8 ms·
Calling Git a blockchain to rebrand bad tech
- etchalon 4y agoI have a rule that I do not take any discussion about how "some people are saying!" seriously unless the discussion includes direct links to people saying that.
- smartmic 4y agoA better suited discussion is whether fossil, an alternative to git, is a blockchain: https://fossil-scm.org/home/doc/trunk/www/blockchain.md https://fossil-scm.org/home/doc/trunk/www/blockchain.md
- PretzelPirate 4y agoI didn’t see a single link in the article to the pro-blockchain crowd trying to claim Git is blockchain. It’s almost always the anti-blockchain crowd that says “blockchains don’t add anything new, it’s just Git with scams on it”. I suspect this person has misinterpreted the messaging they’re hearing and misunderstood the position being taken. It’s also unclear if they don’t know how to spell Ethereum or if they’re weakening their argument by purposely misspelling it.
- mikl 4y agoThe blockchain community are their own worst enemies. There are some interesting use cases for the technology, but those are lost in the noise of the big crowd that treat it like a get-rich-quick scheme. All the “HODL”, “diamond hands” and other memes in those circles essentially amount to trying to rally people to (artificially) increase the price of Bitcoin/Ethereum/whatever. And the more they succeed in doing so, the larger the incentive to run scams or waste power running “mining” computers.
- em-bee 4y agothat is the reason why i stopped being involved with blockchain. i can't in good conscience support a technology that is mostly used to exploit people and use a lot of energy for little benefit. and i don't want to continuously have to explain that the project i am supporting is not a scam and is worth the energy usage, when most of the people probably think i am just a scammer and anti-environmentalist for supporting a blockchain project.
- carlosdp 4y agoWhat "crypto people" are claiming Git is a blockchain? I usually see that claim from people trying to claim blockchains are nothing new, as in "git has existed forever, blockchains are dumb." This is a super low-quality article.
- rpdillon 4y agoFossil has a pretty thoughtful analysis[0] about whether it fits the definition of a blockchain. If you're interested in those semantics, it's far better than the OP's treatment, IMHO. [0]: https://www3.fossil-scm.org/site.cgi/doc/2022-05-28/www/blockchain.md https://www3.fossil-scm.org/site.cgi/doc/2022-05-28/www/bloc...
- t_mann 4y ago> Calling git a blockchain to rebrand bad tech Does he have any examples of people making this claim? Otherwise the post just seems like a lengthy strawman (or what's the name for an argument based on defeating a made-up statement?).
- miracle2k 4y ago"git is a blockchain" is a meme that is exclusively pushed by anti-crypto activists because it provides the basis for their "no there there" talking point (note the popularity of this phrase in particular). Evidence: https://twitter.com/smdiehl/status/1499637399751692288 https://twitter.com/smdiehl/status/1499637399751692288 The entire article is arguing a strawman.
- wcerfgba 4y agoUsing Git as a 'blockchain' was a core part of my experimental essay on NFTs: https://github.com/wcerfgba/moneylab-nft-essay https://github.com/wcerfgba/moneylab-nft-essay
- whatisweb3 4y agoIs anybody really calling git a blockchain? I have only seen this equivalence made by critics saying "we don't need blockchain, we already have git!"
- cybrox 4y agoThere's a lot of nitpicking around this topic. Mainly because "a chain of blocks" only describes the Merkle Tree part of "blockchain technologies". I'd personally argue that "blockchain" is a bad way to describe immutable, decentralized ledgers, because it inherently leaves out some of the defining aspects. However, the term has been way too established for a long time now, so the whole discussion is moot.
- abalashov 4y agoNo, but I have heard blockchain boosters say that blockchains are "kind of like Git!" Of course, "kind of like" doesn't mean anything like "equivalent", but it draws upon something established to legitimise something that's not.
- PurpleRamen 4y agoThe problem is not the blockchain, but the cryptocurrency with it's harmful consent-mechanism, also all the scams happening with it. These are two different technologies. And only one of them is highly problematic.
- devoutsalsa 4y agoCrypto scams aren't a problem unique to crypto. There are plenty of fiat scams, too.
- PurpleRamen 4y agoThere is a big difference between nearly 100% scam, and something like 1% scam. And most of the scames happening with non-crypto are not exclusive to the currency, they would happen with crypto too, if it had wider usage.
- Ferret7446 4y agoThe spam email and phone calls I get are nearly 100% scam.
- tpae 4y agoScams are everywhere, though. Millions are scammed through shitty toolbars, and personal data is brokered to the highest bidders. Cryptocurrency has issues, but generalizing it as the problem isn't necessarily constructive to society.
- PurpleRamen 4y agoThen where are the legit cryptocurrency use cases? At the moment it seems, except people playing around for the sake of playing, every other usage is just scamming the fools or scamming the state. And while other cases were tested, they failed.
- dashdot 4y ago
- devoutsalsa 4y agoMy favorite blockchain is Perforce.
- kris-nova 4y agoI am not sure that git needs to be rebranded - nor do I believe that calling it a blockchain will help that effort in any way. Good day sir.
- lazy_moderator1 4y agoMerkle tree*
- toinetoine 4y agoShould linked lists also be renamed to blockchains?
- AndrewDucker 4y agoOnly if the links are chains. (i.e. once you've made a link between two blocks it can't be changed)
- knorker 4y agoThe C++ `const` keyword makes for a blockchain.
- qzw 4y agoThis is a somewhat poorly worded title. At first glance it sounds like git is the bad technology that’s being rebranded, which made absolutely no sense. I had to read the article to realize that some blockchain people are claiming git as a kind of blockchain. But that’s not really a rebranding for blockchains, either. The title aside, the actual blog post makes some good points and is worth a read.
- teknopaul 4y agoGit is a kind of block chain IMHO. It annoys me that crypto bros think that bitcoin was the first use of bloody cks of data with hashing for an immutable ledger. Its common practice in many industries. Inc the one I work in (lotteries) Bitcoin is a clever trick. But it's underlying tech is not anything radically new. It's just using some best practices for a perticular use case.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- leolara 4y agoThere are legitimate criticism to blockchain technologies and arguments that could be made against its usefulness in the future. However, one of the things that fuel my believe on blockchain is how many the arguments against it are falacies and/or full of ignorance like this one. "Someone made the wrong assertion that git is blockchain IMPLIES THAT blockchain is going down and their adepts are desperate" a very simple fallacy to realize to be honest, not worthy of hacker news. Also ignorant things like: "stumping up in a complicated, exclusionary, and non-existent proof-of-stake system its advocates claim is just around the corner every six months" 1. It is not complicated, I understand it 2. It is less exclusionary than proof of work 3. It exists 4. It launches next month (aprox 15th September) on Ethereum
- ddrdrck_ 4y agoAlso apart from Ethereum switch to PoS planned soon (hopefully), there is a lot of PoS blockchains in production today. Cosmos (ATOM) [0], for instance, is live since march 2019 and going very well, spawning a whole ecosystem of PoS blockcains using Cosmos SDK [1] [0] https://cosmos.network/ https://cosmos.network/ [1] https://www.coingecko.com/en/categories/cosmos-ecosystem https://www.coingecko.com/en/categories/cosmos-ecosystem
- remram 4y agoAt some fundamental level, blockchains do not generate money, it just moves it around. The idea that a content creator might be rewarded every time her site is shown, or every time her in-game items are used, or every time her painting is re-sold sounds attractive. But the idea that the rest of us might have to pay a micro-transaction every time we visit a site, or every time we use an in-game item, or every time we re-sell our property is repugnant. This is the fundamental problem with blockchain/web3 and you will notice that everyone shilling for it is very careful to focus on one side of the coin. The fact that some of those systems start to approach usability is also a very weak reason to switch from the existing usable systems. The non-buzzword web3 exists, works, and is called "micro-transactions".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MayeulC 4y agoI partly disagree with the author, but glancing at other articles of the same blog, it seems that nuance is often left out. On technical merits, the first point is kind of invalid. You can't rewrite history in git without changing commit IDs. And the two others are the same point: git doesn't have a distributed consesus mechanism. It would be very easy to build one, though, which gets git close enough for comparison purposes. And the "blockchain" term only hints at the merkle tree aspect. Now, on rebranding: while I feel the comparison apt, it shouldn't be used as a successfull example of blockchain technology. It can to an extent, but blockchain means something different in people's mind. I'd still do the comparison while pointing out the difference. And that's something I often do, when explaining how either works. And to me, blockchain (including consensus) is still a mathematical curiosity that hasn't proven useful yet. I've seen some interesting PoW proposals, like mail anti-spam, or rate limiting/captcha.
- Ajedi32 4y ago> git doesn't have a distributed consesus mechanism It doesn't have an automated distributed consensus mechanism. It does have a manual distributed consensus mechanism; that's basically how every popular open source project works. You fork the project, make a change, and if your commit is an improvement over the project you forked people will be inclined to merge it into their repositories, eventually arriving at a consensus. In practice this process is often more centralized than distributed, but it doesn't have to be. If you want to 51% attack a popular repo, all you have to do is make constant, quality improvements to the project over time, and eventually your fork may well become the dominant one even over the objections of any centralized authorities.
- dahart 4y agoThe argument that git can have consensus if people just agree to isn’t compelling in this context. The distinction here is that with blockchain, consensus is mandatory and has a specific technical meaning. With git, consensus is optional at best, achieved only manually, is easily broken by rogue activity, and the word consensus might not even mean the same thing and can change over time in the case of git - there are lots of examples of original projects or forks that have claimed to be the one and only place people should concentrate their efforts, only to get abandoned in favor of something else later.
- kmeisthax 4y agoFWIW I've used the "Git is a blockchain" argument to argue in the opposite direction: i.e. that blockchains are not anything new or innovative.
- olodus 4y agoI think this is a much better way to take it. Blockchains are super useful. They solve problems in distributed systems very elegantly and effectivly. It is the consensus part of a crypto currency blockchains that is the part I usually have objections to. I have increasingly started to realize that it is surprisingly few situations you want such a rigid type of consensus and consistency. In computer systems you usually want something much more efficient and in human systems, in the places where you really need consensus it is usually very required to have systems like our institutions that are filled with checks and balances for fault tolerance and fairness. And in most places you just have to realize consensus in a society is really hard and reeeeally slow - and I don't know if that is possible to change.
- abalashov 4y agoI don't think the argument has to go both ways. Blockchains can be indebted to some prior art in distributed version control systems without being similar or identical to them, and without those DVCSs being blockchains.
- em-bee 4y agothe innovation with blockchain is that it adds a feature that git doesn't have, namely to make it expensive to add new entries and very difficult to fork the chain. on the other hand, i believe blockchain is used for many projects that don't need that new feature, where something similar to git would suffice. in other words a lot of blockchain uses are not innovative in that they don't enable something that would not have been possible without blockchain.
- abalashov 4y agoBlockchain for blockchain's sake, in other words...
- 5350-uiop-1130 4y agopossible a scalable blockchain might provide 'distributed' platforms with novel ways of income that doesn't involve selling your data or showing adverts reddit/moons thing is interesting as a kind of experiment of all issues there and problems to solve im not convinced yet that the result will be something good, a kind of hypercapitalistic zero-sum internet rat race
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- adabsurdo 4y ago