloud, Blogging, Video distribution, Maps etc. I will take the ads. Thanks.
- halo 15y agoI completely agree. I've long thought that Wikipedia should sell ads or have commercial partnerships. Another idea is partnering with a search engine. Add "Search for X on Google/Bing" to their search drop-downs and add a tasteful "Search in Google/Bing" on each article plus the search landing page. This wouldn't be very intrusive, many users would find it useful, and it's hugely valuable for the search engines. It seems like such a missed opportunity. The additional money raised could be used in so many ways: investing in full-time researchers and fact-checkers, having full-time photographers, creating teaching materials, or freeing up copyrighted content. Content, afterall, is their core competency. Wikimedia could be the Google of content if only it had the leadership and ambition.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoI think there would be a fairly strong uproar if they started making money off people's donated time and energy. The dynamic would change considerably.
- halo 15y agoWikimedia is a not-for-profit. As long as they use the income to achieve their goals, I don't see why it's a problem. People don't seem to have any objection to commercialisation of open source software. The great things they could do with extra income are endless.
- ErrantX 15y agoTo be honest; the Foundation doesn't spend money particularly efficiently. And I don't think that now is a good time for them to end up with potentially limitless amounts of cash. I know it has been 10 years; but for various reasons the Foundation still isn't 100% there on the organisational level. Particularly on things like communications. The also spend a lot more than they probably should (for example; the budget for next year is something like $25 Million). That's not a criticism; things are still at the "investment" stage - where the Foundation/community are figuring out what to spend, where to spend it and how to do outreach. So I don't think having ads, and a flood of money, would work well at this stage (or, rather, work effectively). However; the biggest hurdle to ads on Wikipedia has nothing to do with perception or economics - it is simply that the community consistently rejects the idea. And the community has pretty strong autonomy :)
- quanticle 15y agoHaving Wikipedia sell ads would lead to insidious conflicts of interest. How do you know that they're not censoring edits to make articles reflect more positively on a company with which they have a commercial relationship? It is possible to remove edits in a way that makes the diffs inaccessible. Currently, such power is used in a tiny minority of cases (e.g. personally identifying information). If Wikipedia entered into commercial partnerships with advertisers there would be great pressure to use those tools in a non-neutral fashion.
- halo 15y agoBut how do you know Google isn't doing the same thing for its advertisers?
- loire280 15y agoIt seems unlikely that the type of people who shepherd Wikipedia pages in their free time would fail to notice and immediately report that type of censorship. The proof would be unnecessary - even the implication that Wikipedia was tampering with the content of its pages would have a huge effect on its reputation.
- VMG 15y agoStill, writing factually correct and positive things about a company or advertiser becomes unnecessarily suspicious.
- loire280 15y agoThis isn't an unusual dilemma in publishing - print or online. If for-profit companies can adequately maintain editorial integrity despite pressure from ad partners, I think an ideological non-profit like Wikipedia can manage.
- eCa 15y agoI am not convinced that for-profit companies can.
- bethling 15y agoAlthough it's probably correct that ads wouldn't impact the content/bias of Wikipedia articles, I think a portion (at least) of the success is that it's clear that there isn't any such interference by corporations on the editorial content of the site. The moment you bring ads into the picture at least a portion of the internet will start to wonder about that. There are a lot of cynical (or realistic - depending on your point of view :) people out there who have seen people/sites/whatever chasing money change the direction and feel of a website. I'd much rather deal with Jimmy Wales' pleas every so often than to wonder if maybe [insert sponsoring entity here] had some role of changing the tone/content/whatever of a given article.
- jimkogs 15y agoNever.
- Tycho 15y agoAds would be a shame I think, but maybe they could have a sponsor. Just in the bottom right corner of the Wikipedia icon, it would say 'sponsored by ____'. I mean that's not too obtrusive but would surely bring in a lot of money. Football teams get £20m a season to put a name on their shirt so...
- wanorris 15y agoBetter yet, at least in the US there's a long history of non-commercial media like PBS (public television) and National Public Radio mentioning sponsors in exactly this sort of way, and no one objects, so the resistance should be pretty low.
- graysnorf 15y agoHow do you know that "no one objects"? Perhaps those that object simply don't listen to NPR.
- digamber_kamat 15y agoWikipedia is not a profit making organization and their commitment to keep the content free and accessible is admirable. Once I start earning I will donate lot more to them. I will be happy to see them not having advertisements.
- ticks 15y agoBeing a not-for-profit doesn't mean no adverts. If they went down the advert road, they could pull the ads as soon as their yearly budget is met.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- rorrr 15y agoSeriously, if wikipedia just put adsense ads, they would make $500K in a few minutes probably. Way better than that huge begging sign on every page.
- ugh 15y agoThe main barrier for this are Wikipedia’s authors and editors. Many would feel that Wikimedia is trying to make money off their work – no matter whether that’s a justified view or not. Wikipedia risks alienating large numbers of their authors and editors if they introduce ads. The Wikipedia authors and editors I have heard speak about this topic seem to be strongly opposed to any kind of commercialization and ads. Writing for Wikipedia is not always fun and sometimes tedious and annoying work. I don’t think Wikipedia can afford to ignore their authors and editors or risk losing them. It’s not like they have to do any work for Wikipedia and it seems like many are doing it for idealistic reasons. For that reason alone I don’t think it’s very likely that there will ever be ads on Wikipedia. Wikimedia would have to try very hard to win over as many authors and editors as possible beforehand and would probably also have to give them a lot of say in how ads are implemented and how Wikimedia is run (I think many would demand absolute transparency from Wikimedia and that they justify any and all spending in detail). Another way to bring ads to Wikipedia might be some sort of grass roots movement from the community. I, however, don’t see anyone who would be willing to start such a movement and I also don’t see how such a movement could win over large numbers. Wikipedia’s relatively federal structure would certainly allow for interesting experiments. It would be nice to test ads in some smaller Wiki, maybe the Russian or Spanish Wikipedia. That would be a lot more responsible than just introducing ads everywhere. But political pressures inside Wikipedia would require a political genius when it comes to actually implementing that.
- wololo 15y agomaybe not Spanish: http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2011-01/20/wikipedia-spanish-fork?page=all http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2011-01/20/wikipedia-spa...
- larrys 15y agoAgree. Even pbs.org (broadcast) which works with donations from individuals and foundations typically does a pre-roll before any show touting the donors. And I've seen things that border on mini ads on certain shows as well for certain donors. They are not just a logo but convey a message with some video. (Sorry I don't couldn't find links to examples). Additionally, they sell items off their website which have nothing to do with repackaging their content: http://pbskidstoys.shop.pbskids.org/ http://pbskidstoys.shop.pbskids.org/ http://pbskidstoys.shop.pbskids.org/school-supplies/back-to-.. http://pbskidstoys.shop.pbskids.org/school-supplies/back-to-.... Here's a page with an ad for "argosy university" which says "support provided by". The logos for the major funders appear in the bottom right of the same page (this is what is typically done in a pre-roll). I'm pretty sure the reason that Argosy does this is for ad value. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/elegant/ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/elegant/ While certainly appearing more tasteful than typical ads there is still ad value that these companies receive for their donations and support.
- kalleboo 15y agoPBS is a bad example since they're now selling advertising in everything but name. Their "sponsor messages" mention a specific product and a slogan, and they also sell messages targeted to specific shows (such as you'll find news/documentaries on high speed rail sponsored by Siemens). PBS have even started producing 30 second ads they run[1] 1 http://www.mediapost.com/publications/article/161440/pbs-produces-documentary-ads.html http://www.mediapost.com/publications/article/161440/pbs-pro...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- 3dFlatLander 15y agoA more unobtrusive idea I've wanted to suggest to them would be to use amazon/otherStore affiliate links for their book pages http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:BookSources/1453606122 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:BookSources/1453606122
- tomkarlo 15y agoOne aspect of ads you're ignoring is how they spread the cost of using a product: whereas charging a fee impacts all users equally, ads will generally impact users relative to their income / spending habits. It strikes me that for Wikipedia, that is more compatible with their objectives than a set per-user fee. I'm haven't thought of many reasons to like ads over they years, but this is one.
- p4bl0 15y agoIt has already been said why some people, including me, think that ads on Wikipedia would be a (very) bad things so I want tell why again. But something which is obvious to me hasn't been said: I think that Wikipedia should be part of the UNESCO's World Heritage and as such be financed with public fund by the United Nations. Given what Wikipedia is, I really wouldn't mind (actually I would be very happy) if governments had to give the project enough money to do whatever the Wikimedia Foundation needs to do. I would prefer our taxes money helping Wikipedia rather than helping banks and other thiefs.
- pajju 15y agoIf they start selling ads, google is gonna buy them!
- k_bx 15y agoWikipedia could sold ads on articles like "antivirus software", or "ocr software", or "photocameras". Hell, I even WANT to see ads on pages like this.