5 ms·
Like a few other people in this post, I generally support the idea but find the implementation details and the political climate to be iminicable to rapid progr
by dekhn 4y ago
Like a few other people in this post, I generally support the idea but find the implementation details and the political climate to be iminicable to rapid progress, which, given the extraordinary cost associated with the project, makes one truly wonder if it will ever be completed.
I'm also curious what it will look like in detail for the HSR to share the Caltrain corridor. I live about 1 mile away and every night, I can hear the existing diesel (which are transitioning to electric https://www.caltrain.com/projects/electrification/electric-trains https://www.caltrain.com/projects/electrification/electric-t...) Caltrains lumbering along once the freeway noise quiets down. It's not the engines so much as the horns- the horns are very loud and some drivers hold them down for long periods.
There are several areas along the way where people are regularly hit by the train (there are level crossings https://www.caltrain.com/projects/grade-crossing-improvement-project-2021 https://www.caltrain.com/projects/grade-crossing-improvement...). i struggle to imagine precisely how Caltrain will share this with a high speed rail service, even with fixing all the remaining level crossings. There isn't room to add more track.
The one time I saw really quick construction was after a truck burned in the Macarthur Maze and caused a section of overpass to collapse. The contractor for that one managed to expedite the process... significantly
https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/A-MAZE-ING-His-reputation-on-the-line-2592154.php https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/A-MAZE-ING-His-reputa...
- tomByrer 4y agoI live in Kansas City, full of rail lines in many directions. Lived near rail lines most my time here. I think horns are sometimes used to warn homeless around corners.
- foolfoolz 4y agothe proposal is to use electric trains on caltrain tracks. they allegedly will run at 110mph which i bet is loud, roughly 40mph more than caltrain today. the horns are getting better with grade separation and stations that don’t have crossings. they are very loud. you can hear them all the time. HSR will add 4 more trains per hour, which means a lot more train horns. hopefully more grade separation is done by then. i can’t imagine any city surviving without it. there was a study done by caltrain about this and some crossings are blocked 20% of the time during peak hours today - and they want to increase train count by like 30%
- kccqzy 4y agoSunnyvale recently told residents that without grade separation, they expect in the future that during a peak hour, up to 24 minutes of that would be crossing gate down time. https://www.sunnyvale.ca.gov/home/showpublisheddocument/3570/637920840156570000 https://www.sunnyvale.ca.gov/home/showpublisheddocument/3570...
- foolfoolz 4y agopage 21 here has all the crossings and how many minutes they are down per hour https://caltrain2040.org/wp-content/uploads/CBP_April_LPMG_Presentation.pdf https://caltrain2040.org/wp-content/uploads/CBP_April_LPMG_P...
- 7952 4y agoI live near a track that was converted a few years ago and runs at 125mph. It is very very quiet and barely noticeable even when you are close. There is no engine noise like you get on diesels.
- bombcar 4y agoEven electric trains will be horny - it’s required by federal law. But with work you can convert a crossing to no horn. https://railroads.dot.gov/highway-rail-crossing-and-trespasser-programs/train-horn-rulequiet-zones/train-horn-rule-and-quiet https://railroads.dot.gov/highway-rail-crossing-and-trespass... Of course the easy solution is to raise the rails or lower the road
- dekhn 4y agohere is the ongoing saga https://www.cityofsanmateo.org/2279/Train-Horn-Noise https://www.cityofsanmateo.org/2279/Train-Horn-Noise
- isx726552 4y agoThat page is out of date — the crossing at 25th has already been rebuilt to no longer be at-grade.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- inferiorhuman 4y agoYou're right, but: Caltrain is being electrified in order to make the track compatible with HSR. HSR precludes at grade crossing where you'd need to use a horn. Ergo Caltrain is eliminating the at grade crossings as part of electrification and the electric trains will be quieter than the diesels service of yore. In the North Bay, SMART (which is anything but) applied for and got an exemption for quiet crossings in some spots. HSR is a good idea that's messy and complex because everyone wants a say. SMART is a great example of America proving that Americans don't want rail transit. It's the Pontiac Fiero of transit.
- sjsamson 4y agoCaltrain electrification project is independent/notdependent on CAHSR and also not dependent on grade separation projects, which seem to be tackled individually/ad-hoc in partnership with the city it's in. Everything I've seen suggests Caltrain will still have at grade crossings for the foreseeable future due to the high cost of grade separations (hundreds of millions each), while overhead electrification is slowly approaching completion including over existing at-grade crossings. Nothing prevents a high speed train from using an at grade crossing, albeit at appropriate speeds. While it would be nice for CalTrain (and most rail crossings) to be fully grade separated, it's incredibly expensive, doesn't add much value for rail users as the train already has the right of way, and it primarily benefits auto traffic. It only makes sense if road money pays for it, rather than more limited rail money.
- MarkSweep 4y agoAccording to their Noise and Vibration section of the report, their plan for horn noise is to assist cities with setting up quiet zones. A child comment mentioned this possibility. Exactly what that means is unclear. Search for NV-MM#4 in this document: https://hsr.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/Final_EIRS_FJ_V1-12_CH_3.4_Noise_Vibration.pdf https://hsr.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/Final_EIRS_FJ_...
- jeffbee 4y agoWith respect to "extraordinary cost" I direct your attention to the new, $600 million, less than one mile 6th Street Viaduct that L.A. just built, which just opened but they had to immediately close. That is a boondoggle. I also direct your attention to the east span of the Bay Bridge, which came in 800% over budget and 25 years late. But oddly the yammering nerd army never discusses the monumental failures of car infrastructure.
- baggy_trough 4y agoThe United States is uniquely incompetent at developing all manner of infrastructure.