4 ms·
> This is a false dilemma. We have more choices than “enable money laundering” and “no one has privacy”. Which other choice is there? AML as-implemented is lit
by AnthonyMouse 4y ago
> This is a false dilemma. We have more choices than “enable money laundering” and “no one has privacy”.
Which other choice is there? AML as-implemented is literally a policy that says you can't have digital transactional privacy, which is the only reason privacy technologies violate it when no other lawbreaking occurs.
And it has <= 0.2% effectiveness and high compliance costs.
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/25741292.2020.1725366 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/25741292.2020.1...
It's a total failure and it's inexplicable that anyone who understands it would defend it.
- MBCook 4y agoI’m fine with AML. I’m not someone who is a privacy absolutist and thinks it shouldn’t exist. My #1 concern is privacy from other people in my banking transactions. You know those Twitter accounts that post everywhere celebrities fly? No one should be able to do that for what I buy. Bitcoin gives anyone that information by design. I don’t like that. But again, I think the article’s solution is attacking the wrong problem.
- AnthonyMouse 4y ago> I’m fine with AML. I’m not someone who is a privacy absolutist and thinks it shouldn’t exist. Why are you fine with it if it has significant costs and doesn't even work? > My #1 concern is privacy from other people in my banking transactions. This is everybody's concern, some people just realize that "other people" include authoritarian governments, corrupt law enforcement and anyone who can hack your financial institution and then post everything they're required by law to collect on the internet. > Bitcoin gives anyone that information by design. Monero doesn't.
- MBCook 4y ago> Monero doesn’t. See that was kind of my original point. Why do problematic things to paper over Bitcoin problems if they’re not issues elsewhere. Why not just use Monero instead?
- tsimionescu 4y ago> This is everybody's concern, some people just realize that "other people" include authoritarian governments, corrupt law enforcement and anyone who can hack your financial institution and then post everything they're required by law to collect on the internet. And these people are concerned about the wrong things, in general. You can't live a good life under an authoritarian government, under corrupt law enforcement, or with a bank that is easily hacked into. The solution is not to try to distance yourself from these things through magical technology and then be amazed that the authoritarian government or corrupt law enforcement attack you for even using that technology. The solution is to fix the government, law enforcement, and financial institution technical security. All very hard things to do, to be clear, but they actually work, and fix many other problems. Using TC works until it doesn't.
- ryan_lane 4y agoAnti-social forces policy (anti-mob policy) in Japan has been highly effective at cutting off the funding sources of the yakuza to the point that they simply can't recruit anymore: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/sep/05/making-a-slow-getaway-ageing-population-japans-yakuza https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/sep/05/making-a-slow-... The meat of Japan's policy is AML/KYC and very actively cutting businesses off from financing if they have ties to the yakuza. Actual results show that the paper you're referencing is simply incorrect. The paper focuses heavily on how much of the funds are recovered, and how much money is being moved undetected, but doesn't seem to consider how much more would move without enforcement.