4 ms·
So after forcing users to enter a phone number to continue using twitter, despite twitter having no need to know the users phone number, they then leak the phon
by londons_explore 4y ago
So after forcing users to enter a phone number to continue using twitter, despite twitter having no need to know the users phone number, they then leak the phone numbers and associated accounts. Great.
But it gets worse... After being told of the leak in January, rather than disclosing the fact millions of users data had been open for anyone who looked, they quietly fixed it and hoped nobody else had found it.
It was only when the press started to notice they finally disclosed the leak.
That isn't just one bug causing a security leak - it's a chain of bad decisions and bad security culture, and if anything should attract government fines for lax data security, this is it.
- myself248 4y agoThe whole announcement reeks of "Stop hitting yourself!" What scum. They had lots of chances to fix this, the first one being not collecting phone numbers in the first place. They chose to do that, and then they didn't adequately protect it, and now they're oh so very surprised that someone might be doxing their most vulnerable users. If anyone is harmed by this, Twitter should be held liable.
- hackernewds 4y agodidn't actually not just protect the phone numbers. They actively used it illegally to market services outside of the purpose for which the numbers were gathered https://www.theverge.com/2022/5/25/23141968/ftc-doj-twitter-settlement-phone-number-security-ad-targeting https://www.theverge.com/2022/5/25/23141968/ftc-doj-twitter-...
- EGreg 4y agoIt's not just Twitter. It happens every few months. The problem is centralized sites having "real name policies", requiring you to put your phone number and other crap: https://qbix.com/blog/2021/01/25/no-way-to-prevent-this-says-only-industry-where-this-regularly-happens/ https://qbix.com/blog/2021/01/25/no-way-to-prevent-this-says...
- eli 4y agoRequiring a phone number is part of fraud & spam prevention. Maybe you'd make a different tradeoff but that's not "no reason."
- bogwog 4y ago> The FTC says Twitter induced people to provide their phone numbers and email addresses by claiming that the company’s purpose was, for example, to “Safeguard your account. > ... > But according to the FTC, much more was going on behind the scenes. In fact, in addition to using people’s phone numbers and email addresses for the protective purposes the company claimed, Twitter also used the information to serve people targeted ads – ads that enriched Twitter by the multi-millions. source: https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/blog/2022/05/twitter-pay-150-million-penalty-allegedly-breaking-its-privacy-promises-again https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/blog/2022/05/twitter-p... So you're right, it wasn't for "no reason", but it also wasn't just for fraud and spam prevention, security, or any of the other lies Twitter told users.
- junon 4y agoExactly. I don't have an issue with this if I know they're not using it to farm shit off of me. But then again, they wouldn't make much money otherwise.
- jazzyjackson 4y agoit adds a small cost to creating sockpoppets but it adds much larger value in having personal data for targeted ads like my sibling said, twitter was dishonest to their users how the phone number was to be used if it's just to prevent bot signups, why keep it on file at all?
- eli 4y agoThey no longer use it for ads, so the value now is just fraud and security. > if it's just to prevent bot signups, why keep it on file at all? I mean, you need the actual number for 2FA. I guess maybe you could hash it after some amount of time just for blocking bots? You couldn't just discard it or one number could create unlimited bots.
- spicybright 4y agoI know the answer is money in politics, SV culture, etc. But it's near certainty twitter will continue as they do in and 2 weeks everyone will move on. Maybe they get a small boo-boo in the form of a symbolic fine, mangers scramble for a bit, and then the whole thing happens again and again. Why is this?
- pauldenton 4y agoTwitter is vulnerable, most vulnerable of the big social media sites it seems. The Musk deal has fallen through, and it seems like Musk was not the only one to lose confidence in Twitter. It could easily go the way of Myspace. How many users does Myspace have these days? Active users
- autoexec 4y agoBecause twitter users care more about the convince twitter provides than they do about the risks their privacy and security as a result of using twitter. I suspect most have no idea what the risks are or have some very limited idea of some of them. Maybe if they had a better understanding of the risks they'd close their accounts and move to something new, but I doubt there be enough of them to cause twitter to invest in securing the unnecessary amounts of data they collect. This sort of thing will only be fixed when we hold companies accountable for failing to protect customer data through regulation with many rows of sharp teeth.
- InCityDreams 4y ago>Why is this? Because non-twitter users don't give a fuck. And also, twitter users don't give a fuck.
- junon 4y agoDiscord is also like this and it drives me nuts.
- lrvick 4y agoThey also refuse voip numbers. I am now at 20 back and forth emails with Discord support explaining I do not own a cell phone. They are seriously suggesting I buy one just to use Discord.
- justinclift 4y agoYeah. I used to live in a semi-rural area with no mobile phone coverage, and the insane level of disbelief from places when you tell them "I have no mobile phone" was a real problem. Including banks, and other utilities. :(
- NaturalPhallacy 4y agoI've seriously considered buying burner phones like a goddamn drug dealer for bullshit like this.
- throwaway742 4y agoBurn phone as a service.
- lrvick 4y agoCell phone numbers require KYC in almost all countries so they put people that require anonymity at risk.
- userbinator 4y agoMaybe there needs to be some sort of law that prohibits this sort of thing. In the meantime, Discord has been added to my "do not recommend" list.
- junon 4y agoPerhaps if you paid for discord. I happily pay for nitro because I see value in supporting discord. Still had to give them my number despite already paying them. I'd be happy about that sort of regulation.