3 ms·
> They can make more by selling higher volumes at a lower margin. Higher margins are made closer to the consumer. > (If we build best, we should eat the desi
by amelius 4y ago
> They can make more by selling higher volumes at a lower margin.
Higher margins are made closer to the consumer.
> (If we build best, we should eat the designers' cake too.)
Apple is eating software developer's cake ... (well, 30% of it).
The greatest businesses on the planet all rely on brand recognition. TSMC has none and relies only on its technological expertise which at some point might be surpassed by a competitor. There is a reason why Apple wants to own the entire supply chain, and they are smarter about it because they start at the other end (close to the consumer) where margins are larger.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Higher margins are made closer to the consumer Which is consistent with and irrelevant to making “more by selling higher volumes at a lower margin.” Higher margins are made by Michelin-starred restaurants than TSMC. That doesn’t mean they should expand into fine dining. Chasing margins at the expense of profits is bad business. Cannibalising Apple would mean losing volume, from Apple and others, which in turn undermines TSCM’s scale-based advantage.
- amelius 4y agoThis isn't about Michelin restaurants versus McDonald's. This is about McDonald's versus farmer joe who makes the best potatoes which are essential to McDonald's business. If tsmc were run by Apple's board, we would all be paying 30% of our income for the privilege of using modern computers. A much better strategy, just look at Apple's balance (and Apple products aren't even as exclusive as tsmc's).
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> were run by Apple's board, we would all be paying 30% of our income for the privilege of using modern computers This was IBM. For fundamental, structural reasons, they were dethroned. TSMC doesn’t have the option of eating Apple’s cake without giving up the scale that makes it competitive. Again, it’s similar fresh-MBA thinking that tanked Intel. (TSMC wouldn’t exist hadn’t Intel given it the neutral market space.)
- Throwawayaerlei 4y ago"> were run by Apple's board, we would all be paying 30% of our income for the privilege of using modern computers This was IBM. For fundamental, structural reasons, they were dethroned." I think they did it to themselves, first by eschewing virtual memory in the System/360 and first models of the System/370, thus losing the higher education market and what people eventually moved to like UNIX, thus their big machines become a specialized niche of the whole computer market. Then in moving from a preference of leasing to sales which gave them a one time goosing of revenue which they didn't prepare to lose when the cycle of that ended. They did do well in PCs for a while, but the unit that did that in Florida eventually got blue washed (there's lots more to the story of course). "Again, it’s similar fresh-MBA thinking that tanked Intel." Also very unsure of this, I don't see that resulting in the 10 nm now Intel 7 debacle. More like their decades long high level very bad engineering management eventually caught up with their crown jewel of fabrication. The not so fresh MBA I assume CFO who was made an interim CEO actually had a plan which might have succeeded. I don't think the current CEO's plan has much if any chance at success, especially since I don't see him making the brutal moves necessary to change the company culture to work as a foundry. In particular, I note while he worked for Intel for a long time, he's a design instead of fabrication guy, the latter is what they needed and I wonder if they couldn't hire anyone good from that field.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> they did it to themselves, first by eschewing virtual memory in the System/360 and first models of the System/370, thus losing the higher education market and what people eventually moved to like UNIX, thus their big machines become a specialized niche of the whole computer market Yup. They went from neutral generalists to niche specialists. TSMC is, today, a neutral generalist with the scale of Apple, AMD, Qualcomm, Samsung and the others combined. You’re (EDIT: Nope!) advocating trading that for Apple’s profits. Short-term versus long-term greedy. > McDonald's versus farmer joe who makes the best potatoes Replying to a parent comment of yours (EDIT: Also wrong!). McDonald’s has scale. TSMC has scale. Farmer Joe competing with McD’s makes sense. Tyson competing with McD’s does not; it will lose, in the long run, McD’s as well as other restaurant chains as customers with that play, undermining its home-turf edge while it competes where it has none.