4 ms·
I think in most things you need an extremist or fanatical element, so I'm not totally against doing some sums to demonstrate that something unintuitive might be
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
I think in most things you need an extremist or fanatical element, so I'm not totally against doing some sums to demonstrate that something unintuitive might be more moral and/or cost-effective.
But I might look up the EA take on some other vaguely parallel things, like Quaker businesses, worker co-operatives, fair-trade, progressive taxation, banning billionaires, revolutionary communism, bringing democracy to the middle East, nuking Russia, installing a benevolent world dictator etc.
Would help me understand them to see how they position themselves against these things as I think you could make a half-assed attempt to prove that any of them was better with their own maths if you wanted to.
e.g. if there's any billionaires then the chance of a billionaire buying elections and installing their own benevolent world dictator that believes in the wrong type of EA is a small but still existential risk (since only the true EA can save the future galactic empire). Tweak numbers as necessary until you arrive at your pre-ordained conclusion.
edit:
EA take on fair trade:
https://www.givingwhatwecan.org/blog/how-effective-fair-trade https://www.givingwhatwecan.org/blog/how-effective-fair-trad...
EA take on renewables, climate change, developing nations:
https://www.effectivealtruism.org/articles/johannes-ackva-an-update-to-our-thinking-on-climate-change https://www.effectivealtruism.org/articles/johannes-ackva-an...
An attempt to reconcile EA and anti-capitalism by a fan of both:
https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/81665058.pdf https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/81665058.pdf
EA take on Socialism (tl;dr central planning is bad, which seems slightly counter to the whole EA thing):
https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/ktEfsoGfBFGsaiY46/overview-of-capitalism-and-socialism-for-effective-altruism https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/ktEfsoGfBFGsaiY46/...
- imtringued 4y agoThe problem with longtermism is the circular logic. Longtermism rewards avoiding existential risk, so longtermism must reward longtermism i.e. one of the worst things you could do to raise existential risk is to criticize longtermism or even abolish it entirely, no matter which flavor of longtermism.
- smk_ 4y agoLongtermism in a moral context rewards thinking about the value of future beings that do not yet exist. Existential risk is important in this consideration, because it is an event that severely limits the amount of future beings that could exists. The strongest argument against longtermism is a flavour of a person-affecting moral view.