9 ms·
We are on such a Goldilocks planet it isn’t even funny. Or life is so exquisitely tuned to optimize for earth’s conditions it isn’t even funny. Or both. We see
by hinkley 4y ago
We are on such a Goldilocks planet it isn’t even funny. Or life is so exquisitely tuned to optimize for earth’s conditions it isn’t even funny. Or both.
We see magnetic fields this strong on gas giants, but not on inner planets. I wonder too if we will find that some asteroid impacts and the formation of the moon didn’t goose up the magnetic flux of the core while they were at it. Maybe habitable zones only appear on tortured worlds, like earth and some of the moons of a Jupiter, because normal planets are just too boring, don’t have enough building blocks for life.
- colechristensen 4y agoProbably true, but as a balance for this there are about 100 billion galaxies in the visible universe each with about a hundred billion stars, each with a chance to build up the right conditions for live. That's 10^22 opportunities to get it right. We can't possibly be alone.
- pfdietz 4y agoNow justify your implicit assumption that the chance life arises on a suitable planet is at least 1 in 10^22.
- layer8 4y agoThe point is we don’t know either way. Earth may or may not be a “Goldilocks” planet. Also, the numbers above are based on the observable universe. We have no idea how big the universe is outside that region. It could be infinitely large.
- colechristensen 4y agoA root fact of my philosophy is the unrefutable claim that I exist, and am alive, so the 1 in 10^22 seems very reasonable.
- pfdietz 4y agoNot 1 in 10^21, or 1 in 10^23? Where exactly is this number coming from? You are implicitly assuming a probability that life can arise. Don't you think that number has to be informed by an actual theory of how life arises, not inferred just from your own existence? And in fact, you can conclude nothing from your own existence. Observer selection bias.
- inanutshellus 4y agoThis thread comes across as bickering, and detracts from OP's original euphoric "wow" message.
- mbostleman 4y agoOrthogonal and bickering, but I find it interesting. I can keep two thoughts going at once. Sort of.
- ziddoap 4y agoWhat an oddly pedantic comment. 10^21, 10^22 and 10^23... Whichever number, the point that the parent poster was making doesn't change at all. >You are implicitly assuming a probability that life can arise. What are you suggesting? We're all actually not alive? Come on.
- pfdietz 4y agoNo, it's not oddly pedantic. It's more an expression of anger, because this sort of argument is common among SETI people. It's a very common error: there's lots of opportunities for life to arise, therefore life must be common in the universe. And this is utter bullshit. Probability does not work that way!
- mrcartmeneses 4y agoIt is at least 1 in 10^22 because we have very strong evidence of one habitable planet Edit: See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth
- Apes 4y agoThe chance of a habitable planet happening could just as easily be 1 in 10^10000000000000000000000000, and it was just a freak occurrence it happened at all. Just because something happened once doesn't tell you much about the odds of it occurring.
- nikanj 4y agoTo be fair, we are working very hard on changing it to uninhabitable
- aaaaaaaaaaab 4y ago>uninhabitable *for humans
- scoopertrooper 4y agoThis earth place sounds preposterous! I'm supposed to believe the planet's alpha predators willing make themselves subservient to smaller, but more furry beta predators?
- pfdietz 4y agoWhy 10^22, and not 10^10, or 10^40, or whatever? The number has to come from somewhere. This should be a strong clue your logic is defective.
- dogma1138 4y agoThe observable universe isn’t particularly interesting as far as looking for life goes, heck anything outside of our immediate intra-galactic neighborhood isn’t particularly interesting because we have no chance in hell of ever visiting or communicating with systems more than a few light years away. So how rare are true earth like planets does matter a lot.
- xqcgrek2 4y ago1 in 10^22 sounds like a lot but it really isn't when it comes to probabilities. It's only about a 10 sigma evidence against a null hypothesis. Put it another away, all it takes is about four one-in-a-million chance independent events (or filters) and you're left with Earth being the only planet with life in the observable universe.
- colechristensen 4y ago>Put it another away, all it takes is about four one-in-a-million chance independent events (or filters) and you're left with Earth being the only planet with life in the observable universe. This presupposes life can only exist on a planet with several exact characteristics that we have on Earth. Given life on Earth exists quite nearly in every environment that exists, it could be expected that despite significant filters, there is room for several variations which enable life even if quite different.
- cogman10 4y agoThe real question to me is if intelligent life exists. If you look at the history of earth, there have been several filters that very nearly wiped out intelligent life. Further, we needed a few extinction events just to have a world where our intelligent life could reach the point of developing science. We wouldn't, for example, have been able to thrive in the Jurassic period. There were simply far too many predators to keep us from doing anything more than hiding in caves and trees. Then if you look at the evolution of humanity, we very nearly went extinct a couple of times. We were estimated to have been whittled down to 10000 citizens at one point. [1] Evolution, it seems, doesn't necessarily select for intelligence. It selects for better killers and better hiders. Being smarter than the predators doesn't immediately grant enough benefit. If it did, we'd probably not be the only intelligent species to ever exist. [1] https://www.npr.org/sections/krulwich/2012/10/22/163397584/how-human-beings-almost-vanished-from-earth-in-70-000-b-c https://www.npr.org/sections/krulwich/2012/10/22/163397584/h...
- macintux 4y agoThis is why I worry about our potential extinction: what if we truly are the only beings in the entire universe capable of exploring it, and we wipe ourselves out? What an incredible waste.
- boplicity 4y agoHow much subjective time would it take to visit say, 1/10th of those galaxies, if you were traveling at say, 99% of the speed of light? It seems to me that the odds of encountering other life forms are vanishingly small, simply because of the scale of the universe, combined with the low odds of finding other life forms. Sure, it might happen, but we're alone until we're not. And we're incredibly likely to remain alone for a very long time.
- vidanay 4y ago“Space is big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist's, but that's just peanuts to space.”
- gcanyon 4y agoFor some reason I'm inspired to write: Time is short. You cannot imagine how vanishingly, briefly, disappointingly short it is. I mean, you might think you have all the time in the world, but to the universe, you're a fraction of a gnat's wingbeat.
- colechristensen 4y agoHow long until a post-human consciousness will have a lifespan of a billion years? If never, why is that not a possible future? There's two scales you can change, yourself, and the tools you use to interact. So how fast can you make a spaceship competes with how long you can make your life.
- asdff 4y agoPost human conciousness on earth has already been around for what nearly 4 billion years? Life on earth represents a meta organism. It's a human bias to elevate the significance of the human species component above that of the greater meta organism. Ecology can be studied with similar tooling whether the frame of reference is a continent or your gut microbiome. If we wanted to, say, ship earthbound life to another planet, then lets consider the best form of earthbound life to make that journey across a hostile environment for an indefinite period of time. Chances are its not humans adapted to persistent hunting and gathering, but put some microbes or spores into a vial wrapped in gold foil, and you wouldn't even need a complex generational space ship to seed earthbound life across the universe, just a gun capable of firing the vial on a vector.
- thaumaturgy 4y agoWell, there are a couple of problems with this conclusion. One is that it assumes that those 10^22 opportunities are evenly distributed in time and space. Another is that we might not be alone, but we might also never meet our neighbors. The universe hasn't always been a habitable place. It's been hotter and more chaotic; life may have arisen and become extinct due to radiation or cosmic-scale collisions a billion times on a million worlds over the universe's early history. We don't know exactly where the lines are, but we're fairly certain at this point that the universe is not static in time and it has had a less habitable period and will probably have a less habitable period again. We also don't know what the prospects are for long-term life in environments like galactic cores. Of the hundred billion galaxies we've observed so far, maybe only the tiniest fraction of them are capable of supporting life in the long term -- recall, it has taken Earth 4.5 billion years to produce us! -- and of those that are capable of supporting life, perhaps they can only support life out on their edges. These amount to some pretty significant polynomials added to the Drake Equation, and they can attenuate the result a lot. But let's imagine the AI swarm, the most popular rebuttal to the unforgiving conditions of time and space. Let's imagine that one arose a billion years ago, and it happened right next door in cosmological terms -- 1000 light years away. Let's forgive that we are now 71 light years farther away from it than we were when it arose [1], it's fun to mention but a rounding error in this imaginary scenario. You still have the incredible problem of maintaining a homogeneous density of AIs over a rapidly increasing volume! Let's figure one lonely AI to a solar system's worth of space in 1000 light years in every direction -- that works out to 2.6 trillion little self-sustaining devices! [2] With "only" a billion years available to cover that volume, 2,600 new AIs have had to come online every single year (on average) and somehow teleport to their proper location. On Earth, it's easy for us to manufacture 2,600 pieces of complicated electronics in a year -- all it takes is the collective efforts of millions of people to mine the raw materials, refine them, design components, manufacture them, and ship all those molecules back and forth across the globe some absurd number of times. In space, this is much harder. And this is, I think, a very generous treatment of the AI swarm thought experiment. It assumes that each node has an indefinite lifespan, and both communication and travel are somehow instantaneous over great distances, and that all of the necessary raw materials are always nearby, and that the entire thing never goes to war against itself, and that there are no cosmological disasters (like a GRB) over that billion year span, and that it all happened right next door to us in our very own galaxy. This is the best case scenario for an extraterrestrial presence in our solar system! [1]: Approximation of the universe's rate of expansion * 1 billion years * 1000 light years of distance, https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=70+km%2Fs%2FMpc+*+1000ly+*+1gy https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=70+km%2Fs%2FMpc+*+1000l... [2]: Volume of a sphere 1000 ly in radius * astronomical units per light year / 100 AU, https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=%284*pi*1000%5E3%29%2F3+*+63241+%2F+100 https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=%284*pi*1000%5E3%29%2F3...
- irrational 4y agoUndoubtably true, but we may never know for sure since light speed limitations means we will never leave our galaxy (and probably will never personally travel beyond our solar system) and there might not be any other life in our galaxy.
- bouncycastle 4y agotime slows down as speed increases, so in theory, it may be possible, for the traveller to leave? (Although the observers would be long gone on the return journey. Relativity is a crazy thing)
- irrational 4y agoSure, but that only matters when you get up to a fairly high percentage of light speed. We’ve never even approached 1% of light speed. The fastest space craft is NASA’s Parker Solar Probe. It has reached 0.05% of light speed.
- bouncycastle 4y agoThese are engineering limitations, not "light speed limitations"
- irrational 4y agoIt’s both. Even if we could engineer a drive to go a high percentage of light speed, it still takes forever to get anywhere. Space is really really vast and even light speed is really really slow. FTL travel is the only practical solution, except current physics says it is impossible.
- unyttigfjelltol 4y agoYou're just referring to known opportunities. The fun starts with unknown chances and specifically infinities. If time is infinite, anything that can happen eventually will happen, right here. If space extends infinitely beyond the observable universe, anything that can happen is happening somewhere (an infinite number of somewheres) right now. No, people approach this question from a far more skeptical position than they should.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> If time is infinite, anything that can happen eventually will happen This doesn't come close to being true. That just isn't how infinite quantities work. You can have an infinite sequence of numbers that doesn't include 3 at any point.
- aaaaaaaaaaab 4y ago>life is so exquisitely tuned to optimize for Earth’s conditions *life on Earth
- zardo 4y ago> Or life is so exquisitely tuned to optimize for earth’s conditions It seems that it would have to be. If a planet has had life for a large number of generations, that life will have evolved to fit the conditions.
- LiquidSky 4y ago>Or life is so exquisitely tuned to optimize for earth’s conditions it isn’t even funny. Well, of course Earth life is optimized for Earth's environment. Otherwise it wouldn't exist. I bet somewhere out there an intelligent lifeform with radically different chemistry and biology is posting on their online forums, "It's pretty amazing our planet has exactly the liquid argon-cadmium oceans we need to survive, really makes you think."
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoIt's really hard to imagine chemistry that could support non-carbon-based life. You just really need an atom that can make 4 covalent bonds.
- sokoloff 4y agoSilicon can make 6 covalent bonds (I think; it’s been a while since I’ve taken any formal chemistry/material science courses).
- spaetzleesser 4y ago“Or life is so exquisitely tuned to optimize for earth’s conditions” That’s how it works. Life adapts to the conditions it faces or it goes extinct.
- idlehand 4y agoIt took billions of years to get to that point, too. Complex life only really got going during the Cambrian explosion.
- wruza 4y agoIt took billions of years, but not so much of evolution itself but rather of saturating the entire atmosphere with oxygen, which was monumental work given they only had that much sunlight at the surface. Life has its limits (what doesn’t) but is very quick in a geological sense. Sadly there is not much time left for it.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoIf we see life as an energetic process (movement of energy across membranes) then it makes sense that it happened here on a planet with an active tectonic situation and plenty of energy differentials -- and yet not so intense that they'd be destructive to emergent life. I like Nick Lane's description of abiogensis as a process born in the chemical reactions at early alkaline hydrothermal vents. Again, a process that could only happen on a very specific kind of planet with active tectonics combined with a (at the time acidic) liquid water ocean.
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoBut that would be the majority of rocky planets with water, no?
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoSeems like most are expected to be tidally locked, or without active tectonics.
- yrgulation 4y ago> We are on such a Goldilocks planet it isn’t even funny. If we are the only living planet then it is out duty to life on this planet to expand outwards. If not then it is our duty to meet the others. Life here will eventually die regardless of what we do. We should start working on spreading the seeds as far as possible. Otherwise we would have lived for nothing as a species.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoWhy do we have a "duty?" We haven't even figured out how to be good to each other. That's far more important than worrying about how to get a civilization on Mars. If most people die, that's a tragedy. If everyone dies, that's nature and no real value is lost.
- yrgulation 4y agoIt is our duty because life is programmed to spread. It’s in the biology of any living thing, ranging from animals to plants to microorganisms. Our planet’s lifespan and size are finite so we have to seek out new venues. You are right re being good to each other. Scarcity of resources leads to a lot of bad things. People and all life are programmed to compete for resources in order to survive. Most wars are caused by the struggle to control these resources. And that causes misery to those on the losing side. Near space has endless amounts of everything we need so that competition can be more relaxed. If anything, expanding to space will make life better here on earth, by keeping our planet cleaner and safer, and will give us the time we need to learn how to move beyond our basic instincts. We progressed a lot but we need to do more. Mars shouldn't even be the immediate goal. We should harness the energy of our star at its full potential and extract nearby resources as first steps. Mars will be a byproduct of these two. Else we are stuck arguing over -isms and tribal wars at scale over who owns what part of the planet. The very fact that we push electrons writing here shows that we humans have moved beyond the natural, so simply stating that “that's nature and no real value is lost” is not in our … nature.
- seti0Cha 4y ago