12 ms·
A meteor or alien tech: Harvard professor plans UFO expedition
- seydor 4y agopoor professor
- sethjr5rtfgh 4y ago
- balentio 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- endofreach 4y agoUh, i already felt like star wars is slowly starting for real. I am not into (pop) sci-fi movies, but i‘m up for some sci-no.
- gurumeditations 4y agoSeems to have nothing to do with aliens and the article is in such broken English it’s almost incomprehensible.
- jkqwzsoo 4y agoThe “article” is a transcript of sections of the video. Removing the culture war bit about Galileo being cancelled, we have: “It’s not a philosophical question whether we live in an environment where objects are floating around that are representing extraterrestrial technologies. We just need to use our telescopes and find out. […] Once I realized that we found an object from a technological origin that was produced elsewhere, I would not seek approval from anyone else. I don’t need likes on twitter. I just want to know what it is.” He doesn’t seem to be saying “it’s aliens”, but rather “If it’s aliens, I want to know — it’s not a matter of faith, if we find evidence of it, it’ll be true”. His use of “Once I realized” is confusing, but I believe he’s speaking in the hypothetical that aliens are confirmed. There is, of course, a massive leap from “an object from outside the solar system hit Earth and was very strong” to “because this object was very strong it might have been made by aliens”. I also don’t see any reason why the fragments they’re looking for should be magnetic.
- iLoveOncall 4y agoSo the only thing that has been confirmed is that it is a meteorite from outside of the solar system. Jumping to the conclusion that it is "possible alien tech" seems a liiiittle bit of a stretch.
- gammarator 4y agoEven the first part is not confirmed.
- trhr 4y agoTechnically, a 99.999% likelihood is not confirmed, but it's good enough for the girls I go out with.
- pavel_lishin 4y ago> "We’re planning to board the ship and build a sled and a magnet attached to it that will scoop the ocean floor. And we will go back and forth, like mowing the lawns across the region, 10 kilometers in size and collect with the magnets, all the fragments that are attracted to it, and then brush them off and study their composition in the laboratory." Wouldn't this only work for iron fragments of a meteor? If the theory is that it's made of something else, then I don't think this would be helpful.
- themanmaran 4y agoIt's possible that it's an iron alloy. Which can be stronger than iron, and also magnetic. But in regards to feasibility of such a project, I feel that 10km range is a major understatement. Think of the effort it took to find fragments of Malaysia Flight 370, even with a pretty narrow path. And that search was the most expensive search operation in history at $155MM [1]. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaysia_Airlines_Flight_370#:~:text=On%2017%20January,US%24155%20million https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaysia_Airlines_Flight_370#:....
- Kon-Peki 4y ago> Using data from government censors primarily used for national security as part of our missile defense system If it got past the government censors it has to be super pure and clean. So not an alloy; it must be previously unimagined material!
- aaaaaaaaaaab 4y agoMaybe it's the fabled wokium!
- AlbertCory 4y agoThis gave me a moment of panic: did I miss some big story? But no: I already knew about the pieces of debris.
- gsatic 4y agoHe might find "polymetallic nodules". Supposedly there are large fields of them on the ocean floor.
- themodelplumber 4y agoInteresting pitch: To conduct this kind of search & retrieve project for an object out in space would cost $1B+, so we'll look here on earth at this obvious outlier which government agencies have already stated they are confident has come from outside our solar system. I mean it makes a certain type of probabilistic sense, and in multiple ways. If you fund this there's a better-than-lottery chance that you'll at least be part of something big, whether alien tech is in there or not... BTW I'm planning to check out his podcast appearances, so here's a link for others who are interested. https://www.listennotes.com/top-podcasts/avi-loeb/ https://www.listennotes.com/top-podcasts/avi-loeb/
- jackmott42 4y agoThis is Avi's second questionable alien obsession/quest. Not sure if it is something mental, grift, or perfectly rational impulse to check out incredibly unlikely but incredibly amazing possibilities.
- wrnr 4y agoHe is a kwak, instead of actual science he shills these ideas on podcasts because the general public is interested in it or something like that. Whenever I meet someone from Harvard I think of this guy and automatically think less of them. Maybe that is wrong of me but then the Harvard alumni ought to have called him out on his BS.
- jackmott42 4y agoI tentatively agree with that take, but am trying to be charitable. The reason I tend to think this is right is that his podcast arguments for why umamua? was probably alien tech were either disingenuous or displayed incredible ignorance. i.e.: pretending that nobody had any explanation for how it accelerated without any visible tail.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoDo we want no one contemplating the n>1 theory of life in the universe?
- wonderwonder 4y agoMeh, good luck to him, he is not hurting anyone and he seems to genuinely be a smart guy that believes what he says. Its ok to be eccentric.
- thisjeremiah 4y agothat’s too bad he crashed
- matonias 4y agoWhat other kind of alien material was found in meteorites?
- 015a 4y agoTo not bury the lead: His team studied data the government made available from military missile tracking systems, which conveniently also false-positives on asteroids. There was one in 2014 which slammed into the Pacific Ocean at a speed at least twice that of the speed stars around us move relative to the sun, which makes it likely to be extra-solar. Based on that speed & how much burned upon entry, they concluded its material must be tougher than iron. They're planning an expedition to the oceanic area around Papa New Guinea, mostly funded through private donations, to recover the object.
- caseyohara 4y agoLede, not lead.
- harmonious 4y ago"You should have written 'lede' instead of 'lead'.", not "'Lede', not 'lead'.".
- caseyohara 4y agoI wrote it that way only to mirror the other corrective comment that was posted before mine.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- adamzochowski 4y agoThe world says "leading news story" and therefore "burying the lead". Lede is an american thing. Parent could have been a british or canadian neighbour with their british colourful spelling.
- MichaelCollins 4y ago> The spelling lede (/ˈliːd/, from Early Modern English) is also used in American English, originally to avoid confusion with the printing press type formerly made from the metal lead or the related typographical term "leading". Huh.
- harvey9 4y agoCamouflage by Joe Haldeman is the sci fi book that springs to mind.
- jandrese 4y agoThe title had me remembering the line from Michael Creighton's "Sphere" where one of the people asks why we always imagine alien spacecraft crashing on land when 70% of the world is covered in ocean.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoI think I've seen this movie before; just don't let anybody touch the strange Sphere thing and you should be alright. Seriously though, this doesn't make much sense to me. Finding shipwrecks even when you know they exist and what general area they should be in is hard enough. This sort of search is a huge money sink, the ships, towed sonars, etc all cost a ton of money to operate.
- gfodor 4y ago$1.5M ain’t much depending on your priors and how much you value the discovery of extraterrestrial tech.
- jmull 4y agoLet’s estimate the expected value for that $1.5M… My estimate is something less than $0.01.
- gfodor 4y agoYou have it backwards, you have to calculate the expected value of the mission and see if it’s less than 1.5M. For example, if odds of success are one in 10k for a discovery worth $1T then it works out.
- jmull 4y agoI’m afraid we’re taking about the same expected value: odds of success * value of success
- upupandup 4y agoha! I was gonna mention that movie here but I don't know what to make of this. This professor seems legitimately convinced its possible but who will believe him?
- jaredhallen 4y agoRight. And magnets? How do we know it's ferrous?
- titzer 4y agoI don't see anything in the original research that suggests it is "tech". I think the article completely made this up. To be pedantic, nearly all of the material that we are made of came from other stars, manufactured in their nuclear fusion and supernovae. I think what they mean is a macroscopic object that was formed in another star system, which they've inferred from its incoming trajectory.
- MichaelCollins 4y ago> I don't see anything in the original research that suggests it is "tech". I think the article completely made this up. It's because it's coming from Avi Loeb, the guy who suggested Oumuamua might be a Rama-style spacecraft. I don't think he's dead set on alien hypotheses, but he wants them to at least be taken seriously as possibilities.
- titzer 4y agoAh, I didn't know it was the same guy. It's not clear, at least to me, how extreme his original claims even were, considering how fast things get distorted with sensationalist media these days. He does seem to be a quite serious scientist and not a crank.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoHe has an interview with Lex Fridman here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=plcc6E-E1uU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=plcc6E-E1uU I haven't listened to the whole thing, but he seems to think that aliens visiting our solar system is likely enough that it makes sense to look for. He falls short of the confident certainty I usually expect from cranks though, he's talking about investigating possibilities. I think he's eccentric, but I wouldn't call him a crank.
- wefarrell 4y agoI don't think it's an unreasonable hypothesis. At this point we know that the government has been cataloging evidence of advanced craft in the air and ocean that behave intelligently and are far beyond the capabilities of any major world power. A small portion of that evidence has been released to the public and officials with clearance (including elected officials) have stated that the evidence they've seen is significant. Doesn't mean its aliens but unless there is some elaborate conspiracy there is compelling evidence of technology in our planet that violates our current understanding of physics. Loeb is connecting dots and hypothesizing that there is a connection between that phenomena and extrasolar objects. It's not a completely unreasonable theory and I think it's worth examination.
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoThe title is a little silly. It’s from outside our solar system, but there’s zero evidence suggesting it’s technological or made by aliens. It’s just a meteor that was going really fast, and it was made of something that was sturdy enough not to break up too much.
- KMnO4 4y agoAlien doesn’t mean “alien life form”. It means “not from here”.
- dorkwood 4y agoWhat about tech? Can tech arise organically?
- NotYourLawyer 4y ago
- ALittleLight 4y agoI would think that, if other people agree with his analysis and this does seem extra-solar, and we have a reasonable guess as to where it might have landed, a couple million would be a small price to check out an extra-solar object.
- NotYourLawyer 4y ago
- supernova87a 4y agoI will just say that in the astronomy faculty community, although Avi Loeb is the head of the Harvard astro department, his "research" has garnered him questionable and often head-shaking disapproval and a decrease in respect from colleagues. Some, bordering on many, think that he's just out to grab headlines and has become a bad joke at this point (past examples: solar system interlopers as "UFOs", etc). Maybe Avi says that he worked his way to this position to be able to tackle interesting and off-the-path subjects, but somehow his work doesn't feel like it has the same integrity as expected from the chair of a leading institution. Or maybe that he goes to tv news channels preferentially over arxiv publishing. And maybe it's just something that happens to professors with age (like one's parents) -- they start going down the weird ideas rabbit hole.
- gloriousduke 4y ago> maybe that he goes to tv news channels preferentially over arxiv publishing https://arxiv.org/abs/2110.15213 https://arxiv.org/abs/2110.15213
- xqcgrek2 4y ago4 citations, 3 of which are self-citations. Entirely inconsequential.
- protastus 4y agoI think Avi Loeb is legitimately excited about this topic. He's also aware that the public is tremendously excited and inspired about the possibility of UFOs, alien flybys of the solar system, etc. I think he's achieved professional recognition, paid his dues playing the game of academia (very successfully), and is now pursuing things that he finds most exciting. The man has co-authored a thousand papers, literally, so I doubt he'd get much marginal excitement from hypothetical paper #1001, i.e., another instance of fitting a curve through noisy data to build support for an obscure model that very few researchers care about. He has also pointed out that it's an invitation to ridicule in academic circles to talk openly about UFOs. He doesn't care though (why would he?), and that for sure is triggering folks who take themselves very seriously.
- barbarr 4y agoCan the title be revised to something like "Harvard Professor on Quest for Possible Alien Tech that Crashed in the Pacific Ocean"? Current phrasing makes it seem like the professor crashed into the ocean.
- AlbertCory 4y agoThe actual article's title was "Harvard Professor Believes Alien Tech Could Have Crashed Into Pacific Ocean" which is more clear. Although to make it less woo-woo flying saucer-ish, I might have said: "Harvard Professor Believes Meteor That Crashed Into Ocean Was Alien Metal"
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoIf it was real alien tech it could be anywhere doing anything by now. If we're not going to just assume aliens 'non-terrestrial' might be more accurate.
- AlbertCory 4y agoRight. I was just correcting the grammar, not his (wild) assumptions.
- dylan604 4y agoThat's how I understood the title.
- effingwewt 4y agoYea I was relieved it wasn't just me. I was confused when I started reading the article.
- tacker2000 4y agoI also thought that the professor crashed into the pacific because he was on a quest for alien tech.
- rgrieselhuber 4y agoIf aliens are advanced enough to come all the way here and hide pretty well, how are they not advanced enough to not crash all the time?
- MichaelCollins 4y agoDerelict spacecraft? I don't believe it, the odds against it are astronomical, but derelict spacecraft are a popular sci-fi trope.
- sammalloy 4y agoAlso, we’ve crashed numerous probes at the end of their lifecycle into many of the objects in our own Solar System. If an interstellar probe from a civilization like our own completed its mission, would it also be programmed to self-destruct itself in a similar manner? I think it’s a highly unlikely series of events, but there is a method to the madness.
- tiborsaas 4y agoMaybe they are suffering from floating point math too and rounding errors added up :D
- exitb 4y agoThis is more like a remote, uncontacted tribe "discovering" other civilizations via trash that washes up on their shore. Given enough scale, this wouldn't be an unlikely event. Who knows, maybe the universe is littered with bits and pieces of ancient Dyson spheres.
- conanite 4y ago> Using data from government censors Should be "sensors" (used correctly a few sentences later). Is this a text-to-speech thing, or written by a non-native speaker, or just appalling editing? > Once I realized that we found an object from a technological origin that was produced elsewhere. Difficulty to having parse.
- mypalmike 4y agoThis article lists 3 authors and is riddled with basic grammar and spelling problems. One can only imagine what factual errors it contains.
- har_ry 4y agoSo (and I welcome correction here) the logic is: An asteroid travelling at great speed would surely burn up in the atmosphere (ice ect.), therefore this asteroid must be made of iron or stronger (a manufactured alloy). And thus Loebs conclusion that since a manufactured alloy must have been made by someone somewhere, it's worth a look?
- subjectsigma 4y agoThis guy's name has come up before in HN. His stuff seemed well-written but the conclusions he came to were a little outlandish. What is the likelihood that this guy just wants to study a cool asteroids and is using aliens as an excuse? EDIT: I know this is not HN kosher and I don't normally do this, but why am I being down voted? This is one of the most inoffensive comments I've ever posted. Not angry, just completely baffled
- EddySchauHai 4y agoIf AI Ethics can get as much funding as it does to philosophy departments, let this guy study cool asteroids in case it's sent by aliens!
- drewg123 4y agoEnglish is so ambiguous that the title made me think that the professor himself had crashed into the ocean. Saying "Alien Tech That Crashed in.." would clear things up, but I guess it would be too long?
- yuan43 4y agoReconstructing what the article appears to be saying: 1. a catalog of government sensor data on meteorite strikes was discovered 2. based on the data, those strikes that could have originate outside of the solar system were gathered 3. one hit in particular appears to be harder than iron based on its speed and loss Then: > Despite the government releasing limited data due to national security concerns - he had discovered something groundbreaking. A paper he wrote with his student laid out what he believed to be true. But three years after writing his findings, a major development confirmed what he knew all along. Great, let's find that paper and see what's up. Wait, where's the link? No matter, just tell me the journal and I'll find it. Nope. Ah, that's right, this is the popular media where such things simply aren't done.
- linkdink 4y agoTo be fair, if you're not going to Google it, you're probably more of a popular media reader anyway. There are no pictures in the paper to look at. https://arxiv.org/abs/1904.07224 https://arxiv.org/abs/1904.07224
- yuan43 4y agoDid google and didn't find it. Maybe my Google fu just isn't as advanced as yours. Then again, why not just include the link? It turns out the key here is to use "Abraham" not "Avi" in the search. The latter returns crapola and the former yields your link a few hits down. Don't worry about lack of pictures (there actually are some figures), I'm pretty good at this English thing. Turns out the object was quite small: > Given the impact speed of the meteor, ∼ 44.8 km s−1, and the total impact energy, 4.6 × 1018 ergs, the meteor mass was approximately 4.6 × 105 g. Assuming bulk density values of 1.7 g/cm3 and 0.9 g/cm3 for Type II and Type IIIa objects respectively, we obtain a radius, R, of 0.4m – 0.5m for a spherical geometry (Ceplecha 1988; Palotai et al. 2018). The small size of the object was something the article didn't address.
- worldvoyageur 4y agohttps://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2019arXiv190407224S/abstract https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2019arXiv190407224S/abstra... The payload: " Based on the CNEOS catalog of bolide events, we identify the ∼0.45m meteor detected at 2014-01-08 17:05:34 UTC as originating from an unbound hyperbolic orbit with 99.999\% confidence. The U.S. Department of Defense has since verified that "the velocity estimate reported to NASA is sufficiently accurate to indicate an interstellar trajectory... Its high LSR speed implies a possible origin from the deep interior of a planetary system or a star in the thick disk of the Milky Way galaxy." "
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoMaybe it's like that TV series, Debris? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debris_(TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debris_(TV_series)
- sammalloy 4y agoI was open minded about "Debris", but only made it through the first episode and had to stop watching. It was really bad. Just terrible. However, if anyone out there likes this kind of science fiction, I must highly recommend the 2019 series "Project Blue Book" starring the superb Aidan Gillen (GoT fame) playing the character of J. Allen Hynek. Unfortunately, this amazing series was canceled after only two seasons, likely due to poor timing, since it was showing during the chaos and uncertainty at the height of the pandemic. But every episode is well written and the acting, for the most part, is really good. Check it out. One of the things I like most about the Project Blue Book series, is how they try to recreate the 1950s-1960s aesthetic, somewhat following in the footsteps of what "Mad Men" sought to achieve in terms of recreating a bygone era.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoThanks. I'll check it out. Debris has disappeared from the firmament. You can't find it anywhere. They are syndicating Space: 1999, but not Debris. Kinda tells you something, there...
- Zigurd 4y agoFinding an interstellar object is spectacular enough. Why overhype it?
- numair 4y agoAren’t there Chinese navy vessels running around that patch of the South Pacific? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Azorian https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Azorian I have a feeling the professor will be able to raise the funds he needs for his expedition.
- nadavision 4y agoUnrelated to the contents on the article but the wording of the title made me think that the Harvard Professor crashed into the Pacific Ocean. You might want to consider clearing it up.
- _jal 4y agoTo be fair, if a Harvard professor impacted the ocean that hard and on that trajectory, that would also be news.
- rossdavidh 4y agoI don't think a Harvard professor could be retrieved from the ocean floor using a magnet. Unless he had been an android, in which case I guess that would be worth investigating.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- xqcgrek2 4y agoIt's Avi Loeb. He's basically considered a crackpot in physics/astronomy.
- twobitshifter 4y agoThe meteor he’s searching for is 45cm (18 inches)
- peanut_worm 4y agoHow on earth do they think they are going to find it
- Rackedup 4y agodiameter I assume...
- bediger4000 4y ago> Using data from government censors I found the sentence starting with this phrase hard to read.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andrew_ 4y ago"I don't need likes on Twitter" I sincerely hope this becomes a trend.
- motohagiography 4y agoI feel like the smarter play would be pitching or investing in a startup to work on changing the economics of gravimetry, sonar and undersea robotics that would be required to identify technology signatures and find objects with extra-terrestrial origin to get talent working on one of the most important existential questions facing our species, and the reward is the mineral resources you find with the tech along the way.
- peanut_worm 4y agoI am going to assume everything in the article is false until its actually found
- trhr 4y agoUFO nuts are probably already making memes like, "See, even Harvard believes in E.T." Just like they did about the gov't report that said "of course there are unidentified objects in our skies." But, unlike their favorite Facebook group's grainy phone videos, this sounds fairly real. Drag the thing up and put it under a spectrograph, and if we haven't seen the stuff in it before, figure out what that means.
- Sporktacular 4y ago"It's not a philosophical question whether we live in an environment where objects are flawed. Around that are representing extraterrestrial technologies." I can't make sense of these sentences. And the spelling mistakes are helping either. "Today [Galileo Galilei] would have been canceled on social media." For what exactly? And his this guy not seen the quality of social media commentary? The bar is loooow. Spectacular but unfounded claims are a mundanity and it's worrying that he's mixing these culture warrior talking points with science. "Once I realized that we found an object from a technological origin that was produced elsewhere." Unfounded spectacular claims just like this. The object is interstellar maybe, but where has he shown evidence of a technological origin? This is pretty important. How is it just left unchallenged? It's a weird article. The video looks like a shot from The Thunderbirds and it reads like something from a local station affiliate run twice through translation software.
- tsol 4y ago>For what exactly? Saying unpopular things that society deemed harmful? Not necessarily defending the guy I didn't read everything he said, but that's what comes to mind
- areoform 4y ago30 years ago, Lobe was the first to suggest that we should look for exoplanet with the help of gravitational lensing. https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&hl=en&user=CvQxOmwAAAAJ&citation_for_view=CvQxOmwAAAAJ:d1gkVwhDpl0C https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&h... He was also amongst the first to study the epoch of reionization that now forms one of the primary mission directives of the JWST. And those weren't his only firsts, he was also the amongst the first to study the formation of supermassive black holes in the early universe. https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&hl=en&user=CvQxOmwAAAAJ&citation_for_view=CvQxOmwAAAAJ:9yKSN-GCB0IC https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&h... He has had such an amazing career and has done such great work that it physically pains me to see him slide into Nobel disease this way. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_disease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_disease He has always been fascinated by the search for extraterrestrial intelligence, but he was such a reasoned person who proposed great techno signatures like looking for pollution as a means to detect industrial-age civilizations. It’s like watching a giant stumble and hurt himself on purpose. And it gets worse when non-technical people come up to me and ask, “have you heard of Avi Loeb?” Instead of being a beacon for enlightenment, he has gone down the path of spreading conspiratorial ignorance. It is painful to watch such a great career fall this way. And no, based on my conversations with my professional astronomer friends, no one inside the field takes him seriously anymore. They don’t laugh at him either, they just don’t take him seriously. It’s probably why he doesn’t seem to have a more prominent role with the JWST. Interesting projects don’t want to associate with him anymore. It’s sad.
- anigbrowl 4y agoEven if this thing in the ocean is just a lump of heavy metals ejected from some remote cataclysm, that would still be interesting in its own right. Is it really so terrible that he wants to go and look at an actual physical thing from space instead of finishing his career staring at computer screens? Give him a few million dollars and let him have his field trip.
- jackmott 4y ago
- m3kw9 4y agoThere’d be war over it if it was proven extraterrestrial tech