29 ms·
Researchers: World can reach 100% renewable energy system by/before 2050
- HidyBush 4y agoNow add a political researcher to the group and see that percentage drop rapidly
- bfung 4y agoTotally agree - technologically possible. Now who’s ambition, will, and money are behind this to get those who are in the middle, don’t care, or need to look after themselves first in the ecosystem to get this done?
- seydor 4y agogovernments have been funding renewables left and right because it's a populist measure, and it creates jobs that guarantee voters. The dynamic is a positive feedback loop on that front. Europe is subsidizing teslas. But one has to look at the downsides. Germany has overinvested in solar, but the results are feeble as it's not a sunny country and renewables are unreliable. Even if there was an agreement on 100% renewables, i m certain it would get squandered in silly but popular projects such as solar curtains or rooftop
- vanviegen 4y agoWhat's wrong with rooftop solar? Seems like a great use for an otherwise unused roof?
- seydor 4y agoMaybe in american suburbs it makes more sense, but in old cities like europe electric grids are not designed to feed into the network, and the installations are small, thus no economies of scale. The money spent on subsidizing them would be better spent on large installations
- thrown_22 4y agoNo it really isn't technologically possible. Throw in a physicists who actually understands the difference between power, energy and time offset and the green grid plans that assume the sun shines at midnight underestimate the cost of replacing on demand power by two orders of magnitude.
- frankfrankfrank 4y agoYou make the foolish assumption that theses "researchers" are not biased simply because you agree with the premise due to your own bias. It is rather surprising to me how people who used to rail against the "evil corporation" now love them some evil corporation simply because evil corporations have been created to pilfer society through renewable energy. It could be a scene from 1984; yesterday the people hate corporations they always have been at war with and always will be, today they have been told to love corporations and they do so with zealous mania.
- HidyBush 4y agoBuddy, what has that got to do with my reply? lol
- frankfrankfrank 4y ago
- HidyBush 4y agoYou replied to a "what" question with "yes", it seems to me you haven't actually understood neither the point I was making in my first post nor my question.
- fzfaa 4y ago
- MadSudaca 4y agoI find this highly unlikely, but then again I'm not a "researcher", so what do I know?
- revertmean 4y agoFar less than the people who actually researched the matter, obviously.
- frankfrankfrank 4y agoIs this a sarcastic comment? It is hard to tell these days, because it is ironic in many ways.
- badpun 4y agoWe've already allowed narrow-field experts to largely dicate our policy re: covid response, and the results are worse than the disease. Let's hope more people are brought into decision making this time.
- ManuelKiessling 4y agoSource?
- badpun 4y ago
- frankfrankfrank 4y ago
- autophagian 4y agoAgreed, im quite tired of HN commenters having the gall to question the basis for my half baked stances and strongly held gut feelings.
- badpun 4y agoOne could very well ask for the source of the (default for a lot of people) belief that the lockdowns were a net benefit...
- Boltgolt 4y ago"results worse than the disease" by what measurement?
- badpun 4y agoInflation getting out of control which will disproportionally affect poor people in Africa, Asia etc. Whereas we might have to get less nicer car on our next trade-in, they might not be able to get enough food. Plus, if the strained economy results in even just one war, the deaths and suffering from it alone will probably be greater than the lives saved via covid response.
- thrown_22 4y ago> energy storage The thing no one talks about. A battery that can store energy over 24 hours costs more than an equivalent nuclear power plant, loses half it's capacity within a decade and has never been build. The closest one in South Australia could match a nuclear plant for all of 10 minutes and still needed the solar panel and wind generation to work. We're out of time. We don't have another 40 years to wait for renewables to mature.
- hackerlight 4y agoCan't you sell the excess capacity to another country? Or convert the excess capacity to green hydrogen which is used as an energy source for things like steel manufacturing?
- ThunderSizzle 4y agoIf we're talking Europe sized countries. But Europe is pretty small relati ely speaking...it's hard to move a lot of electricity thousands of miles without losing too much.
- hackerlight 4y agoFrom Google: "HVDC transmission losses are quoted at 3.5% per 1,000 km" Seems like small losses for large distances.
- Ekaros 4y agoAnd even in Europe the weather patterns tend to be quite larger. So you would need very long transmission lines. And then compete for the supply from the areas that have momentary production, with other areas that don't. Theoretically long distance sounds like fancy idea, but I don't think geopolitics are exactly ready for that yet. At least not on intercontinental scale.
- thrown_22 4y agoHigh voltage inter connects are also more expensive than nuclear power to build. Outside of Russia there are no transcontinental high voltage lines. The US doesn't even have a single energy grid despite being a single country. The European market is probably the most tightly coupled in the world and the inter-border power lines can carry less than 20% of most countries power demand. >Or convert the excess capacity to green hydrogen which is used as an energy source for things like steel manufacturing? We don't have 40 years to wait for that technology to mature. We need to be cutting emissions now. Green energy has resulted in increasing use of fossil fuels. The only reason why total CO2 production has dropped is because we've been building gas power plants instead of coal.
- sigmoid10 4y agoWhat this article claims as "new" has been known for so long, the Onion even turned it into a joke years ago: https://www.theonion.com/scientists-politely-remind-world-that-clean-energy-tech-1819576507/amp https://www.theonion.com/scientists-politely-remind-world-th... Technology isn't what's stopping us from saving the planet, greedy corporations and corrupt politicians are.
- trinovantes 4y agoI'd say NIMBYism is also a big contributor. Renewable energy farms are rarely located near population centers and convincing rural people to sell their land to generate/transport energy to urban centers is a multiyear process with single holdouts stalling projects. The alternative of invoking eminent domain is also politically unattractive.
- IngoBlechschmid 4y agoI agree, and want to add that I feel that NIMBYism would decrease if the residents (as opposed to huge corporations) would earn the profits from those renewable energy farms. You think differently about a wind park at the horizon if you know that each rotation earns turn earns you money.
- enviclash 4y agoI have seen less NIMBY during the last 10 years in some areas, is this a general trend?
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoMost governments are converting coal to Methane gas ("Natural Gas"). Replacing one lobby with another. Most governments are not deploying storage solutions that would allow continous energy supply irrespective of intermitent renewable energy generation. Neither of the above has anything to do with NIMBYs and everything to do with spineless anemic Energy Policy.
- Mountain_Skies 4y ago
- osipov 4y ago
- zokier 4y ago> Many young people are depressed because they feel climate change cannot be stopped. We want to offer them hope by showing that our world can get all its energy needs from renewables at a price below that of fossil fuels idk, to me saying that fossils can be replaced by 2050 is pretty much same as saying that climate change cannot be stopped. I think the discussion has largely moved from preventing the climate change to trying manage how bad it will be, as it seems pretty inevitable at this point.
- dgb23 4y agoYes, damage control becomes more and more necessary. That just means any progress is becoming more urgent.
- d0mine 4y agoThe fact that we might have a technology to do something says nothing about whether it is actually will be done. For example, there is no need for war, we can feed everyone using the technology available today but it is almost certain millions will continue to die from hunger every year and of cause the peace is just a wild dream.
- londons_explore 4y agoThe world could reach 100% renewable energy by next year if every citizen took a massive cut to their quality of life. And it isn't going to happen at all if at least some citizens don't take a cut to their quality of life (compared to what they could have had with no action) So it's a trade-off....
- goodpoint 4y agoThis is plain false. Quality of life is in no way strictly correlated with energy usage and pollution. It's product of thousands more variables and the most important ones are urban planning and social issues.
- perrygeo 4y agoQuality of Life is too fuzzy to make such a strong statement. But if we take economic output as a proxy, it's your view that is demonstrably false. You're roughly claiming that "Decoupling" (economic growth without resource consumption) is not only possible but has already occurred? Seriously? Global GDP is very highly correlated with energy use, fossil fuel use specifically. You probably heard that some countries (the US, EU) are in the process of decoupling. Bullshit. Looking at this on a per-country basis is a deeply flawed analysis at best, a deceptive account trick. We have a global trade network and you can't outsource your fuel consumption to China, import their products, and call yourself green. If you extend the analysis globally, you will not find decoupling at all - energy is the economy. I encourage you to read this paper by the European Environmental Bureau: https://eeb.org/library/decoupling-debunked/ https://eeb.org/library/decoupling-debunked/
- goodpoint 4y ago> Quality of Life is too fuzzy to make such a strong statement. So it is GDP. Also environmental impact, happiness an much more. Yet you can find plenty of lists of countries by per capita income, QoL and so on and make comparisons. > But if we take economic output as a proxy, it's your view that is demonstrably false. Wrong. > You're roughly claiming that ... is not only possible but has already occurred? It's clearly shown if you compare QoL vs environmental impact across nothern european countries, japan and US for example. US being pretty terrible at that, to no surprise. > Bullshit. You can do better. > I encourage you to read this paper by the European Environmental Bureau: https://eeb.org/library/decoupling-debunked/ https://eeb.org/library/decoupling-debunked/ From the landing page: "Is it possible to enjoy both economic growth and environmental sustainability?" ...which is nowhere close to my initial point. And for the record I'm actually going to finish reading the pdf instead of just calling things "Bullshit"
- seydor 4y agoThey could start by not commuting to the office/university
- muhaaa 4y agoRenewable energy is a lot less energy dense than oil or nuclear. Just to maintain renewable energy projects we need to re-invest about 25% of its energy output to keep it going long-term. This 25% needs to come from your living standards. Compare that to oil of about 10% and nuclear of less than 5%. Going green means that we loose productivity and have less money available on non-essential products and services. And many "greens" think they can keep their iPhone - I dont think so -, far away vacation - nope -, having a car - maybe a tiny one which you share with the whole family (incl. uncles and aunts).
- Isinlor 4y agoWhat we care about is overall cost, not how much is required to reinvest. If a renewable energy source is for example twice cheaper overall including the need to reinvest 25% then it is twice cheaper overall.
- frankfrankfrank 4y agoInteresting that you speak from some group of "we". Seems presumptuous at best.
- muhaaa 4y agoThe major driver of renewables costs is investment. The wind blowing and sun shining does not cost anything. Sadly regarding renewables, there is no twice cheaper available right now. Maybe through innovation somewhere in the future. Right now only hydro power is close to fossil fuel energy density. But it is only available in a few places around the world.
- Isinlor 4y agoSolar is on par with fosil fuels. And at least in EU with cap & trade system accounting for externalities as well as stopping sponsoring Russian wars and terrorism, I would not be surprised if renewables were twice as cheap.
- creativenolo 4y ago
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoAh, linear extrapolationists are again at their game. The world doesn't need 100% renewable energy, and does not need to build enormous power storage farms to deal with unstable power supply from solar and wind. The correct answer is nuclear power, and the sooner people will stop having NDS (Nuclear Derangement Syndrome), the better for humanity.
- cameronh90 4y agoHow do we deal with the security issues of nuclear, though? Look at the situation in Ukraine with Russia actively threatening the stability of their nuclear power plant as a bargaining chip. Attacks on nuclear facilities during war are quite common, even the US has done it a few times. Also, unstable countries need energy too - would it really be a good idea to start building nuclear power plants in Syria or Somalia? Perhaps we need an international UN agency in charge of all nuclear reactors in the world, with every country signing a defence pact? To be clear, I do want nuclear power, I just don't feel like society is stable enough to deliver it.
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoBy nuclear deterrence. None of this would have happened if Ukraine had nuclear weapons. And nuclear weapons are best developed when you have nuclear power production and a lot of nuclear physicists.
- Guthur 4y agoNonsense because non of it is actually renewable. There is an insane amount of commodity input into so called renewable energy sources. And what happens once you have two or more dry, becalmed winters, going to be hellishly cold when there is no juice in the battery and you've killed all meaningful hydrocarbon energy sources. On a long enough time line you will eventually not have enough storage to cover these scenarios. The idiocy of the narrative "climate change makes the climate unpredicable, solution become dependent on the climate", fucking moronic. The EU could be a revelation of what's to come. The current drought has brought hydro to it's limits, the progressive liberal foreign policy has starved it of hydrocarbons. If this winter is cold and becalmed europe will collapse and all of you bleeding heart liberal bear responsibility for the millions who will die. And if we do get through this winter we'll have the massive global shortfall in food due to the war on fertilizer both the Netherlands and Canada are waging. You know what, fuck the animals and fuck the climate I want to be able to eat and not freeze to death. No credit no control. No vote no power.
- d3ckard 4y agoMate, Europe ain’t gonna collapse. Even with cold winter, enough resources to keep citizens running will be found. We might have to cut production output, yes. There will be more climate related deaths, yes. But we ain’t gonna collapse.
- fatherzine 4y agoSystems subject to stress sometimes do exhibit a phase change, also known as "collapse". Hard to predict when and what shape, but the probability of a phase change is rather uncomfortable. When it happens, we will likely blame social / ethnic group X, because our brains are, sadly, hardwired for social scapegoating in face of severe grief.
- dgb23 4y agoThis reads like FUD. If more progress was made on the renewable energy front we would be in much better shape.
- Linda703 4y ago[dead]
- Brakenshire 4y agoHas anyone seen any good explanations or visualisations of how long term storage would be achieved? For instance in Britain solar in winter has 1/10th of the output in summer, and we can have lulls in wind output for many days at a time. Using these resources to reduce gas use makes sense, but our current plans call for about 30% of electricity generated from gas using carbon capture and storage. How would this be handled under a 100% renewable scenario? Is it just generating Hydrogen? Or it is that these intermittency gaps can be closed using long distance connectors? Has anyone done studies showing exactly where resources would need to be located and the length of connectors, modelled against weather and demand patterns?
- andy_ppp 4y agoPumped hydro and hot sand batteries should be enough if we get our act together and actually commit to something. There’s also no reason solar from Spain or Morocco couldn’t be wired in at some point. Obviously we currently have a chicken and egg situation where it’s not worth building the X times our peak need in renewables without the storage and not worth building the storage when renewables are a fraction rather than a multiple of our current supply.
- yisonPylkita 4y agoThe problem with getting electricity from Spain or Morocco (or any other country) during winter is not a technical but a political one. Once a nation energy security depends on an another nation you may end up in situation Germany found herself in
- andy_ppp 4y agoWell I’m pretty sure Morocco becoming as wealthy as Saudi would make it stable enough, one way or another.
- jl6 4y agoHydrogen for short term storage, ammonia for medium term storage. Both much less efficient than just using electricity directly, but the aim is to drive down the cost of generation so that the inefficiency doesn’t matter so much. There are also tons of other short-medium term storage solutions, and we probably need all of them that we can get our hands on, but hydrogen and ammonia are the ones that feel most likely to operate at grid scale.
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoJust like when dealing with the losing side of a war we need to have a serious debate into implementing an exit strategy for Oil&Gas companies. We have plenty of technical solutions, but they will all continue to face an enormous amount of friction due to Oil&Gas profits/lobby. We need a political solution and we need to have an honest debate on how to sunset a trillion dollar industry without them putting up a fight.
- jsty 4y agoNot just Oil & Gas companies - but oil and gas nations. There's quite a few geopolitically important countries that either derive a large proportion of their GDP / foreign exchange from hydrocarbons, or rely on them so heavily there's no practical path for transition by 2050. Compared to the difficulty in getting these nations to play a full and productive part in any transition (requiring essentially restructuring a large chunk of their economies), settling up with extractor companies will be a walk in the park.
- bobse 4y agoHow many paid "experts" do you need to "set the Science"?
- andrewclunn 4y agoCue substance free ideological posting in 3... 2...
- lettergram 4y agoI read these titles and always facepalm and laugh. If you remove researchers who have differing opinions *of course* you’ll get the claims you want. Particularly, when those researchers are funded in a way that incentivizes particular claims. Now to these easily debunked claims, look at energy production vs capacity vs consumption in Germany: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_Germany https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_Germany Even though renewable energy capacity is 60% renewables, energy consumption is only 10% renewables. This is every country. Because renewable energy comes in bursts. This also doesn’t include the fact it costs a ton of fossil fuel energy to produce a lot of these renewable systems (solar, wind turbines, batteries). I’m not saying this isn’t a “doable” goal, but only way you might get there by 2050 is destroying quality of life, population reduction and investing all resources into this space. You’d also have to force countries like China and Russia with force… so good luck.
- yisonPylkita 4y agoEspecially Russia since they’ll only benefit from climate change - destabilisation of Europe via refugees from Africa and more arable land in Taiga
- _ph_ 4y agoIf you think climate change leads to more arable land in Russia, well, I think you are wrong. And of course, Russia is missing the least arable land. They could do with some airplanes and more population in general though.
- _ph_ 4y agoYou are wrong in several points. First of all, if we switch from burning fossil fuels to electricity for providing most uses of energy, energy consumption falls by 2/3rds. Heat pumps are easily more than 4x as effective per unit of energy used than burning fossil fuels. Similar numbers for electric cars and many other usages. So we are litterally looking at a moving goal post :) Renewable energy also doesn't come in "bursts". Yes, the maximum available production varies over time, for that we need to compensate. By storage, by grids, by having more flexible loads (for many decades providers worked hard to make loads non-flexible to make their jobs easier, now it is the other way around). And of course, some amount of power2gas will provide us with perfectly renewable gas which can be easily stored for whenever it is needed - we only want to limit that because it uses more power than using the electricity directly. And no, to get there we are not "destroying quality of life". There is no idication it would even compared to our current quality of life. Quite the contrary, as cheap, clean energy will improve quality of life. You are also missing, that our quality of life isn't given. It currently is constantly reduced by the effects of climate change we are already experiencing. Europe is going through a catastrophic hot and dry summer. With ironically energy shortages as the water cooling for nuclear power plants is failing. Just being able to maintain todays quality of life would be quite an accomplishment, which can only be achieved by cutting CO2 emissions very quickly, if at all.
- xbryanx 4y agoI like Vaclav Smil’s shorthand tool for assessing these claims. Be suspicious of any predicted year for full renewable rollout that ends in a zero or a five.
- pjc50 4y agoThis is silly: the estimates are rounded, because there's huge uncertainty. It's a very long way away from "these plants will come online on these dates". Perhaps "2045 plus or minus five years"? We all understand how difficult software development time estimation is, right?
- carapace 4y agoFrom Smil this is a valid criticism in my opinion. He's got the data and he knows how to do the math, so he's basically saying come correct if you want to debate at his level.
- RappingBoomer 4y agothe establishment just loves to latch onto a narrative and push it till....either they win...or... there's a civil war...
- bedhead 4y agoI’ve researched this extensively and I don’t agree, so there’s that. This is a common insidious tactic of the media…pay attention to how presumptuous they are especially in headlines. I can’t even keep track of how many baseless claims they make as if they’re accepted fact anymore.
- titzer 4y agoIt blows my mind that the very same people who can't seem to talk about anything but growing the economy don't see the incredible opportunity to grow the economy that building tons of new green tech represents. Like, completely replacing the world's energy infrastructure is more jobs (and money) than all the defense projects and military tech we could ever think up, combined. It's almost like it was never about the economy, but just about keeping the existing set of corporations raking in the profits and protecting them from disruption.
- missedthecue 4y agoMy comment isn't related specifically to going green, but replacing infrastructure that works perfectly well just for jobs is basically the broken window fallacy in economics. Repaving the highway every six months would "create" lots of jobs too.
- bognition 4y agoYes, except the broken window fallacy doesn't quite work here for a few reasons: First, the current technology is already breaking. It needs to be updated and maintained. So why not invest the same money in the newer tech. Two, the current technology is way better. We will be able to get more bang for our buck with the newer technologies AND they have the benefit of not poisoning our sky.
- missedthecue 4y agoI was replying more to the original claim that people should support this because it creates jobs. In general I support green energy anyway.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoYes, historically, all major economic booms coincide with some dramatic evolution in the use of energy. If you stop thinking about renewables as some hippy pipe dream and start thinking about them as a roughly two orders of magnitude drop in cost for energy, it's immediately obvious that this is going to kick off another such boom and that it will happen a lot faster than some people expect precisely because of that drop in price. Initially, not a lot of people believed this and it was kind of expensive to e.g. put solar on your roof and even make the argument that it was at all economical to do so. That changed a few years ago and people around the world are doing the math and coming to the conclusion that these systems pay for themselves in well under half their supposed life time. Ever since that became obvious, there is a lot of demand for solar panels. Companies building more or better panels are popping up everywhere. There's a lot of innovation happening. And the net result is better, cheaper, technology produced at a rapidly expanding scale. We have already hit the point that even the subsidies and incentives that are available for this are not technically needed any more. IMHO, learning effects, and ongoing research will cause cost to drop much further still. We have nowhere near reached the point of what is technically feasible here at all. What happens when you drop the cost of energy by about 100x in a few decades or so? An economic boom is what happens. Things that used to be prohibitively expensive now become cheap to do. And people start doing these things as quickly as they can. You might think 100x is an exaggeration. But actually, we've already experienced that with solar in the past 20 years. Price parity was reached more than 5 years ago. I'm actually talking about another 100x improvement So four orders of magnitude in total. About 2 orders relative to fossil fuel powered energy, which is a fair benchmark because that's what we are trying to get rid off. At some point renewables are going to be so obviously cheaper that they start pushing out anything more expensive out of the market. The cheaper things get, the faster that happens. The more it happens, the faster learning effects, R&D, etc. will happen. That massive acceleration is basically what is causing people to move targets.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ngmc 4y agoReally glad to see this discussion! My former advisor, Mark Jacobson, is one of the authors of the paper cited in the article. His book "100% Clean, Renewable Energy and Storage for Everything" [1] is a good starting point for folks with a more technical background. I recently started working on my own version [2] for young people and beginners that uses code as a medium to explore these ideas. Perhaps more directly relevant for the HN crowd, Tom Greenwood's book "Sustainable Web Design" [3] provides simple strategies for reducing the climate impacts of the software systems we build. [1] https://web.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/WWSBook/WWSBook.html https://web.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/WWSBook/WWSBook... [2] https://goodenergy.cc https://goodenergy.cc [3] https://abookapart.com/products/sustainable-web-design/ https://abookapart.com/products/sustainable-web-design/
- Brakenshire 4y agoHi, are there Jacobson papers for 100% renewables looking at geographical distribution of generation, storage and interconnectors, then modelling them against weather and demand, or are they cruder than that? If those papers exist, can you recommend an accessible way to understand these models, and their outcomes? For instance, are there areas for wind generation which are more valuable that others, to provide a balance to regional lulls, and is that data published? Is model code available so that it can be run by any of us?
- ngmc 4y agoGreat question! The studies do consider the spatio-temporal distribution of generation and demand. Here's a recent paper [1] that develops roadmaps for 145 countries and has infographics with links to additional resources. I found the source code for the LOADMATCH model [2] used in the studies which can run on a laptop. You can email Mark about data, source code for the GATOR-GCMOM model [3], and advice on running it. And here's a talk [4] he gave on the topic at NASA Ames Research Center a few years back. [1] https://web.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/Articles/I/WWS-145-Countries.html https://web.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/Articles/I/WWS-... [2] https://github.com/mzjacobson/Public/blob/main/powerworld.f https://github.com/mzjacobson/Public/blob/main/powerworld.f [3] https://web.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/GATOR/GATOR-GCMOMHist.pdf https://web.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/GATOR/GATOR-GCM... [4] https://youtu.be/espLfnvuYps https://youtu.be/espLfnvuYps
- photochemsyn 4y agoThe tipping point has come and gone as far as the climate trajectory goes, although actions taken today will reduce the slope of the trajectory say 50 years from now. When you throw the rudder over on the Titanic too late, you must prepare for the impact. Hence this kind of messaging is rather futile: > "Many young people are depressed because they feel climate change cannot be stopped. We want to offer them hope by showing that our world can get all its energy needs from renewables at a price below that of fossil fuels. When we first proposed this, we were ridiculed, but this paper shows our ideas are now scientific mainstream", says Auke Hoekstra from the Eindhoven University of Technology in the Netherlands." The one (going to 100% renewables) no longer implies the other (stabilizing the climate system within the lifetime of anyone alive today). Hugely expensive steps must be taken - retreat from flood plains that will be experiencing 500-year floods every 5 years, securing water supplies to survive epic droughts (with the additional loss of much of the seasonal snowpack in many regions), building termite-mound like architecture to handle the record heat waves, moving critical infrastructure back from the coastlines to deal with rising sea levels and saltwater intrusion, dealing with insects that love these new warm conditions, etc. On top of that, replacing the existing fossil fuel infrastructure is going to cost trillions and require a complete reorganization of the global economic system - just look at all the oil tankers, pipelines, internal combustion engines, gas-and-coal fired power plants. No time to watch TikTok videos, it's going to be work, work, work. Scaling up industrial production of wind turbines, solar panels and batteries by a factor of what, 100X? Better get busy, humans. Think of it more as an exciting challenge, adapting to these frightening new conditions - interesting times!. Of course, we'll have to raid the wealth of the fossil fuel sector and their investors to pay for all this adaptation and industrial development. Sticking the major producers with the bill makes optional sense. Implementing a ban on the global trade in fossil fuels would also be reasonable under these conditions (note that this was the first major step in eliminating the practice of chattel slavery, for comparison).
- ErikVandeWater 4y agoIt's all about the tradeoff. 100% renewable energy would nuke the economy.
- DoingIsLearning 4y agohttps://twitter.com/roshart/status/429501812740079616 https://twitter.com/roshart/status/429501812740079616
- ErikVandeWater 4y agoFalse dichotomy.
- kkfx 4y agoWhy not offer a small list of most relevant studies then? I can claim there are hundreds of studies and that MIGHT be true or not, offer a small glimpse is not only useful to teach readers looking for sources but also to prove I've done my research not just claim to have done it. Beside that: I doubt. Cyclically we see promise, like IBM research that cyclically say they achieve a hyper-big advances in storage, something that "in the near future" can store Zettabyte of data in a rice grain etc, and I still have to see anything even similar. I have built my new home, just six years ago, well insulated, airtight, with proper ventilation, recently upgraded from passive temperature recovery (classic VMC with a paper heat-exchanger) to a heat-pump one, with a small p.v. and lithium storage, all electric again with heat-pumps etc. well it can potentially be "autonomous" IF I'm willing to waste a very big amount of money in a very big battery, much more space for solar panels to have enough energy to recharge the bigger battery AND still depending on a grid or generator for backup because a "reasonably bigger" battery (BEVs alike size) suffice to be comfortable just from a day to the next. Just two day means I need more land to harvest enough energy from the Sun. Oh and that being in France south Alps so in a significantly sunny place. Oh I'm just talking about a home, not a factory. Sure we can already made let's say a glass production AND recycling factory 100% circular and renewable, we just need mountain hydro nearby. Enough, perhaps, if we are Norway with many mountains, water, little population. Or maybe Iceland with geothermal. Hardly for France. So far we have seen MANY promises in terms of new battery tech, but essentially nothing really ready. Potentially in 2050 we can even have finally achieved nuclear fusion, witch is renewable formally. But we can't forecast that. It's a hope. It might be even computed in a game-of-if: if we finally discover a battery tech with this and that characteristic we can produce on scale with this and that intensity what time it take to spread it? It's still a study, but just an hypothetical one. What we see so far is that FOR HOMES we can made single-family homes almost everywhere and power that with electricity only at rate "small enough" to be sustainable even at some arctic latitudes. This on scale means we need abandon dense tall-buildings since YES, we can made them TODAY with similar energy needs BUT we can't really upgrade them in the future, so to be future proof we need homes like cars, with a longer life-cycle but still small enough to be created and re-created after a certain amount of times (like a single human life) to align them with current needs and tech at any point in time. It might be doable if we agree to do so even before 2050 at least in western world, but I see no real push to do so. Just few do so on their own, no plans to design a new society seems to go in that direction, UN New Urban Agenda goes actually in the OPPOSITE direction. The rest are collection of dreams.
- devwastaken 4y agoTell that to the electric grid. Natural gas is still king in the U.S, and always will be. That's because it's the only power source that can scale with demand. When everyone turns their AC on in the summer, or heat in the winter, renewables can only offset the cost.
- icu 4y agoThe issue isn't that we as a race can reach 100% renewable energy, it's at what cost? Right now displacing fossil fuels comes at such an enormous financial cost it's an all of humanity thing or none (or very little) of humanity thing. Also there would be such high costs for poor nations that rich nations would have to pay way more than their proportional share. Sadly it's wishful thinking to get the entire human population/their respective representatives and despots to agree to solve this problem. Our best hope is that a new technological solution with near zero marginal cost emerges and displaces fossil fuels as much as possible.