4 ms·
I can't bear the ideological stench. https://panamaupclose.com/2020/05/25/farmers-learn-not-to-slash-and-burn/ https://panamaupclose.com/2020/05/25/farmers-lea
by imtringued 4y ago
I can't bear the ideological stench.
https://panamaupclose.com/2020/05/25/farmers-learn-not-to-slash-and-burn/ https://panamaupclose.com/2020/05/25/farmers-learn-not-to-sl...
This entire article is about abandoning traditional methods and replacing them with organic agriculture.
You're just creating a straw man to defeat when your original position doesn't even make sense.
Continuous no till, cover cropping, crop rotation, managing mycorrhizal fungi and things like system of rice intensification are hardly traditional and they are also orthogonal whether they are used for organic farming or not but they massively reduce the need for synthetic inputs. This rubs a lot of people proud of conventional agriculture the wrong way because it means their products are really just there to take a shortcut to save money in the short term. The fact that these newer practices are trying to work by understanding the plants and the entire ecosystem you are building rather than treating them as a blackbox which need specific inputs and the recipe is done. Imagine doing something for 30 years and then some new guy comes along and uses a new method that reduces his yields by -10% but saves him expensive inputs and thus results in greater profit while his soil gets better every year and the conventional farmer's soil gets worse. This is particularly annoying to the Bill Gates types who think they are some sort of Messiah because they have a lot of money and push people around.
- upsidesinclude 4y agoI think it be great if you repost this as a direct submission and not below another comment. Forest for the trees with these things...
- Turing_Machine 4y ago> I can't bear the ideological stench. What you call "ideological stench" others call "facts". None of these "newer practices" are responsible for the increase in forest cover in the United States over the past century. None of them are responsible for this: https://www.agry.purdue.edu/ext/corn/news/timeless/images/US_Corn_Yld_Trend.png https://www.agry.purdue.edu/ext/corn/news/timeless/images/US... Also, facts (such as the one in the image linked immediately above) don't cease being facts just because you mod them down. Before modern agriculture, just about every area could count on having a famine every few years. That doesn't happen any more, except in areas where the government is fucked up. And it wasn't "organic farming" that did it. The "organic" bullshit is a gigantic scam aimed at extracting money from rich First-Worlders at the expense of raising food prices for the impoverished.