4 ms·
This seems like the right place to ask, does anyone know a lightweight Explorer alternative? I basically just want Windows XP explorer on Windows 10. I don't ne
by andai 4y ago
This seems like the right place to ask, does anyone know a lightweight Explorer alternative? I basically just want Windows XP explorer on Windows 10. I don't need tabs or dual panes, I just want it to be as fast as it used to be.
Whenever I run XP in a VM, I'm amazed that explorer windows not only open instantly, but fully drawn! In W10 it takes half a second to even respond, and then another half second while it draws the UI elements one by one.
If I move a folder, Sublime Text detects it instantly, but the same explorer window I used to move it takes several seconds to register the change it itself made...
- Daedren 4y agoI'm a fan of Directory Opus. It's -far- more feature filled than Explorer, yet it's much faster at opening (assuming the service is turned on at startup).
- opless 4y ago+1 for DOpus, though as much as I pester the devs they refuse to develop for the mac :-P
- jmnicolas 4y agoIMHO DOpus is an OS in itself ! Way too bloated / complicated for my tastes. Of course YMMV.
- Double_a_92 4y agoI just don't like the design of this, or any other explorer alternative for that matter. It always has some very outdated feel to it... combined with an extremely cluttered view. Like texts and icons and buttons and options that I would never need all over the place.
- ivank 4y agoAll of those toolbars and lister layouts are extremely customizable.
- Double_a_92 4y agoThat's also another point. I don't want to have to customize a software before it's reasonably usable. I probably don't even know myself how I would like it to be. It's the UX designer's job to make it pretty, not the user's.
- andai 4y agoCan you get rid of all of them? My preferred UI: Location bar Sidebar (file tree) | File List Would be nice if each feature you don't need could be removed from the purchase price. I think the version I want would end up having a negative price tag ;)
- UberFly 4y ago"Like texts and icons and buttons and options" Oh the horror... :)
- Hard_Space 4y agoAfter 10+ years of DOpus, I can't imagine ever going back to Explorer, except for the odd outlier use case. I'm sorry to see people saying that it's 'cluttered'. That's exactly the way I like it, and you can make it as basic as you like.
- thrownaway561 4y agolink to Directory Opus https://www.gpsoft.com.au/ https://www.gpsoft.com.au/
- vbezhenar 4y agoThat's not my experience with Windows. Explorer works pretty much instantly for me. Did you try to reinstall Windows? Sounds like issue with some shell extensions or something like that.
- dspillett 4y agoI've not known, Explorer to open instantly, or what I would call instantly, even on a fresh install, for some time IIRC. Heck, the amount of times I hit win+R to kick something off and that takes so long to open that the first couple of characters are missed and go to whatever window I had in focus at the time, is irritating. It certainly gets a lot worse when Explorer has been running a while (presumably this is why it has its own special case in Task Manager – pick Explorer and “end task” becomes “restart”) and its memory use has grown significantly (this is likely at least in part due to shell extension though the only one with any complexity I have installed here is MS's own TFS integration, and I have nothing like that running at home ATM). Other things similarly take a while, like registering an update made elsewhere. These can be quite arbitrary, sometimes pretty instant, sometimes taking many seconds, and sometimes not updating at all until I explicitly refresh. I've even copied a small file to the same directory and waited several seconds before it showed up. > Did you try to reinstall Windows? For no sane desktop/similar operating system should “completely reinstall” be an off-hand answer for any but a massively significant error…
- muststopmyths 4y agoTry dissociating the photos app from jpgs. It triggers some strange CPU hogging and other side effects
- dspillett 4y agoUsually when the problem gets really bad, memory use has jumped into a few hundred MB. That seems to happen when I've switched between local login and acceding the machine via RDC.
- fzfaa 4y ago
- koenvdb 4y agoA lot of people always go crazy when someone asks this question and instantly praise Total Commander. Link can be found here: https://www.ghisler.com/ https://www.ghisler.com/
- enlyth 4y agoYou just sent me on a nostalgia trip, used to use this back in the days. Also anyone else remember the kind of equivalent Norton/Volkov commander from the DOS days?
- pajko 4y agoYou can get the same look&feel with FAR Manager: https://www.farmanager.com/screenshots.php?l=en https://www.farmanager.com/screenshots.php?l=en
- anakaine 4y agoXTree Gold
- macote 4y agoThere's also the native Windows version of XTree: ZTreeWin (https://www.ztree.com/index.html https://www.ztree.com/index.html)
- saiya-jin 4y agothat's how I ended up with Total commander - the line of 2-pane file managers go all the way back to 1993 for me to DOS 6.22 and those tools. Once getting used to this concept, doing anything non-trivial on filesystem is very effective compared to simple file browsing windows others use. All work can be done only via keyboard which is much faster compared to adding mouse. You could say its a matter of getting used to given tool - but consistently when I watch colleagues doing similar tasks, I am so much faster, easily 2-10x depending on task. And thats folks with 20+ years of experience. Yet whenever I try to show my ways to others, nobody picks it up. Its like some mental blind spot, people generally are happy to learn more effective ways for their work, but not this one.
- londons_explore 4y agoHave you tried just running Windows XP explorer on Windows 10? It might just run...
- andai 4y agoYeah, I tried that, and also the one from ReactOS. ReactOS's one at least launches (including the taskbar!) but crashes almost instantly. The XP one seems to heavily depend on various DLL files which no longer work the same way. I tried copying a bunch of them over, solving the error popups one by one but gave up after hitting a brick wall after the 10th DLL or so.
- e12e 4y ago> and also the one from ReactOS Interesting idea, I hadn't thought about ReactOS as a possible source of FOSS programs for windows - but why not? We run Gnu user land various places after all. Curious about why it crashes. Did you build from source?
- andai 4y agoNo, I just copy pasted it from a ReactOS install. Binary compatibility is their goal (WinDbg thinks it's debugging Windows Server 2003, so they did a good job!), but last I heard they have to do some funky stuff in some places to be able to make use of WINE. Or it could be because of the compatibility: XP's explorer doesn't run on 10, so we shouldn't expect its clone to run either! But I had to try :) Still, considering it's open source and the closest thing what I do want, starting with this and stripping out the taskbar might get me a good result. Same with MSPaint: just spent several days trying to get the leaked XP MSPaint to compile, to no avail. Looks like I'd have better luck starting with ReactOS's paint clone and modifying it so it's feature complete and has the original icons :)
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoTotal Commander?
- Tsiklon 4y agoI suspect that for Windows 10 the window appearing but not fully drawn is a function of the introduction of a display compositor (Desktop Window Manager) in Windows Vista - this is also what solved the famous issue of Windows "leaving trails" of application Windows when they were unresponsive, and also permitted all the "aero" effects that Vista and 7 used as selling points. Windows XP and earlier used a Stacking Window Manager.
- alt227 4y agoMicrosoft open sourced the original: https://github.com/Microsoft/winfile/ https://github.com/Microsoft/winfile/ Edit: Also available on the microsoft store https://www.microsoft.com/store/apps/9p7vbbbc49rb?ocid=badge https://www.microsoft.com/store/apps/9p7vbbbc49rb?ocid=badge
- rahen 4y ago> does anyone know a lightweight Explorer alternative? PowerShell. It's builtin, uses little resources, is fast, has pattern globbing, autocompletion, and can be as efficient as using the coreutils on *nix. Unfortunately nnn and Ranger don't work on Windows, and the WSL uses more resources than explorer so this workaround isn't resource efficient. Cygwin is very efficient and could be a better solution to run them, I haven't tried it. edit: Looks like lf works on Windows: https://github.com/gokcehan/lf https://github.com/gokcehan/lf
- moqster 4y agohttps://github.com/files-community/Files https://github.com/files-community/Files
- sprremix 4y agoI can't attest for its speed, but this seems like the polar opposite of lightweight.
- JacobSeated 4y agoAlthough I am not having these problems with Explorer, I am going to answer this out of interest. Obviously running Windows in a VM will be slower, but besides, Explorer is more than just the file manager. It used to be very easy to replace the shell (Explorer.exe) with your own binary, but while this is now harder in later Windows versions it is still doable. I loved to play around with that when I was younger, and before I got seriously into Linux. Now, there is actually a few options: - Aston Shell used to be my favorite, but it does not seem like it is actively developed anymore. It is also closed source, which is potentially a security concern. - Classic Shell (Works for Windows 10) - ExplorerPatcher (taskbar enhancements for Windows 11) - StartIsAllBack (taskbar enhancements for Windows 11) I do not recommend replacing the default file manager, because Explorer is already extremely good. If this is slow for you, most likely something else is causing it to be slow. E.g. Waiting for a external/internal storage device to respond perhaps? Now, talk about Finder on Mac – while not slow, its UI is truly horrendous compared to Explorer on Windows or file managers in Linux. If your system is slow, then keep in mind that a lot of things are going on with later versions of Windows that can make the system slow. I hate the "blackbox" nature of it, but fact is, you probably have a bottleneck somewhere, possibly you are still using a mechanical hard disk and/or do not have enough RAM for things to load properly. Windows prefetch should help speed things up, given enough RAM, but if you have too little, then it actually might make it worse. I remember fiddling a lot with Windows services, like prefetch, search indexing. Etc. Basically turning these off will make a slow system feel more responsive. And, of course, Windows update and Windows defender should also be turned off entirely on older systems, because they will constantly pest you with updates and slow the system down. With bloatware added from the computer's manufacturer this only gets worse. Everything unnecessary running in the background should be purged from the system.
- andai 4y agoI have an SSD, 16 GB of RAM and the system was freshly installed a few weeks ago.
- JacobSeated 4y agoThat's extremely strange, because I do not have problems with speed. Perhaps it is something else interfering, a bad driver, or poor support for your paticular system? Typically things open near instantly for me. But, keep in mind in a VM, things is just horrible slow. Probably even more so if you run Windows 10 from a Linux host OS – I have had a lot of problems with that, and eventually I just gave up, because it was not fast enough for me. For Windows, it is much, much better to setup dual boot.
- avryhof 4y agoJust tested ReactOS explorer on Win11 and it worked good. http://www.foxplanet.de/explorer/ http://www.foxplanet.de/explorer/
- andai 4y agoThanks, I will try this version, mine did launch but crashed, perhaps I forgot to copy some DLLs.
- nullify88 4y agoPerhaps load up sysinternals Autoruns and see if a particular plugin / DLL is being loaded which is causing the slow downs.
- achn 4y agoMake sure your folders are configured for “general” files and not “photos” or other metadata consuming options. I had a similar issue and this resolved it.
- medlazik 4y agoXYPlorer is fantastic
- alok-g 4y ago+1 for XYPlorer. It's powerful, still performant, and heavily configurable. The free version (discontinued but the last version is available) itself works great.