7 ms·
The productivity tax you pay for context switching
- echelon 4y agoI want a very quick intro to context switching that I can show to laypeople that don't do knowledge work. So many people I interact with don't understand the toll of interruptions.
- cweagans 4y agohttps://devhumor.com/media/never-interrupt-a-programmer https://devhumor.com/media/never-interrupt-a-programmer maybe?
- bsilvereagle 4y agoYou may be able to leverage this write-up, but it's not necessarily geared towards non-engineers: https://frdmtoplay.com/on-a-researchers-momentum/ https://frdmtoplay.com/on-a-researchers-momentum/
- crispyambulance 4y agoI think the toll of interruptions has to weighed against the benefit of the interruption. Sometimes sacrificing your time to help someone get unblocked reaps benefits that make the sacrifice worthwhile. It's not just about your time.
- codingdave 4y agoAgreed - while interruptions are a problem, a dev who refuses to engage with the wider team is also a problem. It needs some active discussion amongst the team to balance where to draw the lines.
- lysergia 4y agoI’m not so sure about this article. I’ve crafted my daily computing into various buckets not only to stay organized, but to compartment different activities from each other. For example I have a browser profile for NSFW activity that I don’t want anywhere near my professional work related activity. Likewise I have a whole browser profile dedicated to casual surfing of the web with browsing history turned off and all the browsing artifacts get erased upon closing the browser. This isolates sessions so that cookies etc can’t build massive profiles of me. Likewise I have a browser profile where I need to be logged into various services (Amazon, Netflix, Spotify etc) which keeps cookies, and no other browsing is done apart from using those specific sites. If I need to be productive, again, I context switch into a dedicated workstation that has all my devtools ready, alongside specially configured browsers that I use to test the sites I’m building. These browsers again are separated and highly context specific. Welcome to modern computing! Context switching is on the menu :)
- theshrike79 4y agoNow try context-switching from those to a hour long meandering meeting with no agenda, that you MUST attend in person and pounding away at code on your laptop during the meeting is frowned upon.
- hinkley 4y agoI have vowed that this year I'm going to use a private profile for Christmas shopping, but the problem is that once I actually buy the present, that's going to be tied into their database whether I use a private session or not. And since they love to show you ads for things you just purchased, which makes no sense to me at all, then I have to hide my browser windows from that person until December 25th or they'll be able to tell what I got them by looking at the right margin of any page I'm visiting.
- Yahivin 4y agoBuy the gift now and by the time December rolls around the targeted ads will have lost interest.
- natas_claus 4y agoOr install an ad-blocker.
- hinkley 4y agoOh the exquisite joy of having to talk a friend or loved one out of buying the thing that you got them for Christmas without giving it away.
- nerevarthelame 4y agoOne aspect of context switching I struggle with is that often a task requires short periods of forced inactivity, like waiting for a script or query to finish. Often times it’s in the scale of 1-2 minutes. It feels long enough that I don’t want to sit there staring at a progress bar, but switching to another task momentarily definitely can cause a loss of focus. The solution is probably something along the lines of: become more comfortable sitting and reflecting on the current task. Find ways to remain engaged with the current task during the waiting period (reviewing the code, adding more comments, fleshing out next steps, etc.). Don’t give in to a perception of “justified” context switching.
- analog31 4y agoI did a bunch of optics R&D, so those 1-2 minutes were spent waiting in a lab with the lights turned off and a warning light flashing over the door. You know where I'm going next. Actually, I found that a quick snooze didn't affect my flow at all.
- a9h74j 4y agoArthur Ashe the tennis player wrote about what an advantage it gave him closing his eyes for c.a. 30 seconds on each change of sides. Cumulatively: about 12 minutes extra rest after four close sets.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoYeah. At least for me, what I switch to isn't even an ounce more productive than staring at the progress bar. What I do sometimes is just to go offline. I use iptables to deny outgoing connections on 80 and 443. Then there is nothing to switch to. No emails to check, no nothing. The computer gets really quiet, for a lack of a better word. Uncomfortably so at first, but you get used to it, and after it passes, it's almost calming.
- llaolleh 4y agoFor things like that I tend to step through what I'm going to do after the query finishes. You still keep the context and planning in your head helps with the next few steps.
- Tr3nton 4y ago
- ss48 4y agoThat picture from 9am to 5pm with so many messaging apps says it all. Too much of the things that give us context is scattered and fragmented in so many places making it so difficult to take action on anything, and consolidating it would be more work than it's worth. I think a lot of what it takes to be able to do focused work is to get better at actively search for context on what you should work on and why, on what problem is worth solving in what manner. Otherwise, I find myself keeping on searching for something or browsing around to give me a sense of purpose. Once I do, though, I don't want to be distracted from it.
- julianlam 4y ago> You probably won’t finish this article. In fact, I may have already lost you to another tab in your browser. I feel called out because that's exactly what happened. I opened the link, switched over to Signal to message a friend, had a shower, and then came back to the article. Let's see how many tries it takes for me to finish (coming back to HN makes 2 attempts so far.) Edit: 3.
- nonoesp 4y agoGreat read. The references are on point and the article touches on many points of context switching thoroughly and providing actionable advice. > You probably won’t finish this article. In fact, I may have already lost you to another tab in your browser. I found it funny that the writer teases the reader to do a full read.
- muzani 4y agoI was challenged by this, but didn't finish reading it because my code finished compiling.
- _8j50 4y agoThis is why I have hundreds of tabs open. It works just fine if you have multiple things that require incremental progress so long as you complete each increment without context switching.
- flacebo 4y agoI can highly relate to this. There's also the tax of having too many tasks in queue. Maybe that's just me, but if I have to get done 10 different things in the next couple of weeks, my productivity drops to like 40% as my mind keeps switching between all of them. Having only one project without interruptions, a closed office door, headphones on with music without vocals and my productivity can even surprise me.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- renonce 4y agoThe modern communication tools aren't designed to save productivity. People like things with instant response, so things like commenting on Hacker News or sending a email works instantly, but there is no mechanism for things like telling you that the recipient is busy at the moment and will be available at 4:00 PM when he would start reading the email. Productivity isn't just about cutting down the amount of time needed for a single job, it's about arranging for things to be done more efficiently.
- slowhand09 4y agohttps://www.joelonsoftware.com/2001/02/12/human-task-switches-considered-harmful/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2001/02/12/human-task-switche...
- Foobar8568 4y agoMy problem is not context switching, that's easy, it's the jump between unrelated projects/clients, it kills everything.