3 ms·
There's one statistic that I didn't see but I'm now really curious about: what percentage of audits discover irregularities, per income level? If lower-income p
by josephcsible 4y ago
There's one statistic that I didn't see but I'm now really curious about: what percentage of audits discover irregularities, per income level? If lower-income people are more likely than average to cheat on their taxes, then it makes sense to audit them more, but if they don't, then this is indeed totally unfair.
- kevinventullo 4y agoAlso, the whole point is that they may in fact not be as low income as they claim!
- Scoundreller 4y agoWould make more sense if they looked at IRS audit rates by zip code.
- SubiculumCode 4y agoI'd guess that audits of the poor finds *less* but can be completed swiftly; if there is any quotas requiring X audits/month of IRS accountants, are you going to choose the 1040EZ or the tax filing with 50+ pages of mumbojumbo?
- oneplane 4y agoIf we were to try to assess fairness, wouldn't it make sense to also take effects and side-effects into account? Say a disproportionate amount of poor families cheat, but also end up on the street after an audit, either not able to pay any outstanding taxes, or having paid them and no longer being able to afford a roof over their head. At the same time, while breaking the law should be the same for everyone else, wouldn't it also be more fair for small time violators to be treated less harsh, for example not having paid 100 dollars in tax vs. not having paid 1M. At the end of the day, the enforcement is there for one reason: to make sure everyone pays for the shared facilities of society. If you catch someone who was supposed to pay 250.000 or catch 1000 someones who all had 100 outstanding tax, wouldn't it make more sense to focus on the big fish first?
- josephcsible 4y agoThere's a big difference between acknowledging that you owe taxes but not paying them, and lying that you don't owe taxes when you really do. I can only sympathize with people who do the former, and these audits are all about catching the latter.
- singlow 4y agoThe audits also catch a lot of cases where people don't know how to file anything beyond their basic employer withholdings. If a poorer, less educated person gets a 1099 for a side job or does an early withdrawal from their IRA, they are likely to fail to report it properly, or pay the required taxes. This is not usually intentional, they just don't know better. Even if they know they have to pay taxes on the money, they don't realize that the IRS didn't already take their cut just like they do from a paycheck.
- googlryas 4y agoTrue, and the IRS is fairly reasonable about understanding when something is intentional or unintentional when levying fines and setting out payment plans.
- rglover 4y ago> wouldn't it make more sense to focus on the big fish first? Of course, but the reason they don't is that the tax system is a psychological control mechanism disguised as "doing good" (I make that assertion by looking at the utter amount of careless, unaccountable waste in government despite the endless gaslighting about "muh roads"). Why? Because if you can keep the majority in the psychological bracket of being the property of their government (purely via suggestion), you guarantee some percentage of cash flows. The "big fish" are smart and financed well-enough to circumvent (legally, in many cases) the system, while the little fish are ripe for catch and require far less worms/fishing poles to track down. This is why a flat tax rate with a floor is necessary. If you don't make above a certain amount per year (e.g., at or just above the poverty line), you don't pay any taxes. Everyone above that pays 10%. The government, as they should, adjusts their budget accordingly instead of treating citizens like an ATM. What the money gets spent on is transparent, itemized, and readily available for you, me, and everyone else. This would solve all of the unnecessary red tape and procedure, fearmongering, etc. And that's precisely why it will never happen.
- nonameiguess 4y agoNot sure that really follows. Is the goal of the audit to punish the maximum number of people or recover the maximum amount of money? If the latter, then it doesn't make much sense to spend most of your effort assessing $400 penalties.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThat depends on the ROI. If it costs a fraction of a penny to write a code that catches hundreds of thousands of $400 errors, the ROI is pretty good
- offsign_p 4y agoExactly. Study makes a huge assumption that low earned income means the recipient is poor. Investment only income isn't "earned" income, unreported income isn't earned income -- both are probably good targets audits.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> what percentage of audits discover irregularities, per income level? "The rate at which taxpayers understate their tax liability increases monotonically with income and average adjustments are highest in the highest income decile" [1]. [1] https://dl.acm.org/doi/fullHtml/10.1145/3531146.3533204 https://dl.acm.org/doi/fullHtml/10.1145/3531146.3533204
- llbeansandrice 4y agoThey're not cheating. It's because the EITC is complex so it's easy to make mistakes. Also because the IRS doesn't have the proper staffing to actually go after people that are richer and file yet more complex tax returns. "Cheating" is a very loaded word to use here. Increasing funding so the IRS can hire the proper staff to enforce tax-law across the board is the solution and it results in net revenue for the government. But the GOP consistently opposes these measures and is intent on hamstringing the IRS in its ability to audit higher-income households and businesses.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoThis. A large percentage of "audits" of the middle class and below are oopses, not cheating.