6 ms·
Technically, RDOF ISPs have until 2028 to provide the promised service but Starlink's application was denied because their Ookla speed tests are slightly low in
by wmf 4y ago
Technically, RDOF ISPs have until 2028 to provide the promised service but Starlink's application was denied because their Ookla speed tests are slightly low in 2022. Appearances matter. If they provisioned slightly fewer customers per cell they might have passed.
- malfist 4y agoPromising 20mbps and delivering 9 is not "a bit low". I want starlink to succeed, and I wish they'd gotten the the criteria to get this funding, but let's not be deceptive here.
- mgerdts 4y agoThat’s what Spectrum has done with my cable modem. It used to be 200/20 now it’s advertised as 300 with no upload speed advertised. Ookla tells me it is now 320+/10, but sometimes only 9 up. Uploads are reminiscent of my DSL line 20 years ago.
- sidewndr46 4y agoYep, I just got the same "upgrade" where I live. No guaranteed upload speeds at all now.
- notatoad 4y agonot that i want to defend the practice, but real-world speeds being a bit less than half the advertised speed is about what i've experience from every ISP i've ever been a customer of.
- shaklee3 4y agoI've had 5 cable providers in different cities and never experienced that. usually they overprovision you to make your plan look even better.
- hedora 4y agoNext time netflix (or whatever you watch) drops off max resolution, look up the bandwidth requirements that your ISP just failed to meet. https://help.netflix.com/en/node/306 https://help.netflix.com/en/node/306 We have a 1080p TV. We had a connection that was effectively 6mbit dedicated down, and it never pixelated or buffered. Our “75mbit” comcast line regularly dropped to minimum resolution or started buffering. Speedtests said the connection was providing 25-100 mbit down, since ISPs often prioritize households that are currently running speed tests. This was before netflix launched fast.com to defeat such gaming. For starlink, everything is fine, except that a few times an hour it jumps to the next satellite and the connection drops for about a second. I don’t think it resets tcp streams or anything, but it definitely makes Zoom and “live” TV streaming apps cranky.
- shaklee3 4y agoit literally never does that. I'm on spectrum right now and had one outage in 8 years.
- yencabulator 4y ago> For starlink, everything is fine, except that a few times an hour it jumps to the next satellite and the connection drops for about a second. > I don’t think it resets tcp streams or anything, but it definitely makes Zoom and “live” TV streaming apps cranky. It hops to next satellite more often than that. The satellites take about 90 minutes to go around the globe. Most of the handovers to next satellite are seamless (maybe 10ms delay in traffic), but especially when they're working on the beta phase software the more routing-oriented parts of the system seem glitchy. Earlier in 2022 I'd lose Internet for a few tens of seconds every now and then -- but that seems to have been a bug in the routing stack that they since fixed.
- jeffbee 4y agoThird-party observations are not mere optics. The company's claims simply did not survive scrutiny.
- mlindner 4y agoThe ookla results are misleading so they're optics. Starlink speeds are completely non-uniform. Some areas get 300 mbps or even higher. Some are dropping down below 50 mpbs.
- dicknuckle 4y agoI'm getting 10/10 at 8am on the east coast US. Highest I've seen by manually testing was 87/3. There's a few Grafana based Starlink monitoring projects I've been looking at. Historical data would be nice to have.
- ajross 4y agoThey're satellites, they move. You can't "provision" customers like that. You provide a constellation that gives some level of coverage at some level of reliability as a function of latitude, and that's what you get. Now, OK, maybe that's not going to be acceptable to regulators. And... that's sort of a shame given the fact that satellite services are available literally everywhere. How many people not served by existing rural broadband RDOF recipients would love to have a subsidized Starlink antenna? I really don't see how this is helping anyone except a handful of cable companies actually doing deployments. The vast bulk of the rural subscriber base that fund is intended to assist aren't going to get anything out of it.
- ezfe 4y agoThey literally do provision customers per cell. The satellites move in predictable orbits meaning each cell has a specific capacity.
- bri3d 4y agoStarlink right now is a bent pipe between the dishy and a ground station. Depending on how many customers they have in a specific ground station's cell, they need different backhaul capacity for that cell. So, in the case of Starlink, they absolutely CAN provision customers like that, and that's EXACTLY how it works right now - invites happen per "cell," and each "cell" has a capacity quota. Recently, they've been overprovisioning "cells" for some reason or another, and the service has slowed down, so it objectively didn't meet the thresholds and they'll need to bid again. This also seems reasonable. I say this all as a happy Starlink customer - negative externalities to space junk and obnoxious fanbase aside, it's way better than my previous fixed point to point WISP experience was, and worlds better than ADSL stretched to the bitter end of distance capability over lines from the 1970s was.
- ghaff 4y agoMy experience with the Starlink at my brother's house in Maine is that it's "OK" relative to wired broadband. Speeds are reasonable and, while I've had a couple multi-hour outages in the limited time I've spent up there, it's pretty usable. I could work up there if I wanted to. But there are no good alternatives. ADSL was 1Mbps down with a tailwind and it was the last house on the road that could get it. Cell service is very sketchy, especially if not on Verizon. HughesNet limitations are well-known. So it's pretty much a game-changer in terms of Internet access.
- NelsonMinar 4y agoI've been using Starlink since March 2021 and am very grateful for it. But the US service has gotten a lot worse since they chose to oversell their capacity. I'm glad to see that has consequences. Also a little sad; I'd hoped that 100/20 RDOF standard would mean Starlink would have someone keeping them honest. They seem to be in a race to the congestion bottom right now.
- the_duke 4y agoYou should be careful about being too glad. Starlink is a money sink and won't even have positive cash flow for many years. SpaceX has used Starlink as a driver for investment rounds and is regularly raising money. Considering the expenses of Starlink and Starship, both big money sinks, it's entirely possible for Stalink to get scrapped at some point if investment money dries up. Probably unlikely, since they could stop launching and keep the service running until the sats decay, but still possible.
- pjscott 4y agoStarlink is mostly a bet on Starship. If they can actually get big reductions in cost to LEO, the cost of maintaining a large satellite constellation goes way down —- the capital cost of building each satellite is in the five-figure range, and the really expensive part is launching them. (Which, as you mentioned, they need to keep doing constantly as the older satellites are de-orbited.)
- Andys 4y agoThey're already more than half way to a billion a year in revenue from only ~2500 of 12000 satellites so far in orbit. Hopefully this will make its continued support financially plausible.
- ncmncm 4y agoThey need that revenue just to keep building replacement satellites.
- NelsonMinar 4y ago