6 ms·
This will never happen in North America because the existing payments establishment is collectively worth trillions of dollars (think Visa, Mastercard, Paypal,
by paxys 4y ago
This will never happen in North America because the existing payments establishment is collectively worth trillions of dollars (think Visa, Mastercard, Paypal, Square, Stripe, all credit card issuing banks, all smaller second and third degree players) and will be ready to spend a big chunk of it to lobby and keep themselves relevant. Look at the case with tax filings, for example.
The US government will never be permitted to enter a business area and displace existing corporations regardless of whether it makes life easier for citizens or not.
- srhngpr 4y agoThis has existed in Canada for a very long time via Interac e-Transfers and it doesn't cost anything. You can send money instantly from one bank to any other bank. You do this by sending to someone's email or phone number. The recipient can setup auto-deposit so the money is deposited instantly. For this reason, Venmo, Cash App, etc. makes no sense in Canada either.
- 1-more 4y agoZelle is roughly that in the US. Where Venmo is an intermediary that makes money by having your money before you take the extra step to transfer to your bank (for free in 3 days or instantly for a fee), Zelle is bank account to bank account. Transfers with it show up as debit card transactions in my statement, and I can look people up with phone or email.
- mardifoufs 4y agoInterac is not really the same thing. It's much closer to Venmo, but with more integration with your bank. Mostly because not all banks are actually in the interac network and the transfers are between interac accounts, not bank accounts. You can set it up to autodeposit but it's still a "third" party layer more than actual interbank transfers.
- aceofspades19 4y agoWhat Canadian banks are not in the Interac network?
- dan-robertson 4y agoThere are basically easy bank transfers in the U.K. which are almost always very fast but they aren’t used for most payments. You’d use them to transfer between friends/family and paying for something like rent (with a standing order) or moving money between accounts. While the payments industry (ie Mastercard/Visa) is a big one, they do actually provide a service. The cards allow people to buy things on credit (so stores can let people buy things on credit without needing their own collections departments or taking on default risk) and they provide various consumer protection mechanisms (which consumers want even if they won’t care about buying things on credit and paying back the loan over a long time). It also isn’t obvious to me that this market won’t see disruption. There are a lot of BNPL firms trying to get in on it, for example.
- pfranz 4y agoIn the US, I've generally avoided debit cards (but still would recommend them to people who aren't good at budgeting) because while disputes are settled you're missing the money. My brief experience in other European countries is that debit cards are common, but credit cards aren't. I've heard this is because of strict caps on fees, which means few promos and benefits (like the US has). Sweden has a digital p2p service called Swish. Small businesses seemed to prefer it, but was a little annoying because you had to key in the code or use your camera to scan their QR code. This wasn't a huge hassle for sending money to friends. From what another commenter said, the UK requires you to manually key in the sort-code and account number. I can see that preventing adoption for casual purchases. I was never sure of what protections I had around fraud with other payment options. I imagine consumer trust will be difficult to build.
- adventured 4y ago> The US government will never be permitted Then why don't corporations regulate the government, instead of it being the other way around? Why did the minimum corporate tax rate just go up to 15%? Why is there any corporate tax at all? The US government pushes companies around anytime they see fit. They're a superpower with the world's most powerful military, the FBI, CIA, NSA, and dozens of prominent regulatory agencies that control every aspect of the US economy. When they decided to go after Google, guess what happened? The founders of Google immediately ran away in fear. They promptly resigned simultaneously and shrank from view. They knew what would happen and they got out in front of it. When they went after Microsoft, guess what happened? Bill Gates resigned from leading the company that he founded and had been in charge of for a quarter century. The most powerful, richest private citizen in the US gave up control over one of the world's most powerful corporations. The feds are drastically more powerful than any private citizens or corporations. Corporations are run by people, and people are very easy to target and easy to break, especially when you have powers of an epic scale central government. Even a company the size of Apple is barely a spec to the US Government (a government which is currently engaged with Ukraine in smashing the supposed #2 military, Russia, using just a modest flex of its weapons and capabilities). Only China's government comes close to rivaling the US Government for power, corporations are a joke by comparison. If the feds want to implement an instant payment system, then that's exactly what they'll do, whether Visa or PayPal likes it or not.
- squeaky-clean 4y ago> Corporations are run by people, and people are very easy to target and easy to break, especially when you have powers of an epic scale central government. This is true of governments too. Tech lobbyists doesn't sway the people who make up the government that much. But oil, guns, and real estate very much do.
- motbob 4y agoThis pessimism is pretty popular, and it's just wrong. It's not about whether the U.S. government will "displace existing corporations." It's about whether a publicly funded and developed solution to a problem is clearly better than a private solution. Should the U.S. have an official tax preparation system? That would sure save a lot of people a lot of money, but I'm personally grateful for the fact that a bunch of private companies have been spending a lot of dough trying to develop good online tax prep utilities. Self-service tax prep is in a much better place than it was 15 years ago because of the efforts of those private companies. And an official option for tax prep would undercut those efforts. (At this point, of course, it's high time for the IRS to create an official option, and they are moving towards that.) Congress is aware of the above concern. The lawmaking "meta" since the Reagan years is to not undercut the normal operations of a competitive market unless there's a clear reason to. But sometimes there are clear reasons to. That's why we have things like FDA rules that tell companies what can or cannot be labeled as "peanut butter" or "milk chocolate." It's why we strictly regulate the radio spectrum. It's why we have healthy anti-trust, anti-cartel, and anti-foreign-bribery laws. Congress understands traditional examples of market failures and is very interested in fixing them. But the tax prep industry, for example, is not an example of a market failure, so Congress is not excited about getting involved. Getting back to FedNow, creating a standardized payment system to be used throughout the financial industry is a prime example of fixing a market failure: the difficulty of coordination, and the obvious benefit of getting every bank onto the same payment system. So I am not especially pessimistic about the prospects of this system.
- umvi 4y ago> Should the U.S. have an official tax preparation system? That would sure save a lot of people a lot of money, Would it? Seems like a conflict of interest to me. Down the road the government might be tempted to abuse its control of both tax laws and ubiquitous tax preparation software. I think it would be better if: - Tax laws and tax law updates are required to be released in machine-readable format (i.e. JSON) using a machine-parsable protocol (i.e. converted from "English" to "Tax Grammar") - IRS was required to maintain a public API for submitting returns This would lower barrier-to-entry of tax filing software and weaken incumbents' (i.e. Intuit's) lobbying power. Furthermore, IRS is free to build a tool if they want, so long as it is both open source and dogfoods the public API and public tax law data that everyone else has access to.
- snarfy 4y agoThe Federal Reserve is not the US government. It is a private bank.
- daxelrod 4y agoIt's weirder than that. The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve is an agency of the US federal government. The system as a whole has "a combination of public and private characteristics". See the section "The U.S. Approach to Central Banking" of https://www.federalreserve.gov/aboutthefed/structure-federal-reserve-system.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/aboutthefed/structure-federal... .
- stazz1 4y agoThanks for this clarification. I had a hunch it was a weird mix of the two. In reality I'm glad congresspeople don't have a lens into the money printing business.
- astrange 4y agoBut they do. They control the Treasury and US Mint, who are the real money printers. The Fed controls the price of money for everyone else.
- vesinisa 4y agoWhat do you mean by this? As far as I know, the Fed was established by an Act of Congress and it is overseen by a Board of Governors whose members are appointed by the President and report to the Congress. To me it doesn't necessarily seem too different from many other government agencies, the biggest difference being that it is self-funded. Because of its autonomy it doesn't seem to fall well within any of the three classical branches of government, but it sure seems to me like a part of the government nonetheless.
- rufusroflpunch 4y agoI think you’re wrong. The credit card system’s days are numbered. In 5 years I think digital wallets will be common in the US, and it won’t be because of anything the government did except get out of the way.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoWhat is a credit card if not a kind of digital wallet?
- rufusroflpunch 4y agoI'm referring to a payment network outside of credit card rails entirely.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoSure, but most people don't care about that level of detail. Credit cards are essentially "digital" in the sense that most people care about.
- bobthepanda 4y agoI really doubt it. Credit is a fundamentally different system than debit with different use cases. US credit cards have all sorts of attractions for consumers, like cashback or frequent flyer miles. And they‘re still one of the most accessible ways to build credit score history. Credit cards these days are pretty much usable as digital only; all of mine are addable to Apple or Google Pay, and usable at pretty much any contactless pay terminal.
- astrange 4y agoCredit cards are popular because of government regulation, namely that you have better fraud protection on your credit card than your debit card. If they go away it's because their credit product will be replaced by BNPLs, and transactions with trustworthy stores will move to FedNow to avoid that 3%ish interchange fee.
- throw10920 4y ago> will be ready to spend a big chunk of it to lobby and keep themselves relevant Or worse than just lobbying? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32511170 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32511170