4 ms·
> severe restrictions Why do people always turn to regulation and rationing rather than simply increasing the price of water?
by WalterBright 4y ago
> severe restrictions
Why do people always turn to regulation and rationing rather than simply increasing the price of water?
- photochemsyn 4y agoEssentially the effect is the same, but one reason is reducing conflict. A bidding war over water rights, for example, might mean that some regions don't get enough water to survive while others get enough to keep their golf courses green. Historically in the American West, that kind of thing has led to people dynamiting canals and so on. A more balanced option might be setting a minimal delivery baseline for everyone in the watershed, with prices rising steeply above that baseline for the remaining water. This would encourage adoption of recycling, aka 'toilet-to-tap'...
- Ancalagon 4y agoNot to mention restricting water use for agriculture would more than solve the problem for residential users.
- fallingfrog 4y agoBecause the people with the most money (golf courses) and the people with the most legitimate need for water (thirst) are not the same people. Many Americans have this bizarre fixation on the idea that markets are magic and freedom means that whoever has the most money gets whatever they want. Sorry but that is an incredibly cruel and inefficient way to make decisions.
- RhysU 4y agoI would rather accept the wisdom of the cruel and inefficient markets, in which literally the whole world has input in some fashion, over the edicts issued by a local board of the well-connected and appointed.
- fallingfrog 4y agoNo, the world's people are not what has the input- the world's money does. Very different. Money does not think or feel, it's just a measure of power. Money is power. If you think money should purely decide this question you are in effect saying "whoever is the most powerful gets what they want", which is anti-civilization. Markets only function at all because powerful governments moderate and regulate them. Otherwise the world would quickly decay into a hobbsian war of all against all. Unregulated markets always self-destruct. Rationing on one level or another is the only reason that markets in limited areas are even possible. Try having markets without "rationing" who can print money, for example.
- WalterBright 4y ago> Unregulated markets always self-destruct. I hadn't noticed the US self-destructing. Maybe I read the wrong history books?
- fallingfrog 4y agoBecause our markets are tightly regulated. And where they aren’t you get things like the financial crisis.
- RhysU 4y agoRegulations certainly play a large and important role in creating and sustaining well-functioning markets. No argument there.
- WalterBright 4y agoDepends on the kind of regulations. Wage and price controls, for example, do not create well-functioning markets. Quite the opposite.
- RhysU 4y ago
- WalterBright 4y ago> bizarre fixation The system of free market pricing has always been a more efficient and effective way to distribute scarce goods to where they are most needed. The system of rationing has never produced fair or efficient results. If you disagree, present a system where rationing has done otherwise. Certainly, that has never worked for water distribution.
- fallingfrog 4y agohttps://www.nationalww2museum.org/war/articles/rationing https://www.nationalww2museum.org/war/articles/rationing I mean that's the most obvious example. But really, this is a commonplace and standard practice- get out a cake at a birthday party and how are you going to divide it? Richest family gets the most cake? This is a bad question to be honest, possibly asked in bad faith.
- WalterBright 4y agoTalk to someone who lived through WW2 rationing (I have). (Sadly, they're pretty much all gone now.) Let's take WW2 gas rationing. People were allocated gas based on their profession. Note that this had NOTHING to do with their needs. So what happened? Nobody had an allocation that matched their need, it was either too much or too little. So what happened? An illegal black market emerged where those with extra sold it to those with less (at high prices, as illegal markets always carry a price premium). Let's take your birthday cake example. It has the same assumption built in - that everybody wants exactly the same amount of cake. This is never the reality, and forcing it on people results in inefficient mis-allocation, and people who want more saying "hey, are you going to finish yours? Can I have it?". > possibly asked in bad faith You might want to read up on the history of the results of rationing before you draw such conclusions.
- beej71 4y agoThis recent spike in has prices left a lot of people without. It distributed gas to the people who could afford it, not to the people who needed it, no?