4 ms·
I agree, but I see why they don’t want to skim the mortgages that could be paid off in a lump sum off the top of their bucket of dodgy loans. I’d love to see t
by hedora 4y ago
I agree, but I see why they don’t want to skim the mortgages that could be paid off in a lump sum off the top of their bucket of dodgy loans.
I’d love to see the law change to force owners of debt to give the person that owes right of first refusal whenever debt is sold. (Mostly for medical debt and collections agency situations, but also for mortgages.)
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThat makes no sense. A borrower would have incentive to default on the debt, so they can then purchase it at less than face value, effectively causing them to experience a gain and the lender to experience a loss. Why would anyone choose to lend under such terms?
- Volundr 4y agoThis could easily be addressed by simply not offering the option to someone in default, but even without doing that, I don't think your assertion makes sense. Not paying my mortgage on the idea that my bank will go brankrupt before they are able to reposses my house is a HUGE gamble. I doubt my monthly payment has any meaningful impact on my banks bottom line.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIf I understood correctly, the proposition was to give borrowers the first right of refusal when a lender sells the debt, which can and does happen all the time without a lender going bankrupt.
- namelessoracle 4y agoSure, but the "value" of the mortgage is supposed to be that it represents twice (usually way more) of value in interest payments that the Debtor will pay over the life time. So why is the bank selling it for sometimes half of what the Debtor owes then on a fire sale scenario where the holder is having issues? One of the big problems that happens a lot with mortgages is that the bank sells it to this other bank and mix ups can cause all kind of problems for the debt holder. Give the debtor right of first refusal at price they are about to sell (simple form letter that they have 30 days to respond to). 9 times out of 10, debtor just lets it happen. But what WILL happen is a company will come along, offer what are basically refinance loans to service this situation, and the debtor gets helped out. The whole practice of tranching is toxic to begin with and if this discourages that its a double win.
- nradov 4y agoNo that's a terrible idea which would damage the mortgage market. Your scenario is unrealistic. Mortgages aren't actually sold at "fire sale" prices unless the borrower has already defaulted and the value of the property has significantly declined. A debtor in default is unlikely to be able to refinance, even for a slightly lower balance. Mix ups with selling mortgages or servicing rights do occasionally occur but they are rare and impact relatively few borrowers.
- conductr 4y agoA debt holder can typically pay off their debt any time they want. I think what you're proposing is to pass along the discounted price to the debt holder. Eg. if the lender is going bankrupt and selling the debt for 30% of it's value, they should offer that purchase price to the debtor? There's really nothing prohibiting them from doing that, I don't see why a law needs to be changed for this to start taking place. It's just not a norm in business because bankruptcies and liquidations are easier/faster to conduct if you can move the assets in a single/few transactions. It also encourages default from the borrowing side.
- idiotsecant 4y ago>There's really nothing prohibiting them from doing that, I don't see why a law needs to be changed for this to start taking place. That's exactly the point. There is nothing prohibiting them from doing that but they don't do it anyway because it makes life a little more difficult for them while making like substantially more difficult for the debt holder. Parent post is suggesting enforcing an inversion of that dynamic - put more power in the hands of the debt holder and less in the hands of the debt owner. A law is absolutely required to overcome the natural incentives at play, if that is the goal.
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoIt makes life a LOT more difficult for the company. Even setting aside the administrative hassle, imagine how this works in practice. All the debtors who are paying attention and have money pay off their loans at a discount. The loans that remain are the worst of the worst, and they fetch an even lower price in bankruptcy.
- bombcar 4y agoExactly. The same thing already happens at 100% value with refinancing (example: all those with good credit can refinance their student loans with the companies that popped up, those who are likely to default can't).
- liber8 4y ago
- mikkergp 4y agoWouldn't this create a weird incentive to create coops to try and bankrupt small lenders by collectively refusing to pay your mortgage?