7 ms·
Archaeologists rebury ‘first-of-its-kind’ Roman villa
- poulsbohemian 4y agoI'm not an archeologist or historian, but it has been my impression that high-status roman villas typically had rooms linked by courtyards. In that regard, this villa seems to be particularly interesting, given that it appears to be rooms with a central tower. In that regard, I'd be curious to know why they believe it is a villa rather than say, military in nature, especially given the history of the Romans in Britain.
- ggm 4y agoI'm going out on a limb here with speculation: wall paint, tesserae and other signs of high status finishes to interior, and things like a hypocaust and food preparation spaces which don't meet the formalisms of a military facility. That said, I read of military owned staging posts with pretty high investment features like baths. 5 star roadside hotels for senior staffers and government officials on the move. So dual use, or military but fancy is possible. Also not an archaeologist
- mc32 4y agoYep I think it’s possible that someone on the outpost of their society might still want some semblance of their civilization while they are there.
- rendall 4y agoThe tower isn't central. That picture is not of the entire villa. Here's a video that shows more: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HGpdirRWJMA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HGpdirRWJMA I recommend watching with sound off.
- StillLrning123 4y agoWouldn't a tower have thicker walls? Medieval towers have walls that are several meters thick
- jacquesm 4y agoThe Romans were way ahead of their time in terms of construction ability and plenty of the stuff made much later is downright crude by comparison.
- saalweachter 4y agoConstruction techniques aside, what was siege technology like in the Roman era? Did they build walls to resist heavy thrown rocks, or just arrows and infantry?
- Retric 4y agoCatapults and other torsion where during the Roman empire, though the thickness of walls also related to how tall they needed to be to be effective. Anything under 30 feet is easy to get over using simple ladders. The Trebuchet is plenty old enough, but we don't have evidence of use by Rome.
- mcguire 4y agoAs far as I know, it depends on what you mean by trebuchet. Counterpoise trebuchets (using heavy weights) are definitely medieval.
- Retric 4y agoYes, the giant weapons most people think of when they hear the term trebuchet is medieval improvement allowing people to further scale up the design. A mangonel (traction trebuchet) is the older design, but trebuchet is referring any scaled up staff sling.
- jacquesm 4y ago
- Fatnino 4y agoCould it have been built for military but then taken over and given a fresh coat of paint (or mosaics, as the case may be) by the new civilian tenant?
- WalterBright 4y agoKinda stingy with the pictures. I'd like to see a photo showing the excellent craftsmanship the article discusses.
- m0llusk 4y agoUsually the evidence of craftsmanship is fragmentary. Ornamental decorations such as engraving and paints survive on bits of structure, plaster, and statuary that allow experts to reconstruct the larger whole.
- samizdis 4y agoThere are some pictures (13) on the local newspaper's site, but they're mostly similar aerial shots and there's not really any crafsmanship on display: https://www.thescarboroughnews.co.uk/news/people/in-pictures-amazing-aerial-views-of-scarborough-roman-villa-hailed-as-world-first-3205827 https://www.thescarboroughnews.co.uk/news/people/in-pictures...
- labrador 4y agoI didn't know "reburying" was a thing but I like the idea.
- beloch 4y agoIt's pretty common. If the site isn't about to be turned into the foundations of a new supermarket (This is a common fate for archaeological sites), you can't just leave an open pit behind. People might fall in! Plus everything deteriorates faster when exposed to the elements. Erecting a building to protect the site might be a nice idea... If you had a lot of money and nothing else to do with it. Some ruins will attract tourists if you build a nice museum around them, but most are too uninteresting or remote to attract enough people to make this worthwhile. Reburying sites is standard practice. They survived hundreds or thousands of years buried under dirt, so putting the dirt back may help preserve them for hundreds or thousands of years more. Another practice that may surprise you is that archaeologists often dig up only parts of a site, deliberately. i.e. They'll leave some parts where they think there's something interesting untouched. They do this because digging is a destructive process. Any information that can be gleaned from digging up a site has to be done with the technology and methods of the day. Archaeologists of the future might be able to learn substantially more than archaeologists of today from the same column of earth. So, you dig up only part of the site and leave other parts completely untouched so that future archaeologists can return and learn things you couldn't.
- dotancohen 4y agoSeems that archaeologists are some of the few people who care about the future, as well as the past.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoOne very common justification archaeologists give for their field existing beyond heritage preservation is that it can help inform our own responses to future events. Archaeology/history is our only long-term view of societies and how they've adapted to changing conditions historically. The actual application of that research remains a bit limited though.
- unhammer 4y agoGood riddance. I'm sure the folk of Scarborough don't want another occurrence of https://scarfolk.blogspot.com/2013/05/the-ghost-of-mrs-payne-field-recording.html https://scarfolk.blogspot.com/2013/05/the-ghost-of-mrs-payne...
- randomcarbloke 4y agoIt seems reasonable to want to ensure proper excavation and to therefore rebury if the budget is not available to preserve or process the excavation, however it is still rather tragic, perhaps these articles will give the project enough visibility to chase better funding.
- altacc 4y agoHistory is full of instances of barbarism masquerading as archaeology, so gently investigating then reburying sites seems like an enlightened approach.
- throwawayacc2 4y agoI get the wish to preserve but I don’t understand why burry it back? Why not encase it in a temperature/climate controlled structure? I’ve seen plenty archaeological digs like this. Is it due to money or why?
- vanderZwan 4y agoThe soil itself also contains information. Not disturbing that unless necessary will let future archaeologists with better technology extract more information. Also, I'm guessing that the sand encasing the site is a temperature/climate controlled structure when buried properly. No sunlight and no air, for starters.
- fluoridation 4y agoThat's a valid argument against ever performing any dig whatsoever, since it's always true that future archeologists might have better technology to extract more information from anything you find.
- gchamonlive 4y agoCompared to a fully equipped and financed archeology team from today, which is not the case. Those who discovered the site know they are underequipped and underfunded for the specific site. In this case, reburying is cheap and effective.
- ziddoap 4y agoThankfully, there is a suitable middle ground of extracting some reasonable amount of information now and preserving some of the site for later.
- debacle 4y agoAnyone who has watched Time Team understands why this took place. England is filthy with Roman ruins, among other sorts. But only when you have a noteworthy celebrity, a reality TV show, and everything that is involved in that, do you have an opportunity to even scrape the surface on many of these sites. The funding just isn't there. The work is hard, complex, interdisciplinary, and mostly unsexy. But the findings are sometimes incredible.
- timthorn 4y ago> But only when you have a noteworthy celebrity, a reality TV show, and everything that is involved in that, do you have an opportunity to even scrape the surface on many of these sites. The funding just isn't there. Or proposed building works - most day-to-day archaeology is funded by developers as part of the planning process.
- theknocker 4y ago
- wswope 4y agoGonna shill Time Team for anyone interested in seeing what these villa digs look like. It’s a British archaeology series with a reality TV twist: they bring a big team of professional archaeologists and do as much digging/surveying as they can in three days per site. Twenty one seasons of it, with the vast majority officially available on YouTube - and they’re in the process of a reboot, which has been remarkably successful thus far. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=vYCRaztndtk https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=vYCRaztndtk
- louky 4y agoYep, love Time Team! The original series is what I use to go to sleep every night. Also a drinking game - drink every time Phil says "flint, evidence of burning, postholes, or 'stone the crows'". Or yells at Tony for getting in a trench without permission.
- mcguire 4y agoHow do you go to sleep watching Phil Harding's legs in those too-short cut-offs? :-)
- scop 4y agoWow I had no idea archeologists do this, but it makes perfect sense. Reminds me of a commented TODO in code when time or resources do not allow a proper implementation.
- donatj 4y agoI've always had the somewhat silly thought to myself "What if the archaeological record only goes back to the point of past archaeologists digging everything up?"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- trident5000 4y ago"when investigating land slated for a housing development" what happens to the owners/developers when this type of thing happens? Are they reimbursed by the state?
- tssva 4y agoPeople have been building on top of previously occupied sites or tearing down buildings to build new ones for our entire history. Suddenly in the latter half of the 1900s it was decided preserving these sites was for some reason I can't comprehend vitally important. We have chosen to stagnate because of the actions of prior generations.
- mcguire 4y agoMostly a case-by-case thing, I think. I know (from watching Time Team) that in Britain there are a fair number of fields which the farmer can farm, but can't dig deeper than that due to the archaeology. Other cases have existing buildings ("Oh, by the way, you have an iron-age cemetery under your house. Enjoy!"). In cases of new development, it would be investigated pretty thoroughly to determine whether it should be protected (involving negotiations with the developer), or either entirely excavated or just left and the development continues.
- basicplus2 4y agoSoooo dissapointed.. In my hast i read it as… Archaeologists [REBUILD] ‘First-of-Its-Kind’ Roman Villa Would have been fantastic to see it rebuilt rather than reburied