3 ms·
1. Transactions won't change noticeably since the gas costs won't change and the network won't have more capacity. 2. The 'demand' from mining for GPUs is over
by latchkey 4y ago
1. Transactions won't change noticeably since the gas costs won't change and the network won't have more capacity.
2. The 'demand' from mining for GPUs is over-rated. It was a brief problem years ago. You are correct that energy usage for validation will go down.
3. One difference between bitcoin and eth... ethash is a memory hard algo so it doesn't require the fastest GPU. 4-5 year old GPUs are more ROI efficient. Everything is bound in the speed of the memory controller.
4. To be seen.
5. 'staking' today is just depositing ETH into an ETH1 contract that doesn't have a withdraw function. It will require forks to add that functionality.
6. Correct.
7. Correct. Although this likely won't have an impact on price like people think.
8. A fork could always change things.
- DennisP 4y ago5. Staking today also means you're running a validator on the beacon chain, and accumulating a balance that will be respected by the future withdraw function.
- latchkey 4y agoTrue... although there is no absolute guarantee of that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MarkPNeyer 4y agoHow do 7 and 4 work together? If the reward for staking is fixe at 5%, what keeps the issuance rate from being net positive?
- coolestguy 4y agoThe staking reward is for collateralized validators only (a small % of the network) Overall issuance can potentially be negative due to the burn effects of eip1559 - where the base transaction fee of an eth transaction is deleted from the network forever (akin to using oil/gas/petrol & then it's gone) If 2>1 then net issuance is negative
- latchkey 4y agoPretty cool visualization site: https://ultrasound.money/ https://ultrasound.money/
- lottin 4y ago"cool" maybe, but completely uninformative.
- latchkey 4y agoOk, I see that you're now just making repeated negative comments towards me. It is your opinion that it in uninformative, for you, but for myself and many others, it is quite informative.
- lottin 4y agoExactly, it's my opinion. What's wrong with sharing my opinion? The whole purpose of this site is sharing opinions and points of view with others. Do you think I'm looking for comments written by you and posting "negative" replies? You're crazy.
- vhgyu75e6u 4y ago2) The latest earning from NVIDIA and AMD showed that about 30% of their GPU were to crypto miners, so no, the shortage was not an exaggeration and certainly not from many years ago.
- Mikealcl 4y agoI took it as the environmental stance not supply when I read it but can see both.
- vhgyu75e6u 4y agoStill the same, the more GPUs are added to the network the harder it is to mine, the harder is to mine the more GPUs are added until it is no longer profitable, all this while drawing more power.
- latchkey 4y agoWhen profitability goes down, miners shut down.
- latchkey 4y agoThe shortage was due to demand from people beyond mining wanting GPUs (including a new problem... scalpers) and there not being enough production. In effect, it was a manufactured shortage. There are a ton of articles that talk about all the aspects that went into the shortage and miners are definitely not the only reason. Easy scapegoat though... https://www.pcmag.com/news/inside-the-gpu-shortage-why-you-still-cant-buy-a-graphics-card https://www.pcmag.com/news/inside-the-gpu-shortage-why-you-s... https://gamerant.com/nvidia-gpu-shortage-not-due-crypto-mining-says-cfo/ https://gamerant.com/nvidia-gpu-shortage-not-due-crypto-mini... https://www.pcgamer.com/why-crypto-mining-wasnt-the-only-culprit-for-wild-gpu-prices/ https://www.pcgamer.com/why-crypto-mining-wasnt-the-only-cul...
- belltaco 4y agoLink #1 and #3 mention crypto as one of the causes of the shortage. Like #2 is a statement by Nvidia who has a vested interest in lying, and has lied about the exact same issue so blatantly that they got fined by the SEC for it. https://www.theverge.com/2022/5/6/23059930/nvidia-sec-charges-fine-settlement-gaming-gpu-crypto-mining https://www.theverge.com/2022/5/6/23059930/nvidia-sec-charge... Scalpers only come in when there's a shortage already, they don't cause shortages except at launch, they just delay items getting to the real users. There's image and video evidence of dozens to hundreds of GPU mining rigs in a single room if you care to look. Eg. https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/788512140322406473/908192493554782238/120_rtx_3070s_7500_mhs-fjtdyi5y98d71.mp4 https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/788512140322406473/90... https://old.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/r39ph3/found_this_video_in_a_group_chat/ https://old.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/r39ph3/found_... https://old.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/wganva/posted_on_facebook_group_mining_rig_to_the_moon/ https://old.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/wganva/posted...
- alchemist1e9 4y agoIf you have a good understanding of ETH PoS perhaps I can ask this question. The only issue I’m still confused about is the incentive to add hardware to the network. Obviously the network needs to be resilient to attack on consensus but it also needs networking and physical hardware resilience. How is that incentivized in the PoS?
- jlokier 4y agoThe stakers have to perform consensus network and block building actions continuously online, or they are penalised by losing value from their stake over time rather than gaining it. The penalty is reasonable so a small downtime during updates and such isn't a problem. This incentivizes them to have reliable networking and hardware, running 24x7. However they are heavily penalised if they are seen to do things like double-voting by accident, so they can't just put up duplicate systems and forget about it. High availability failover is something they can only do carefully. This is different from the current proof-of-work miners. If a miner stops or screws up, they won't gain mining fees during the stop, but they don't lose anything either.
- alchemist1e9 4y agoI understand all that but what I don’t understand is what encourages more physical nodes with high quality bandwidth because it seems like if me and you both want to stake for PoS then we can even be better off sharing the same hardware and buying higher quality hardware than we could individually, and this is a sub-linear incentive which I would think would result in the physical hardware footprint significantly shrinking. Am I missing something? Now you might say well isn’t that a good thing for less resources but without an incentive to decentralize physically won’t there be a risk of centralization and potentially catastrophic outcomes for the network?
- latchkey 4y ago> what I don’t understand is what encourages more physical nodes with high quality bandwidth because it seems like if me and you both want to stake for PoS then we can even be better off sharing the same hardware and buying higher quality hardware than we could individually. For the same reason that there are a number of mining companies too. But you're right, PoS doesn't 'fix' that problem.
- yieldcrv 4y agoI thought the network will have 64 shards, increasing capacity by 64x, with finality being periodic and a bit later whats changed in that plan?
- DennisP 4y agoThey decided to do proof-of-stake first, putting shards off until later. Also it started looking like zkrollups could do everything without loss of security or convenience, and with way better scaling than they ever hoped to get with the original sharding plan. So they removed execution from sharding, using it instead as just data for rollups. Then someone came up with "danksharding" which is more like a RAID system than actual sharding. The plan now is described in some detail here: https://members.delphidigital.io/reports/the-hitchhikers-guide-to-ethereum https://members.delphidigital.io/reports/the-hitchhikers-gui...