7 ms·
Dept. of Ed cancels $3.9B in student debt for over 200k borrowers
- balentio 4y agoGreat. Now apply it to all the other colleges who marketed themselves as money making for students and an "investment" only to saddle them with unforgivable student loan debt.
- verdverm 4y agoDoes that fix the problem? Will the universities still be allowed to keep doing this and thus create another generation of indebtedness?
- balentio 4y agoNo. The problem is greed. I'm not sure what fixes that, other than usually tragedy.
- jmoak3 4y agoAt scale, everyone looks out for #1, and kids have a tendency to be a little naive. I'm no expert, but it sounds like the problem is that we keep giving gov-backed money to kids to spend at schools who are telling them that paying 120k to be a history major is an excellent idea. These schools are not their friends, and if we want to fix this, it feels like we have several choices: A. Dictate to kids which programs they can get easy loans for. B. Punish schools that produce tons of screwed over indebted kids, and hope they begin to downsize programs and costs. C. Cut out the easy loans altogether, let schools fail, and see what happens. D. Keep forgiving debt, and watch as angry people who avoided college and the loans vote in radical politicians with axes to grind. Maybe we could see schools move to some sort of income sharing program, but I'm somewhat confident we'd soon see schools getting kids to sign on deals that are wildly exploitative (like 20 years of 10% of income sharing with the school...). I know it sucks, but this whole situation sucks - I'm leaning towards A. Open to more discussion on this.
- verdverm 4y agoMy hunch is that the underlying problems are 1. Easy, govt backed loans allow the schools to raise prices without reducing demand 2. Most of this extra revenue is not spent on academics, but rather admin staff, new student housing / amenities, and loss centers like sports 3. Students choosing paths that cannot pay back the debt they take I think all parties have blame to share, though the schools maybe the most through their exploitive practices I'm hopeful that new learning paths will emerge so that people can find meaningful, sustaining work without the traditional 4 year degree
- balentio 4y agoThe simple solution would be to make the debt hypothetically discharge-able again and to get the government bubble of money out of the picture of higher education. I suspect the market would mostly regulate itself at that point, but then you get into the whole "not equal opportunity" crap. I hate to say it, but it isn't equal now. You trade proportions of colors of students for everyone has a degree, no one has a job, and everyone is in debt.
- willcipriano 4y agoA solution I never see anyone else argue for. I'd like to have the FTC look into college advertising over the years to see what claims they made. If people were under the impression that expensive degrees in fields with way more supply than demand were going to result in good saleries that would be fraud and I'd expect them to be refunded. Would probably bankrupt them but that's what you get when you make misleading claims for money.
- public_defender 4y agoThis is only for people who attended ITT Tech.
- lapcat 4y agoPuts things in perspective. Some people brag that the President has already canceled more than $30 billion in student loan debt, but $4 billion was from just one school. Total US student loan debt is over $1.7 trillion.
- public_defender 4y agoOne one hand I support this because if you went to a for-profit college which provided you with no career skills and then went out of business, you need help. On the other hand, there is a massive population of people who went to a university of renown (on "good advice"), exited with a liberal arts degree in cartography and +$100k in debt, and who would now stab someone to get a job at Starbucks because that is their only way to get healthcare. They need help too.
- Auracle 4y agoNo, they needed help to see that was a dumb decision. That time has passed. The government can’t be bailing out everyone that makes poor decisions, even when they’re young.
- lapcat 4y agoThe government actively participated in that decision by providing the loan. One person can't just write themselves a check out of nowhere, it takes two parties. So why shouldn't the government bail out someone who the government put underwater in the first place? Moreover, the government is also financing the universities in various ways. The government is propping up the whole university system into which students become indebted. Funny how the least powerful, least wealthy, least experienced, least knowledgeable people always get blamed: the kids. Never blame the ones who know better and yet continue to exploit the kids: the government, the university administrators, the banks. Not to mention the parents, teachers, and guidance counselors who tell kids they need to go to college, and the employers who demand college degrees for no apparent reason, other than classism. Of course this is just par for the course. In the 2000s when the banks made too many bad mortgages, the banks got bailed out by the government. The mortgage holders did not. The banks are "too big to fail". The universities are too big to fail. So we make the little people fail instead. And the big people, the wealthy people, get to continue failing upward. Consequences are always for debtors, never for loaners.
- cuteboy19 4y agoDebt cannot be cancelled, only transferred.
- guywithahat 4y agoYeah this title doesn't really make sense, and seeing as ITT Tech is now defunct it looks as though taxpayers (funded with a new 1.9 billion dollar funding allocation) will be picking up the tab, and people who worked hard and paid off their loans early won't be seeing anything. I feel like a much better option would have been to make loans private and defaultable (so that if you get a loan it's not government money, and if you plan to get a worthless major private banks can simply charge you more for your loan or even refuse to give loans for a certain degree). ITT Tech was known to be a bad school for a long time and this would have been preventable through a freer market
- lapcat 4y ago> funded with a new 1.9 billion dollar funding allocation That's not how it works. The money was already disbursed from past taxpayers to ITT many years ago. No new money is getting disbursed now. (Not to mention that it would require an act of Congress to allocate more money.) Cancelation of debt held by the federal government just means less incoming government revenue in the future. But that revenue was never guaranteed to come back anyway, because many student loan debtors can't afford to pay back their debt, and some die never paying it off. (One of the fastest growing groups of student loan debtors is senior citizens. Some are getting their Social Security garnished.)
- dominotw 4y ago> was never guaranteed to come back anyway do you know what % gets back. This data looks like really hard to find. (One article says around 40-50% [1]) So its a loss of 750-900 million in revenue to the govt? 1. https://www.credible.com/blog/statistics/average-time-to-repay-student-loans-statistics/ https://www.credible.com/blog/statistics/average-time-to-rep...
- foxyv 4y agoGreat, now make all student debt dischargeable in bankruptcy. Too many people end up deeply in debt with degrees that don't do what was promised. Especially the trade schools! ITT Tech, Silver State Helicopter, Culinary Schools, and all sorts of garbage private schools are taking advantage of people who were told to get an education at all costs. Right now we already "socialize the downside" for all sorts of debt. I don't honestly know why student debt is any different.
- ffggvv 4y ago
- westmeal 4y agoBecause a lot of large organizations stand to make a lot of money! :D
- dominotw 4y agoare you saying they don't stand to make a lot of money on other kinds of debts.
- strawhatguy 4y agoyes we socialize the downside for lots of stuff, not just debt. Two wrongs don't make a right, though. By canceling this debt, no school (or student) will have learned the lesson, and indeed schools can take advantage of students even more now!
- cyanydeez 4y agoPoor people can't learn. Sorry man. Also, corporations aren't incentivized to learn either.
- strawhatguy 4y agoYes, I believe I said no one is incentivized if they can get your tax dollars to pay for their mistakes. That’s precisely my point.
- Blackstrat 4y ago
- supercanuck 4y agoI had no idea ITT Technical Institute (ITT) was in the Ivy league.
- Blackstrat 4y agoI’m betting the majority loans are not to ITT
- BugsJustFindMe 4y agoThe article addresses your bet in the first and second sentences.
- GauntletWizard 4y agoAnd addresses his comments in paragraphs 7-11, where they're talking about future debt-movement plans from borrowers to the government.
- Blackstrat 4y agoNo matter how many times you toss this word salad, it falls to the taxpayer. I paid my student loans off in full and on time. At the time I owed a loan amount equal to about 25% of my annual salary. If one borrows the money, they are obligated to pay it back. If they believe they were defrauded by the institution, that’s between them and the institution, not between them and the government. Maybe the government should just “forgive” my mortgage as well. My car payment? My monthly utility bill? The expectation that government will remediate one’s bad decisions is the road to serfdom.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- electric_dreams 4y ago
- footlose_3815 4y ago[dead]