5 ms·
It shouldn't count as a vulnerability that you can get root of a device that you have physical possession of. If there's any real vulnerability here, it's that
by josephcsible 4y ago
It shouldn't count as a vulnerability that you can get root of a device that you have physical possession of. If there's any real vulnerability here, it's that having root of your terminal gives you any extra privileges to the rest of the network.
- bilekas 4y agoI have to agree to be fair. Physical access is obviously incredibly different than exploiting a vulnerable even a particularly egregious design flaw. Wouters has to literally short the board. That said it is a clever approach and it’s good it was discovered by someone without nefarious intentions.
- bdcravens 4y agoIf a system is designed to not allow that access, and you can compromise that design, it is most definitely a vulnerability.
- nine_k 4y agoIf a system is not resilient against rooting a terminal which is in user's physical possession, it's a design flaw. Or, rather, the more resilient the system as a whole is to compromises of individual terminals, the better the design is. Assuming such compromise never happens would be outright incompetent.
- mlyle 4y agoYou might very well want both E.g. You may want to protect end users against implants and other attacks from physical tampering with their terminals. You might not want hostile parties to have an easy time reverse engineering terminals so they can more easily search for remote vulnerabilities in the terminals. You may not want to hand hostile parties a phased array optimized to transmit to Starlink running arbitrary software of their choice, along with keys identifying the terminal, because even though you think the satellites and authentication mechanisms are robust, making it hard to get this information adds defense in depth.
- nine_k 4y agoCertainly. Best defence is layered. It makes every layer an impediment for an attacker, but does not fail completely if a layer or two is breached. Among other things, it buys time to react.
- Denvercoder9 4y agoI'm convinced that it's impossible to prevent anyone that can physically tamper with a system from having full privileges on that system, as a result of physics. The only way to truly protect information is to make use of quantum effects, and we've only just started doing that in labs. Everything else is just making it harder. So, if you make things harder and someone comes along that invests more effort to overcome, can you really call that a vulnerability? It'd be a real vulnerability if with this access to a user terminal they could elevate permissions on the satellites, but that hasn't been shown (yet?).
- akira2501 4y ago> can you really call that a vulnerability? Yes. Just because executing the attack doesn't seem to get you anything particularly valuable doesn't make it "not a vulnerability." We're not personally insulting it, we're just describing reality.
- xaduha 4y ago> Everything else is just making it harder. If it's hard enough that only state actors can potentially do it, then what does it matter in real life that it's theoretically vulnerable?
- czx4f4bd 4y agoYes. Vulnerabilities exist with respect to a system's expected functionality and must be understood and weighed against other requirements to determine the system's security model. Even if you think the expected functionality is stupid or impossible, that doesn't change the fact that the system has a particular expectation that it doesn't meet and a mechanism by which that expectation can be violated, i.e. a vulnerability. To put it another way, consider physical locks, which must inherently be able to resist direct physical tampering by an adversary. Under your definition, no flaw in a lock could be considered a vulnerability since any lock can eventually be cracked. The problem is that this doesn't provide us any useful insight, it just makes the word "vulnerability" useless. It's already well-known that any lock can eventually be cracked, but tradeoffs still have to be made in deciding which lock to use for a certain situation.
- forgotmypw17 4y agoI think it should count as a defect that you can't get root of a device that you have physical possession of.
- xaduha 4y agoMicrosoft and Sony appear to have solved it for their gaming consoles. Satellite TV providers definitely solved it by now after learning from their mistakes. All in all there are plenty of devices in the world that are protected against physical access, so if Starlink tried doing that and failed, then that's definitely through an exploited vulnerability.
- armchairhacker 4y ago> Microsoft and Sony appear to have solved it for their gaming consoles Have they? I know Apple an Nintendo have been trying for years and we have jailbreak and Homebrew, I believe there is even jailbreak for nintendo switch. If there isn't yet an exploit to gain root on Xbox and PS5, it's only a matter of time.
- extheat 4y agoThere is one for PS5, no hardware hack needed. I don’t know about Xbox.
- belltaco 4y ago>If there isn't yet an exploit to gain root on Xbox and PS5, it's only a matter of time Xbox One didn't have a root exploit for its entire lifetime and counting. It was released back in 2013. That's nine years. So one could say MS "solved it".
- Scoundreller 4y ago> Satellite TV providers definitely solved it by now after learning from their mistakes. I don't know if they really "solved" it. I think the appetite for new hacks dwindled with broadband internet everywhere and streaming services. Cat doesn't care for the mouse so much when there's kibble everywhere.
- xaduha 4y agoUsing this table for reference and the fact that proper smartcards like banking cards and SIM cards are secure I'm pretty confident calling modern CA systems secure too. If some providers don't have one of those, then it's probably because it's not worth it for them to switch or upgrade. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conditional_access#Digital_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conditional_access#Digital_sys... EDIT: More than that, some recent ones even solved so called 'card sharing' which is basically using a legitimate card to transmit control words over network to many users. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Card_sharing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Card_sharing
- ec109685 4y agoCurious why an iPhone been susceptible to this type of hack before?
- bee_rider 4y agoI think you mean: > Curious why an iPhone hasn't been susceptible to this type of hack before? The answer is probably, "it's complicated." These sort of hardware hacks are quite clever, and typically depend on using chips in unintended ways -- I mean most circuits will have some undefined behavior if you start shorting parts! There are lots of reasons an iPhone might not get a widely popularized exploit like this. Firstly it might be low-priority -- iPhones are general purpose computing devices, so there are usually software bugs for people who want to root their iPhones. Second, it might legitimately be more difficult. Apple has lots of experience in hardware, their circuits might be more robust. And iPhones are quite tightly integrated, it might be hard to sort out which parts you need to short when everything is on a handful of chips.
- croes 4y agoSo if you can get root on a PS5 or iPhone it's not a vulnerability?
- dymk 4y agoThe iPhone is built to be resistant to physical attacks, such as decapping chips or inserting compromised chips. It's an advertised, first class feature that simply having the iPhone shouldn't give you access to its contents or let you circumvent its security measures. This is different than a Starlink base station. Base stations aren't built to be hardened against a physical attacks, and are rather intended to be untrusted links to the satellites. So it's kind of in a grey area, but I would also not consider this a vulnerability of the Starlink base station itself, in the same way that rooting an iPhone with physical access would be a vulnerability.
- o_1 4y agoHow many versions of the iPhone were required to become resistant to jailbreak. SpaceX should have a leg up on the sins of the past, but its an entirely different concept / product. The security improvements are on a curve of maturity, I imagine software and platform management will mitigate this until hardware updates are released. I will say Starlink customers shouldn't have to pay exorbant upgrade costs due to security vulnerabilities in past hardware. That is an ethical boundary SpaceX must not cross.
- unixbane 4y agoYeah this is a typical article where the author gets all excited and explains the technical details of the "hack", because it can be called a "hack". But it seems nothing was done here other than some reverse engineering and bypassing tamper proofing to gain access to his own OS.
- sllabres 4y agoI think we have left this level a long time ago where one could answer: The system is in a physically secured location. As long as there is no physical access it should be safe. See mobiles like iPhones, gaming devices like XBox, Playstation etc. authenticators like chipcards or security token and HSM. All have to asume that the attacker has physical access to the device. Security Engineering Ch. 16 "Physical Tamper Resistance" is a good read for some special classes of devices. But I would recommend all topics from this book even unrelated to this thread. ;)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]