4 ms·
Every week my office restocks on bananas from Latin america Every week at least a few end up in the trash, because they turned black and no one wants them anym
by lm28469 4y ago
Every week my office restocks on bananas from Latin america
Every week at least a few end up in the trash, because they turned black and no one wants them anymore
So some dude, thousands of kilometers away, grew his bananas, put them in a boat, for a weeks long trip to Europe, followed by hundreds of kilometers in a truck, to end up in my office trash
This is a simple example
It's not about what was possible before, of course we've been shiping stuff world wide for a long time, it's about the scale and banality of it and the scale and banality of waste that comes with it. Nothing is measured with the "absurdity" scale, everything is measured with the "money" scale. A lot of what we now consider normal is complete madness
- bm3719 4y agoYou can take them home to add to your compost bin. Then you can put this excellent and free compost in your garden.
- bitwize 4y agoBlackened bananas can also be frozen and used later to make banana bread.
- lm28469 4y agoI don't know if you're sarcastic or not, because this is exactly what I mean by using a monetary scale. It's free to me but it still is an incredible waste of energy, time and ressources
- bm3719 4y agoI'm being serious, and I do this when possible. My non-gardening relatives will sometimes even drop off a pile of unusable produce for such purposes when visiting. Ideally, it's better not to overproduce and overbuy. But I'm suggesting making the best of a situation where the bananas can either go to the landfill or still be of some use.
- delusional 4y agoIn that case we shipped literal dirt around the world so that he could put it in his garden. Is that any less absurd?
- spookthesunset 4y agoWhat do you propose as an alternative?
- _hcuq 4y agoEat locally grown food?
- jimbobimbo 4y agoSo, no banana for you, eat potatoes instead?
- lm28469 4y agoYou haven't tried the vast majority of fruits, veggies, meats, fishes out there and I'm sure you don't feel like you're life is miserable because of it
- nautilius 4y agoThat argument makes no sense. Presumably, jimbobimbo already sources ~100% of their intake from some producer outside of their apartment, to not be stuck on eating the mushrooms growing in the bathroom. Just because there is even more out there to miss out on doesn’t make missing out on bananas less of an issue. I assume you can just stop to eat altogether, because you’re not consuming the vast majority of food out there.
- jimbobimbo 4y agoYou do understand that this position comes across as incredibly paternalistic? It's like mom telling a child they can't have a cookie until they finish their broccoli first. I don't have to try "the vast majority" of other stuff to enjoy the banana.
- yellow_postit 4y agoI can recommend “The Fish that Ate the Whale” [1] — this race against time for bananas is a tale told over many different phases of shipping. [1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13166586-the-fish-that-ate-the-whale https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13166586-the-fish-that-a...
- onos 4y agoI don’t like the waste but I also like bananas. Not sure what to make of your example.
- orangecat 4y agoSo some dude, thousands of kilometers away, grew his bananas, put them in a boat, for a weeks long trip to Europe, followed by hundreds of kilometers in a truck, to end up in my office trash Along with millions of other bananas that got eaten. You're arguing against economies of scale here, and you'll need to show your work rather than dismissing long-distance trade as "madness".
- rakoo 4y agoThat's the thing. Under capitalism the only way to measure something is money. Millions of tons could be sold, profit was made, so it's OK to throw away a few tons. Environment, living and working conditions, resources and materials being taken from non-renewables sources, all of those are unimportant under capitalism, all of those are unimportant with capitalism and are the reason why no one asks themselves whether it's really worth shipping fruits from the other side of the world. Sometimes even by plane.
- kqr 4y agoRight. In a system where people feel forced to work crazy hours in the middle of the ocean; in a system where someone else pays the externalities of petroleum; in a system where the raw materials for a freighter can be dug up by people who may not need to understand why anyone would need bananas shipped to them; in a system rich people have shaped so that it feeds them whatever exotic fruits they desire... only in such a system can shipping bananas to be thrown out be considered "cheap because economies of scale". Economies of scale means individual suffering turns into statistical noise.
- fallingknife 4y agoBecause the environment is so much less polluted and working conditions are so much better in non capitalist countries?
- kqr 4y agoI don't know if there's been a good example of an actually non-capitalist country yet. I'm not a historian, but all examples I can think of have a small class of people owning the means of production. They aren't always the bourgeoisie but sometimes a political elite or dictator's following. What I can say is that on a more local scale, the non-capitalist systems I've had experience with have been much more pleasant than the ones where a small set of people held most of the power over production.
- AlbertCory 4y agoI actually see a food bank "gleaner" regularly at my Safeway. Bananas with any black spots at all are considered unsaleable, although they're perfectly edible. So long before they turn all black, they're taken to the food bank and given away to whomever wants them at their central location. If a banana does make it all the way to black, it means someone bought it and then didn't eat it. There is actually competition among the food banks for supermarkets' unwanted food. One will go to the supermarket manager and ask for their unwanted food and get told "Sorry, we're already giving it to Second Harvest." It isn't only produce. The gleaner regularly fills up his car with breads, milk, and lots of other stuff.
- hypertele-Xii 4y agoThis is a failure of your office, not of the logistics network. The bananas arrive just fine, why does your office stock so many they go bad? I eat plenty banana and almost never throw any away. And when I do, the reason is never "because I didn't eat it in time".
- kortilla 4y agoThe economies of scale make this nearly no different than you wasting a locally grown banana. Very little energy was spent on that particular banana to get it do you.
- philwelch 4y agoIt’s not like each individual banana was artisinally grown in a flower pot. They literally grow on trees.
- lm28469 4y agoAnd petrol grows in the soil so I guess we're all right then I took a single banana as an example, now think about the millions of animals we slaughter every year which end up straight to the bin etc. It's like cars, a single car is fine, 1.4 billion cars are not, I think most people just don't comprehend the scale of it all
- philwelch 4y agoPetrol does not, in fact, “grow” on human timescales.
- drexlspivey 4y agoAlternative: You’ve never eaten a banana because they don’t grow in Europe. How does this measure in the absurdity scale?
- lm28469 4y agoWho cares, I haven't tried the majority of fruits, vegetables, meats out there, I'm fine Life isn't a race to consume everything as much and as fast as possible
- Cederfjard 4y agoA lot of people would care, that’s the issue. Even if you personally have achieved an enlightened state where you’re perfectly able to voluntarily forego trying to do and acquire things that are contributing to an unsustainable society, it doesn’t mean that you can extrapolate from that and construct a stable system where everyone else does the same. Human beings are greedy and shortsighted, and they especially want to have more than the people they surround themselves with. Any sustainable solution will need to take this into account.
- karaterobot 4y agoI apologize for my ignorance: under what economic system do a small fraction of bananas not get bruised during shipping? Sign me up!
- MRtecno98 4y agoYeah it's called efficiency, which you can never have 100% of