8 ms·
Why Nagasaki? (2013)
- credit_guy 4y agoThe reason is simple. If hypothetically speaking, someone had conducted a poll in the US in July '45 (after almost years of hard war in the Pacific) with the single question "are you ok with killing one million Japanese people to save one hundred thousand American boys?", I think the vast majority of the people would have answered yes. America had just lost more than 20000 killed at Iwo Jima and Okinawa, and many more wounded. That's almost exactly the same number as those killed in the whole battle of Normandy (not just on D-day, but during the whole 3 month campaign). Iwo Jima was a tiny speck of land of less than 10 square miles, Okinawa is less than 500 sq miles. For comparison Normandy has an area of more than 10000 square miles. The Japanese were able to draw as much blood while surrendering 500 square miles as the Germans surrendering 20 times as much. Oh, and the Japanese had the kamikazes. I don't think the American's feared the Japanese by this time. After all, in all the battles the casualty ratio was between 1-to-3 and 1-to-10 US vs Japanese casualties. It was a given that they will crush Japan, and it had been so for 2 years already. But war is war, and people die in war. If there was something that could stop the war and save American lives, then Americans wanted it. The alternative to a land invasion was total psychological shock. A few hours after Hiroshima Truman gave his "rain of ruin" speach [1]. He implied that America will drop numerous atomic bombs over Japan (if you pay attention he never says that directly, but it's easy to think he does) We are now prepared to obliterate more rapidly and completely every productive enterprise the Japanese have above ground in any city. We shall destroy their docks, their factories, and their communications. Let there be no mistake; we shall completely destroy Japan's power to make war. It was to spare the Japanese people from utter destruction that the ultimatum of July 26 was issued at Potsdam. Their leaders promptly rejected that ultimatum. If they do not now accept our terms they may expect a rain of ruin from the air, the like of which has never been seen on this earth. Behind this air attack will follow sea and land forces in such numbers and power as they have not yet seen and with the fighting skill of which they are already well aware. Nagasaki was needed because Truman needed to follow through with his threat. [1] https://millercenter.org/the-presidency/presidential-speeches/august-6-1945-statement-president-announcing-use-bomb https://millercenter.org/the-presidency/presidential-speeche...
- Geonode 4y agoTo the assumed question, it was a major port city and the home of Mitsubishi Heavy Industries. To the really obvious question the article asks, the second bomb shows you can do it again, and you're ready to do it some more. It's a "surrender today" kind of statement.
- _8j50 4y agoYup, else they might try to decide to wait it out and build their own bomb. They were so much against surrendering many committed seppuku or regular suicide when it happened and those were regular people. It's very interesting how until recently I grew up and believed the bombings should not have happened. Modern ICBMs and hydrogen bombs are much more scary as is nuclear powers going to war but MAD aside there are situations where a single nuke at a strategic location will save many more lives on both sides of a conflict.but it still doesn't feel right saying it.
- orionion 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoGenuinely curious, how do you square your comment with toddlers and babies dying in the blast. - Do babies and toddlers have strong anti-Christianity sentiments? - Or does an all powerful benevolent compassionate God actually considers babies and toddlers an acceptable collateral damage?
- lelanthran 4y ago> - Or does an all powerful benevolent compassionate God actually considers babies and toddlers an acceptable collateral damage? Have you not actually read a bible or quran? Of course the all-powerful God considers babies and toddlers acceptable sacrifices for the greater good of more worshipers[1]. Not saying that I do, but a significant minority probably does.
- rainworld 4y agoRelevant recent threads by the author: https://twitter.com/wellerstein/status/1556664257005092864 https://twitter.com/wellerstein/status/1556664257005092864 https://twitter.com/wellerstein/status/1557053360313966593 https://twitter.com/wellerstein/status/1557053360313966593 https://twitter.com/wellerstein/status/1557360502954774528 https://twitter.com/wellerstein/status/1557360502954774528
- JohnZSmith 4y agoWhy? There is Urakami cathedral. Render unto Caesar.
- pegasus 4y agoSadly, the answer has nothing to do with Japan and everything to do with the Soviet Union: https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2020-08-05/hiroshima-anniversary-japan-atomic-bombs https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2020-08-05/hiroshima-a...
- marketerinland 4y agoContrarian counterfactual myth
- wodenokoto 4y agoI find the phrasing of the question annoying and left the article without having my curiosity satisfied. The question phrased as "Why Nagasaki?" is actually "Why a second nuclear bomb?" But why was it Nagasaki? The closest to an answer the article seems to give is "Because Kokura was clouded" or "Because they wanted to spare Kyoto", neither of which really satisfies why Nagasaki (or Kokura, or Hiroshima for that matter) made the list in the first place. I largely only know of Hiroshima and Nagasaki because of the nuclear bombings. So why wasn't it Tokyo or Osaka? Annoyingly, the author does this phrasing again when linking to a page that he purports answers the question "Why Hiroshima", but in facts discuss "Why throwing a nuclear bomb at all"
- glandium 4y ago> So why wasn't it Tokyo or Osaka? Presumably because of https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo_(10_March_1945) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo_(10_March_1... and ... can't find the corresponding wikipedia page, but Osaka, Nagoya and Kobe were fire-bombed shortly after. The fire-bombing of Kobe is probably what wad depicted in the animation movie Grave of the fireflies. This is not talked about much, but led to more deaths than both Hiroshima and Nagasaki combined...
- pydry 4y agoIIRC the imperial palace in Tokyo was nuclear target #3 assuming Japan didnt surrender.
- SiempreViernes 4y agoHere's the list of why, but I doubt it'll make you any happier: """ (1) they be important targets in a large urban area of more than three miles in diameter, (2) they be capable of being damaged effectively by a blast, and (3) they are unlikely to be attacked by next August. Dr. Stearns had a list of five targets which the Air Force would be willing to reserve for our use unless unforeseen circumstances arise. """ http://www.dannen.com/decision/targets.html#d http://www.dannen.com/decision/targets.html#d The answer really does boil down to the USAF hadn't bombed it by the 10th of August and the more preferred target had bad weather.
- fartsucker69 4y agoI always wonder why the second nuclear bomb in particular isn't much more prevalent in the Zeitgeist as the atrocity that it was. The first bomb is somewhat understandable, still you could argue that the US might have figured out a way to demonstrate its destructive power to the Japanese without killing over 100,000 mostly innocent people in an instant. Maybe at the trade-off of temporarily risking US soldier lifes and resources of the general public. Still, you can argue the other way and see it as a terrible conclusion to a terrible war. But the second one? I've seen many docs and historians perspectives on why it was considered necessary, but I can't find the point of view from which it was anything but a total atrocity for which the people who made it happen should be remembered in shame forever. So much of Japan not immediately surrendering after the first bomb dropped was down to the fog of war, to simple and understandable slow speed in government decisionmaking, etc. Even if you can't be sure that the first bomb would have been enough to have them surrender, just the chance of it should have been enough to pick a different strategy, at the chance of saving a couple of dozen thousand innocent lives.
- ransom1538 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanjing_Massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanjing_Massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Holocaust https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Holocaust The war needed to end immediately.
- Cocktail 4y agoWhile i understand the rationale, ive come to question if "fighting fire with napalm" is such a good idea, from ethics perspective. Is it not a duty to not fall prey to indulge in mass killing even if it may seem justified by the barbarity of the opposing side?
- GiorgioG 4y agoIt’s easy to question the decision when you’re not responsible for making it. When you’re not responsible for your soldiers’ lives it’s easy to talk about ethics. Invading Japan would have killed tens of thousands of US soldiers, easily. When it comes right down to it, you’ll always prefer the option that’s spares more of your countrymen than the enemy (who started the war against the US.) That’s perfectly ethical as far as I’m concerned - as ethical as anything can be in war.
- Taniwha 4y agoI've visited Nagasaki - it does seem like a poor choice - the city is a series of valleys - they shielded much of the city from the bomb. Ground zero was the largest Christian cathedral in the Far East, closest war related govt facility housed PoWs. Hiroshima in comparison is on a flat plain.
- xchip 4y agoWaste of time. The article is long and doesn't answer the question.
- dkn775 4y agoKind of reminds me of 9/11 actually. The first plane hit and everyone was kind of in a stupor, but when that second plane hit the urgency of the situation comes into sharp focus
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wrp 4y agoI can add something relevant to this bit: One wonders, of course, why anyone would think the Japanese would think the atomic bomb was a one-off thing, or that the Americans wouldn't have the resolve to use it again. When I was a student studying the Japanese side of WW2, one of my histories quoted a memo to the Japanese high command arguing that since producing nuclear weapons was such an expensive and lengthy process, it was almost certain that the USA had only two bombs and that their threat to continue with them was a bluff. It was not unreasonable for the Americans to expect the Japanese to be skeptical. Down in the comments section, the author makes this point: One of the very best points that Hasegawa makes in his work is that there is no single "Japanese" or "American" policy opinion -- because both governments involved rather complicated balances of power within their cabinets. Something usually ignored when discussing American decision making about the bomb is the actual state of their knowledge of Japanese thinking. We now have 70-odd years of studying Japanese documents and interviews with key Japanese and there is still nothing close to a consensus on how the Japanese would have reacted to different situations. Yet people criticize the American leadership for lacking that same insight into the mind of the enemy during the war.
- Jeema101 4y agoI've been to the USAF Museum in Dayton, Ohio, where they have the B-29 that dropped the bomb on Nagasaki. At first glance, it's just another plane in the museum. But if you actually let yourself think about it, it's somewhat more sobering: you're looking at the actual plane that actually flew and did it. It really brings home the reality of it. And it's a bit disturbing to think that a piece of machinery can end the lives of tens of thousands of people all at once, and that humans are even capable of building such things. Anyway just thought I'd share my experience.