13 ms·
Plasma reactors could create oxygen on Mars
- zoba 4y agoThough if it is released into the atmosphere, won’t it all just get blown away without a magnetosphere?
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoI’ve heard that takes a few thousand years or something.
- thatoneguy 4y agoNASA thinks we can just park an MRI machine's worth of magnetic shield a million miles in front of Mars to fix the issue. https://phys.org/news/2017-03-nasa-magnetic-shield-mars-atmosphere.html https://phys.org/news/2017-03-nasa-magnetic-shield-mars-atmo...
- elihu 4y ago> "In the future it is quite possible that an inflatable structure(s) can generate a magnetic dipole field at a level of perhaps 1 or 2 Tesla (or 10,000 to 20,000 Gauss) as an active shield against the solar wind." The article is unclear whether this is 1 or 2 Tesla at a point, or if what's needed is a field that's 1 or 2 Tesla over a large area, which would be a lot more than "an MRI machine's worth". Interesting idea anyways.
- Groxx 4y ago>As a result, Mars atmosphere would naturally thicken over time, which lead to many new possibilities for human exploration and colonization. According to Green and his colleagues, these would include an average increase of about 4 °C (~7 °F), which would be enough to melt the carbon dioxide ice in the northern polar ice cap. This would trigger a greenhouse effect, warming the atmosphere further and causing the water ice in the polar caps to melt. Also suspiciously absent is any mention of how long this kind of change would be expected to take... I would be legitimately surprised if it'd take less than 20 years though, which is somewhat implied by the paragraphs that follow: >"A greatly enhanced Martian atmosphere, in both pressure and temperature, that would be enough to allow significant surface liquid water would also have a number of benefits for science and human exploration in the 2040s and beyond," ... A lot of it does seem to be very carefully avoiding making any clear statements or connections between critical bits of info though. There's room for "that wasn't claimed" arguments, but it's certainly standing very close to some lines...
- manholio 4y agoWe are clearly talking about a planetary-sized magnetic field. But I don't think it's in the realm of impossibility. With a sun-shade like that of JWST, temperatures naturally drop to superconducting ranges and at that point a closed electric loop has effectively zero resistance. So, at least in theory, you could induce an infinite current into it, slowly gathering solar energy until you build up the required magnetic field. The limiting factor would be the physical strength of the winding. I don't have the technical expertise to estimate if such a project would require mere billions, or planetary sized piles of money.
- elihu 4y agoI don't think the carrying capacity of superconductors is infinite. If you exceed the capacity, the superconductor "quenches" and ceases to be superconducting.
- phire 4y agoInteresting. That's actually very achievable. I'll point out you couldn't just park it at L1. If it's deflecting the solar wind, then it's acting as a solar sail. You would need active propulsion to keep it on station.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> I'll point out you couldn't just park it at L1. If it's deflecting the solar wind, then it's acting as a solar sail. Assuming the solar wind is constant, you could presumably park it somewhere other than L1. That's certainly not a valid assumption, though, so propulsion is going to be necessary.
- xphos 4y agoI was thinking the same thing but you likely have an area to work with however L1 points are unstable as it is and require satellites to alter the courses every once in a while potentially if you use the magnetic field as a light sail slightly in front of the point you'd be balanced between the sun and mars with less active thrust https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/resources/754/what-is-a-lagrange-point/#:~:text=The%20L1%20and%20L2%20points,regular%20course%20and%20attitude%20corrections https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/resources/754/what-is-a-lagrang....
- zardo 4y ago> So, at least in theory, you could induce an infinite current into it, Superconductors stop superconducting at very high B field strengths, which limits them to carrying less than an infinite current.
- jl6 4y agoSounds like an incredible single point of failure. You would have to keep it constantly maintained and fuelled, and maybe build ten of them for redundancy, and even then whoever controls them would be able to hold the entire planet to ransom.
- CuriousCosmic 4y agoJust because it works with martian atmospheric conditions doesn't mean you have to do it in open atmo. Instead you can fill a chamber at atmospheric pressure, run the device, then pump the oxygenated air into a filtration system to process from there. This is pretty similar to what the researchers did to prove the concept on earth anyways (build it in a sealed tube with mars-like atmo). The main issue after simply having oxygen is that the martian atmosphere has so much CO2 and so little everything else. Considering that subsurface temperatures can get low enough to sublimate CO2 into dry ice, you could potentially (and I say potentially because this isn't my specialty by any means) build an air production loop that uses relatively little power other than to drive the plasma reactor itself and a thermal pump to bring cold fluid to the surface to chill the oxygenated air so that the CO2 sublimates out. Of course here you could also just use energy to chill the gas via a compression chiller or make some tradeoff between the two. This process would move you along the following steps: Standard Atmosphere with 95% CO2, 2.5% N2, and 2.5% trace elements (mostly argon, also a very small amount of O2, and a tiny amount of CO). After Plasma Reactor: 65% CO2, 30% O2, 2.5% N2, and 2.5% trace elements. After Sublimation: Lower volume of gas with 85% O2, ~7% N2, 5.5% argon (from trace elements), and the rest of the trace elements. And the CO2 is now dry ice. Then it's just a matter of diluting the "purified air" with nitrogen or other inert gasses, adjusting the pressure, and preventing buildup of any nasties in the trace elements (such as the carbon monoxide). Now you should have breathable, earth-like atmosphere for suits and cabins. This is mainly based on my knowledge of processes we use on earth already for extracting stuff from the air so caveat that I could be missing important details.
- Koshkin 4y agoAlso, wouldn't the density of the atmosphere stay at about the current level (i.e. pretty low, regardless of the composition)?
- ncmncm 4y agoIts atmosphere will not get thicker in this millennium.
- ncmncm 4y agoIt absolutely would not be vented. It would be liquified and stored to use in rockets. They can't go home until they get enough of that and of methane. It will soon occupy all their thought, and squat their dreams. being stuck until the launch window opens up again.
- bilsbie 4y agoOver millions of years. So plenty of time to keep it topped off.
- hoseja 4y agoThat is largely overblown.
- WithinReason 4y agoOnly over about a 100 000 000 years, Mars' lack of magnetic field is a non-issue for terraformation.
- yrgulation 4y agoTo workaround this we could build a modular planet wide “city” and have everything shielded by walls. Expand it as you go along and keep everything needed inside. No need for expensive and time consuming terraforming.
- hinkley 4y agoOne book I read suggested it would take about 100,000 years for the atmosphere to ablate into space. We should be on Europa and other outer moons by then. Of course “Corey” (The Expanse) are probably right that each colony will develop her own personality, and it will be difficult to abandon any of them. The cultural trauma of such an event could be profound.
- PaulHoule 4y ago"Method X could create oxygen on (Moon|Mars)" headlines drive me nuts. Before we sent astronauts to the moon successfully we discovered the hard way that astronauts are likely to die if they breathe pure O2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_1 Future Apollo missions mitigated the danger of fires by being really careful about the materials in use, but that's not a good answer for long term missions, particularly if the astronauts are going to conduct industrial activities such as in-situ resource utilization. If you want to make breathing gas on Mars, O2 covers 20% of it, the rest of it is going to be an inert gas like Nitrogen, Argon, Helium or SF6. Of course every method of producing O2 in space works by separating O from something else and the "something else" is likely to be useful, such as H2, C, Al, etc.
- teraflop 4y agoThat seems like an extremely pedantic complaint. Sure, the breathing gas for a crewed mission or habitat would need to include an inert gas as well as oxygen. But oxygen is consumed during respiration and the inert gas isn't, so oxygen will be needed in much larger quantities, so in-situ production is a much more pressing problem.
- PaulHoule 4y agoYou are probably recycling the CO2 from the astronauts breath which is easier than cracking it from the air. Also many practical breathing systems (especially for spacesuits) leak some of the inert gas for cooling and other purposes. The real thing you’ll need O2 for is an oxidizer for fuel but of course you need to make fuel too. If you are interested in making anything interesting such as large plastic sails or small biospheres nitrogen is the big missing piece of the puzzle right now in the moon, mars and asteroids.
- ben_w 4y ago> recycling the CO2 from the astronauts breath It’s literally exactly as difficult as cracking out from the air, because breath is in fact made from air.
- eggy 4y agoDouglas Quaid discovered this in the 1990s on Mars!
- macstuff 4y agoGet your ass over to Mars
- trhway 4y agoSpaceX will need to split CO2 into CO and O2, H2O into H2 and O2, combine the firsts into methanol and pour all this into the Starship tanks for the Earth bound trips. That means that they will probably bring nuclear reactor(s) there (my hope though is that Musk will decide to do to fusion that he had already done to EV, space, etc.). O2 for humans will be just a noise (also greenhouses for food production will probably generate O2 enough for humans).
- tsimionescu 4y ago> my hope though is that Musk will decide to do to fusion that he had already done to EV, space, etc. Fusion power doesn't need the kind of incremental advances and smart marketing that Musk's companies have benefitted from, it needs huge fundamental advances in science and engineering. That said, by the time anyone actually tries to establish any kind of base on Mars, we may well have figured fusion (my money is still on ITER's follow-ups, the DEMO plants, being the first to actually do anything, in 2050 at the earliest). Musk's "plans" for Mars are just part of his pretty smart marketing / outright lying to bolster his companies.
- trhway 4y ago>Fusion power doesn't need the kind of incremental advances and smart marketing that Musk's companies have benefitted from, it needs huge fundamental advances in science and engineering. It is systems engineering - take the available science and engineering and combine into an actually working thing. That is exactly what we need with fusion today.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> take the available science and engineering and combine into an actually working thing This doesn’t describe the present situation. For example, high-temperature superconducting magnets open design space which simply didn’t exist a decade or two ago.
- tsimionescu 4y agoNot really. For example, no one has ever tried to extract even a milliwatt of power from a fusion reactor. We have some good ideas how to do it, but it's just never been attempted, so we might discover some fundamental challenges. Then, even if all current plans go right, current designs have no realistic hopes of being economical. Plants will cost extreme amounts of money, as they require state of the art technology at every level, and the irradiation caused by the fusion reaction will turn all materials in close contact with the fusion core brittle (reactor vessel, support structure, possibly even magnets) in a few years, requiring a complete replacement. Not to mention, an accident can easily be catastrophic for the entire reactor, making the whole thing an extremely risky endeavor. Even the environmental risk is large, even if not nearly as bad as fission - if such an explosion occurs, it will send radioactive materials (concrete, steel, cooling agents), plus radioactive tritium, all around the plant, requiring expensive cleanup and risking the future of the whole plant.
- John23832 4y agoGreat. Now let's deal with the carcinogenic soil.
- elihu 4y agoHere's one approach: https://phys.org/news/2021-06-catalyst-perchlorate-martian-soil.html https://phys.org/news/2021-06-catalyst-perchlorate-martian-s... Apparently there are also bacteria that consume perchlorates.
- somecommit 4y agoShould we blast a giant hole into Mars? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RnRzsQOZSfQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RnRzsQOZSfQ
- bambax 4y agoInteresting. So maybe the asteroid that killed the dinosaurs was an alien attempt to make earth habitable for them.
- knodi123 4y agoAnd it worked. And we are them. Cue intro theme music....
- elihu 4y agoThat was sort of how C.S. Lewis imagined Mars in Out Of The Silent Planet, before we really had a good idea of what Mars was really like. Most of the planet was unlivable without an air supply, but the valleys trapped enough air for plant and animal life to thrive. If one were to make a hole like the one described in the video, I wonder how much that would affect the atmospheric pressure on the rest of Mars?
- JosephK 4y agoInteresting idea, but wouldn't the ejecta from multiple impacts create a global cooling effect, which would be counterproductive to the intent of the project (i.e. a warm, high pressure area)?
- gene-h 4y agoHere's a link to the paper which this article is about: https://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/5.0098011 https://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/5.0098011 Using plasmas is interesting for ISRU because they may work at Mars ambient atmospheric conditions. I'm quite surprised that this plasma reactor approach is more energy efficient than the solid electrolysis technique used by the MOXIE experiment.
- vlovich123 4y agoNeeding to lift all the materials into space from Earth seems energy intensive. On the other hand, maybe we'll have fusion-based rockets in the future where the energy cost to escape Earth's gravity well isn't as important. You'll still have potentially two planets worth of needs to support. I know that the various space companies are looking at asteroid capture. I wonder if it makes sense to just smash some of those into Mars before it's inhabited. Yes it potentially destroys scientific data but that risk can be managed vs the benefit of having easily-accessible building materials on Mars to build large-scale industrial equipment / housing if we get serious about colonizing Mars.
- colechristensen 4y agoIsn't there plenty of oxygen which could be much more simply burned out of mars rocks? Place is covered with fine dust that's almost entirely metal oxides. I'm thinking concentrated solar to liberate the oxygen and produce a nice metal building material that could be refined to base metals for all sorts of things.
- ortusdux 4y agoI've always thought this was the obvious choice. I wonder what the logistical issues are. As a bonus, you get pure iron as a byproduct, which would be worth it's weight in gold as a building and additive manufacturing resource.
- colechristensen 4y agoIf you just roast common Martian soil you don't just get iron but many metals mixed together (the three mars landers tested and got pretty similar results at a high level)
- nickpinkston 4y agoThat's my intuition too, though given's gene-h's citation [1] in this thread, there may be an interesting analogy between water evaporation and reverse osmosis, as the proposed tech creates a plasma and the oxygen diffuses through a membrane (like osmosis tech). We know that reverse osmosis is the more efficient tech compare to evap, so who knows. [1] https://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/5.0098011 https://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/5.0098011
- hinkley 4y agoOn earth a great deal of life's variety happens at the boundaries, such as in tidal zones and estuaries. There are no oceans on Mars but there is also very little atmosphere. I suspect we will want to engineer our oxygen producing equipment to make estuaries and tidal zones for atmosphere, where there is either a steady stream of atmosphere, or daily pulses that push life to adapting to temporary deficits and surpluses of resources. Later on that could be accomplished just by routing the exhaust down into the canyons, but early on that may have to go through greenhouses, which either vent above a certain pressure or aren't quite hermetically sealed.
- basicplus2 4y agoWhat would they do with all that toxic CO??
- LeifCarrotson 4y agoToxic to who or to what?
- PaulHoule 4y agoMake organic chemicals. See ‘C1 chemistry’. CO is one of my favorite substances to get in designing chemical factories in space.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoHuff it to get high
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- smm11 4y agoLet's put Arnold on it.
- throwaway4837 4y agoI don't totally recall what your reference is about.
- ncmncm 4y agoEx-governor-stand-in of California. Was in a movie set there. Mars, I mean. And California. That can be remembered wholesale.
- sph 4y agoGP's comment was a pun based off Total Recall, a science fiction movie with Arnold Swarzenegger set on the red planet. Unless yours is a pun within a pun that flew over my head.
- S_A_P 4y agoCould the same thing be used to remove carbon dioxide from earth’s atmosphere?
- Johnny555 4y agoThe reaction described in the article says that it strips an oxygen molecule from carbon dioxide, creating carbon monoxide. CO typically only lasts for a few months in the atmosphere, but only because CO molecules react with oxygen, forming CO2. So I think no, this could not be used to sequester CO2 from the atmosphere.
- jmyeet 4y agoTwo things: Producing materials from other materials such as extracting oxygen from various compounmds is ultimately an energy problem. Better processes might reduce the ultimate cost by reducing the capital cost or reducing the running cost. For example: we can make hydrocarbons from the atmosphere. It's just uneconomic because of the energy cost. The energy source itself presents issues. If you need a $50 billion fusion reactor that takes 20 years to build and a thousand people to maintain then that's a problem to bootstrap on Mars. I personally believe that on Mars, much like on Earth, the future is solar. Solar has a lot of benefits on places like Mars. It's the only form of power generation that reduces electricity directly rather than boiling water and turning a turbine. So mars still has the two big problems it always has had: 1. It's further from the Sun so solar is less effective. This just increases the cost of energy, ultimately. Of course, there'll occassionally be a months-long dust storm that'll stop you producing any power or just a shorter one that covers all your panels in dust; and 2. What are you going to do with this oxygen? You're going to be living underground because living above ground exposes you to radiation and the Martian surface itself is toxic (eg perchlorates). If you're living underground anyway, why are you living on Mars instead of the Moon? Mars just makes zero sense to colonize.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- elihu 4y ago> The energy source itself presents issues. If you need a $50 billion fusion reactor that takes 20 years to build and a thousand people to maintain then that's a problem to bootstrap on Mars. ITER is a research facility, not a practical reactor. We have new (relatively) high temperature superconductors that are much better than what was state of the art when ITER was originally designed, meaning we ought to be able to build much smaller and cheaper reactors going forward once the basic technology is worked out. The MIT ARC and SPARC reactors are an example. > If you're living underground anyway, why are you living on Mars instead of the Moon? Mars has air that be used to manufacture rocket fuel. It has closer to Earth-standard gravity. The temperature swings are less dramatic. Water is more abundant. It's closer to the asteroid belt, which means it functions as the local gas station and resupply depot for asteroid mining. It has close to an Earth-normal day/night cycle. Basically, it's a much more hospitable environment for humans than the moon. The main thing the moon has going for it is that it's far quicker and easier to get there from Earth.
- Taniwha 4y agommmm O2+2CO great to breathe ..... to be useful they're going to n eed something that separates out ALL the carbon monoxide
- linuxftw 4y agoWe're never going to colonize mars, every penny spent on mars is wasted.
- Tagbert 4y agoColonize or not, there are many things we explore on Mars to understand it's geology and evolution that are not wasted.
- linuxftw 4y agoIf we're never going to colonize it, then it's a net-negative to resources from Earth, and therefore that money is wasted. It seems extremely unlikely that we'll make some discovery that makes this all worth it.
- StanislavPetrov 4y ago>It seems extremely unlikely that we'll make some discovery that makes this all worth it. Finding evidence of previous life on mars would make it all worth it.
- ncmncm 4y agoBut in the end, it is all on Mars, so implicitly of only marginal interest. People are so proud of being able to get there at all that they forget to consider whether there is anything there to get to.
- megablast 4y agoWe waste money on almost everything that isn’t good or shelter. Cars. Roads. Movies. Sports. Etc
- cryptodan 4y agoThis is how DooM started.
- jscipione 4y agoThere’s a heck of a lot more CO2 in Venus’ atmosphere than there is in Mars’.
- ncmncm 4y agoAnd, more importantly, hydrogen. For those wondering, the gravity, temperature, and air pressure in the cloud tops of Venus are all near Earth-normal. And, breathing air is buoyant. Mars is a frozen, dry dump. There is really no value in sending live people there. They would take one trot around the lander and want to go home.
- metadat 4y agoWhat about the sulfuric acid in the atmosphere of Venus? Can we transform that away, too?
- ncmncm 4y agoThat would all be outside. Polypropylene is proof against sulfuric acid. But you will need that sulfuric acid for the hydrogen it carries. Carbon from CO2 for structural members, hydrocarbon for plastics and fabric for gas bags, oxygen to breathe. There is thin gaseous silicides, in case you need any silicon. It will be hard to keep the concentration of CO2 in the breathing air thin enough not to make everyone stupid, with so much of it outside.
- 4y ago
- kazinator 4y agoAh, oxygen. I wonder when will the first cigarette be smoked on Mars, and the first butt dropped on the ground.
- _joel 4y agoThey'll need some kind of reactor as solar won't cut the energy needed to run Sabatier, that's for sure.
- golemiprague 4y ago
- HPsquared 4y agoOzone would also come out in fairly large amounts (it's basically an electric arc). Probably not suitable for terraforming..
- hinkley 4y agoThere was a plan at one point to put solar powered gliders into the stratosphere above the ozone holes and use coronal discharge device to create ozone with the excess power. I don’t imagine for a moment you could fly a reactor especially in such a thin atmosphere. But you might be able to park one pretty high up on Olympus Mons.
- manholio 4y agoMethods that involved splitting CO2 will always be power intensive due to physics. What many people forget is that the martian atmosphere has massive total amounts of gaseous oxygen, even if it makes just 0.16% of a very thin atmosphere, if you could capture it and store it would be more than enough for centuries of human colonization. NASA is investigating this very scenario with some low energy adsorption methods, that promise to be very energy efficient: https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/vhnuqa/nasa_funding_potential_game_changing_technology/ https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/vhnuqa/nasa_funding... This could enable, for example, the creation of suits that extract unlimited oxygen from the surrounding atmosphere as long as they have electric power - say a few solar panels.
- hinkley 4y ago> They estimate that the device could create about 14 grams of oxygen per hour: enough to support 28 minutes of breathing, the team reports today in the Journal of Applied Physics. So the greenhouse is going to be a better option, though having backup plans is good.