6 ms·
The Last Naval Battle of World War 2 (2018)
- jlawson 4y agoQuestion. How did the Americans win? The forces were: Japanese: One junk with five Japanese officers and seventy-eight enlisted men. Armed with a 75mm pack howitzer, six machine guns, and over one hundred rifles. Americans: Two junks with two bazookas, one .50 caliber heavy machine gun, one .30 caliber light machine gun, several rifles, and grenades. It seems the .50 cal was the Americans' only advantage. That said, when I think about how this battle may have played out, a .50 could have been incredibly useful since it could outrange other weapons and shoot through basically all available cover, unlike the rifles and machine guns, but also fire much faster than the artillery.
- nullwarp 4y agoWith encounters like this it's sometimes just the roll of the dice as well.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoI mean... the article explains it in detail. The bazookas took out the howitzer, the HMG was useful, and later they just got within range and spammed hand grenades to great effect before wrapping it up with a melee boarding party (I presume the enemy was basically defeated by this point).
- jlawson 4y agoThe articles says what happened, not why it happened that way. _Why_ did the bazookas take out the howitzer, and not the other way around? Howitzer seems like a more powerful weapon for the situation. The Americans were greatly outnumbered, so _how_ did they win?
- neither_color 4y agoThis got me curious and while a quick search didn't give me much info on what kind of "howitzer" these junks had, this similar naval gun had an optimistic fire rate of 5 rounds per minute and was less effective against agile targets. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/20_cm/12_short_naval_gun https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/20_cm/12_short_naval_gun So my guess would be light, slow, inaccurate gun against highly maneuverable bazookas. It seems to me like a bazooka vs tank situation. Tanks are more powerful but a well positioned bazooka will kill a tank.
- jonstewart 4y agoOutnumbered by manpower, but they had two ships. The howitzer was a heavier weapon but pretty limited all the same.
- themadturk 4y agoHowitzers are built to fire at an upward angle -- perhaps less accurate overall when going up against a target where both the gun platform and the enemy are moving? The bazooka, on the other hand, fired at a flat trajectory.
- saberdancer 4y agoTo fire a howitzer you need to calculate the angle at which you need to fire and amount of propellant. It seems like an incredibly hard thing to do on a ship and with the enemy maneuvering. It's likely you could only guess and hope for the best. Usually howitzers fire, observe where the shell lands and then adapt. Here this couldn't work as ships changed positions. In other words, you are right. Having something that you can point and shoot is easier to do. This might not be true if they could aim their howitzer low but then you get the fact that howitzer cannot be steadied (it will roll with the ship) while a human holding a bazooka can do some stabilization and fire at an exact moment the target is in crosshairs.
- themadturk 4y agoMaking a bazooka much more like a gun on a sailing ship, able to time their fire with the roll of the ship, while a howitzer would be more akin to a mortar on an 19th century bomb ketch, where precision of aiming, powder needed for the shot and timing of the fuse are arrived at by trial and error. (I am reading through the Hornblower books for the umpteenth time, so Napoleonic sea warfare is fresh in my mind.)
- saberdancer 4y agoBazooka would be more like a rifle on a ship. Much easier to aim with the roll and you get your arms to do the stabilization. Howitzer works as a mortar or if they are lucky and can aim low, as a non stabilized gun.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoI doubt the howitzer was that great. The battled opened with a hit on the foremast from the howitzer and it seems the ship still worked well enough to participate.
- Sporktacular 4y agoAnd the fact they had two boats over one.
- Archelaos 4y agoWhat a waste of lifes! The Tennō had already broadcast via radio his intention to surrender a week before. The war was practically over.
- Sporktacular 4y agoYeah right? The bombing of Nagasaki was 12 days earlier, and the surrender shortly after that. So unnecessary.
- duxup 4y agoI wonder why the Japanese chose to open fire.
- CamperBob2 4y agoProbably the same reason why there will always be a debate about the net lives saved/taken with the atomic bombings. The Japanese were indoctrinated to keep fighting regardless of the odds. Plenty of them wanted to fight on even after the bombs were dropped. The fact that it was a hopeless cause was beside the point. Or, maybe they just had a broken radio and didn't know what was going on. Shame the article doesn't say more about the enemy's motivations.
- duped 4y agoIt's no wonder the US didn't mint another Purple Heart until 1976. They were prepared for more casualties in the Japanese home islands than the nation saw in all conflicts since, combined.
- billfruit 4y agoSimilarly in World War 1, over 2700 soldiers lost their lives in combat, on the day the Armistice came to effect.
- credit_guy 4y ago> Swentzel was later awarded the Navy Cross for relentlessly pressing the attack against overwhelming odds. His actions were in accordance to the highest traditions of the United States Navy. I never cease to be amazed of the performance of the US Navy in WW2. How did these "highest traditions" come about? America did not really fight naval battles in WW1. Before that they won a quick naval war against the Spanish in 1898, but arguably the Spanish were well behind technologically, in an era when technology was evolving by leaps and bounds. In WW2 though, the US sailors were simply incredible. And the absolute majority of them (maybe 99.9%) did not have any prior combat experience. How did the US Navy turn from an inexperienced Navy into the most fierce-some naval force ever assembled in history? And it's not just the industrial might of the US. Sure, in many encounters the US Navy just had more and better warships. But at least until 1943, there were plenty of encounters where it didn't, Midway being obviously the most famous. There was something about the fighting spirit of the US Navy, but how did that get nurtured, considering that the US was a nation at peace? I genuinely have no idea.
- vkou 4y ago> How did the US Navy turn from an inexperienced Navy into the most fierce-some naval force ever assembled in history? Numbers[1], technology, practice in the interwar years[2], and a lot of trial and error. Also, the war in the Pacific was largely an air war, where both of the two belligerents were more-or-less figuring both doctrine and how to implement it from scratch. Also, it helped that Japan could not take advantage many of its victories early in the war, due to lack of numbers, supply shortages, and an absolutely rotten command culture (It had a habit of firing competent admirals because they didn't win hard enough.) [1] By the end of the war, American shipyards were building an aircraft carrier, two escort carriers, two heavy cruisers, and ten destroyers every month. [2] Being surrounded by two oceans, the US has always depended on its navy in its ability to wage war.
- sonofhans 4y agoI have a few ideas, and I’ve read about this for years, fascinated and frustrated that my dad was in WW2 but never talked about it. Most recently I’ve read The Pacific War[1], a comprehensive classic. The USA had two huge long-term advantages that Japan could not match: intelligence and production. For most of the war we were reading most of the Japanese encrypted communications. It’s one reason that we won the battle of Midway, for instance. In terms of production, the US moved its economy into a war-footing quickly and nearly completely. People were planting Victory Gardens so that food producers could use less petroleum for farming and fertilization; tires were rationed. Over the long term it’s impossible to see the relatively small island of Japan standing toe-to-toe with the USA. E.g., I found a 50-year-old dissertation [2] on the subject which claims that in 1939 over 90% of Japanese imports of petroleum, copper, and several iron and steel products were from the USA. It’s one reason they kept expanding during the war, despite the risk of being unable to hold territory: they needed the resources. Certainly there are other factors, but these have always stood out to me as incontrovertible advantages. 1. https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/437549.The_Pacific_War https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/437549.The_Pacific_Wa... 2. https://shareok.org/bitstream/handle/11244/23634/Thesis-1972-K91i.pdf https://shareok.org/bitstream/handle/11244/23634/Thesis-1972...
- ggm 4y agoGreat shame there wasn't two Japanese Junks, so they could do the Thomas Cochrane/Nelson thing of attacking boat #2 across from the deck of boat #1 having stormed it.
- TylerE 4y agoFor anyone interested in this sort of thing… https://youtube.com/c/Drachinifel https://youtube.com/c/Drachinifel
- gadtfly 4y agoSeconded. I've been a big WWII guy my entire life but never realized how much I'd been shortchanging myself with neglect of naval stuff until I started watching Drachinifel.
- ngold 4y agoChiang Kai-shek and madame shek and big eared du, were horrible. But better than Mao? In the long term?