3 ms·
> if you don't have an AML system that works, and your system is used for anything the government can prove would've been stopped by AML and should have been st
by matheusmoreira 4y ago
> if you don't have an AML system that works, and your system is used for anything the government can prove would've been stopped by AML and should have been stopped by AML, it is incompatible, in principle, with the US dollar
Yeah, and I think it's really interesting how widely accepted this stuff is. I mean, it's literally the financial version of global mass surveillance. Governments gotta know every single transaction that's ever happened because reasons, and if anything bad happens and it turns out someone's lack of total surveillance and record keeping of everyone they ever dealt with somehow helped it happen, well...
Sometimes it feels like people don't realize how tyrannical and dystopian that is. Like money laundering is some unbelievably evil crime that makes it okay for the government to surveil everything in hopes of stopping it.
- jimcavel888 4y ago
- Nursie 4y agoMoney laundering is evil. Sorry, this weird obsession people have with "Muh financial privacy" and "I'm just moving it around, that ain't a crime!" is the outlier here. Should the government be handed every transaction on a silver platter every day? Probably not, but I don't think you'll find many people in the big wide world agreeing that financial activity should be forever unavailable to governments, courts or anything else, even under applicable warrant, which is what these services provide. And why is this absolute privacy bad? Where to start? Criminals hiding ill-gotten gains is only a small part of it. We have the funding of rogue nation states and enabling of ransomware, which is roughly in the same ballpark, sure, but very harmful. Then we have straight-out tax evasion. We also have dictators and despots who plunder their countries and enrich themselves. Should their activities be private? Should we just allow them to siphon money off to other countries and live the high life while their population suffer? It happens all too often already, but in much of the west now we are catching this stuff and denying them those things because we can see some of what's gone on. And what about our own democracy? Absolute financial privacy can allow wealthy interests to brazenly buy politicians, with guarantees of untraceability. So no, I don't "realise" how tyrannical and dystopian that is, in fact to me it looks like it helps prevent a variety of forms of dystopia, in which the rich and the corrupt could even more easily and directly buy democracy out from under us. The fact that you can't currently have a system which provides privacy until an authority (such as the court system) demand things be unlocked, well that seems like a problem for cryptocurrency users, not the law.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> Money laundering is evil. Be careful that you do not become even worse in the attempt to fight it. We are all engaged in a politico-technological arms race: government makes laws, people make technology that circumvents them. They must create ever more tyrannical rules in order to stop the latest technology. So what is your limit? How far will this loop continue until either criminals win or people are crushed under a totalitarian government? > Should their activities be private? Should we just allow them to siphon money off to other countries and live the high life while their population suffer? Should governments warrantlessly surveil everyone to prevent such things? Corrupt people getting rich off of taxpayer money sucks but I wouldn't trade away my privacy in order to prevent it. > The fact that you can't currently have a system which provides privacy until an authority (such as the court system) demand things be unlocked Yes, because governments, especially the USA, are notorious for respecting the rights of their own citizens not to be surveilled without reason. Right?
- Nursie 4y ago> So what is your limit? How far will this loop continue until either criminals win or people are crushed under a totalitarian government? Not only is this not my 'limit', I view the incident we are talking about as a very positive move. Traditional finance laws should be enforced in the cryptocurrency space. "But blockchain" is not a good answer to why you shouldn't have to. They aren't even creating any more rules here! They're literally applying the exact same rules that are already applied to everyone else in every other avenue. If cryptocurrency systems can't play by those rules, then that's a cryptocurrency ecosystem problem. > Should governments warrantlessly surveil everyone to prevent such things? You'll note I already explicitly said no to that in the comment you're replying to. You then go on to talk about "muh privacy" in absolute terms as well. This black/white, all/nothing view of the world is part of the problem. I don't think government should be surveilling everyone all the time by default, nor do I think that we should be enabling completely untraceable large-scale money-laundering facilities that can't even be examined under appropriate warrants. There is an entire spectrum of shades of grey between those two. It may even be multi-dimensional, and the entire 'mainstream' financial system lives in there. Presenting it as only one or the other is fallacious. If blockchain systems can't support any sort of middle ground then again, that's a cryptocurrency ecosystem problem. > Yes, because governments... You're making the case for democratic reform here, which I am all for. Democratic reform and democratic oversight. Sounds good.