3 ms·
Beyond Linear Perspective: Art, Human Vision, and Computer Graphics
- jmiskovic 4y agoThe 3rd presentation (PICTURES, Crafting & Beholding) has some great slides, interesting material.
- pavlov 4y agoIt’s typeset in Comic Sans, presumably as a torture test of the reader’s motivation. The content is worth it! The Hokusai painting (slide 94) with three depth planes reminds me of Shadow of the Beast, an Amiga game that used this kind of parallax scrolling planes very effectively for a feeling of depth and motion.
- bawolff 4y agoThe blog post linked in required reading (https://aaronhertzmann.com/2022/02/28/how-does-perspective-work.html https://aaronhertzmann.com/2022/02/28/how-does-perspective-w... ) was fascinating. It also had the line > Even more confusing, there’s some evidence that people with very different cultural backgrounds may vary in perspective perception in some cases. Which sounds fascinating but they didn't expand.
- lioeters 4y agoThis topic is hard to search for, because the word "perspective" in the abstract sense is commonly used to talk about culture, but almost nothing about "linear perspective". Cultural Differences In Depth Perception - https://www.chegg.com/learn/psychology/introduction-to-psychology/cultural-differences-in-depth-perception#influence-of-culture-in-perception https://www.chegg.com/learn/psychology/introduction-to-psych...: Cultural Differences in the Perception of a Three-Dimensional Ponzo Illusion - https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Cultural-Differences-in-the-Perception-of-a-Ponzo-Brislin-Keating/7a13596aa86337437046f1a4bd3d6a85ed69e8bf https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Cultural-Differences-i... Development of Pictorial Depth Perception: Cross-Cultural Replications - https://www.jstor.org/stable/1128092 https://www.jstor.org/stable/1128092
- dahart 4y agoIt seems likely there could be subjective cultural differences in perception when there are subjective cultural cues in the content/image at hand, while at the same time the biology and physiology of our visual system is human in nature and doesn’t vary culturally, and the geometry and physics of light and perspective is universal. The hard part of any of this research is figuring out how to control for cultural cues in the first place in order to establish what parts are biological and what parts are learned and cultural. It’s easier to search for cultural differences in color perception. There is an ongoing debate about whether differences in color names across languages indicates that cultures perceive colors differently. https://www.sapiens.org/language/color-perception/ https://www.sapiens.org/language/color-perception/ FWIW I was hoping for something explanatory in that Chegg article, but it’s so hand-wavy and disconnected I can’t help but feel like it’s tickling my BS mater, like a lot. It is trying to imply connections between cultural perception and biology, but doesn’t manage to establish anything. A bunch of the sentences use big words but say nothing. The third link you gave, that last paper’s summary point is that they do not find major cultural differences in depth perception. “The absence of marked cultural differences suggests that the phenomena under study may be universal in nature.”
- egypturnash 4y agoLinear perspective is an abstraction. It works great for some scenes but once you get outside of its sweet spot it rapidly falls apart. As an artist, it is very useful to learn so that you get a feeling for how to map the complexities of the 3d world to a 2d plane, and it can be great to lean hard on if you’re doing a lot of work that does fall in that sweet spot, but you’ll need to learn a lot of other kinds of perspective to be able to balance precise rendering, emotional factors, and your deadlines. Curvilinear perspective is generally lacking in digital perspective rulers, though you used to* be able to buy massive sheets of paper pre-ruled with curving construction lines to draw your beautifully warped scene on; atmospheric perspective is one of your main tools for creating a sense of depth when you’re not in the middle of a rigidly gridded-off city. * maybe you still can, I haven’t really looked at drafting supplies since like nineteen ninety-something
- bondarchuk 4y agoI remember some video of a 3d renderer that used some kind of inverse perspective equation - stuff got larger the farther away it was. I was surprised that that worked at all but it looked quite funky. The video was of a car driving through a city and/or some hills, unfortunately can't find it right now.