4 ms·
>Do I understand correctly the much of the worlds semiconductor fabrication is in Taiwan Not straightly true. The worlds "leading edge" Semiconductor Fabs is
by ksec 4y ago
>Do I understand correctly the much of the worlds semiconductor fabrication is in Taiwan
Not straightly true. The worlds "leading edge" Semiconductor Fabs is located and dominated by TSMC. Yes. But Semiconductor as an industry includes many things not leading edge like small chips used in appliances as well big volume commodities like NAND and DRAM. Those are mostly in South Korea, Japan and then US. ( Along with Singapore and Germany in case anyone wants to nitpick. )
If TSMC get destroyed, it will likely set back the whole Semiconductor industry by 10 years. Simply rebuilding the Fabs capacity, leading edge or not would take 5 - 10 years with perfect project planning and execution. Not to mention no player in the industry has shown they are capable to providing similar quality, yield, services to TSMC with similar prices at an acceptable margin.
- amelius 4y ago> If TSMC get destroyed, it will likely set back the whole Semiconductor industry by 10 years. If that is true, why doesn't TSMC crank up its prices? Or why don't they build a consumer brand? They could fade out Apple if they start building their own consumer products.
- swores 4y agoI don't understand what part of the sentence you've quoted makes you think that TSMC hasn't put a lot of thought into their price points already. Regardless of how true quoted sentence is, it's also obviously true that if they changed prices to $1billon for every single chip sold then they would sell close to zero chips (ignoring that such a crazy move would probably see an attempt to replace leadership, or a takeover attempt, or whatever). And equally, if they lowered their prices to give each sale only 1% of their current profit margins, they would sell more chips. Every time they set a price, they'll be thinking about where the line is to get that balance right. And they already know they're the industry leader, and of course they know it in a lot more detail than that simple statement, so they're taking that into account (along with things like demand, how close the competitor products are, etc.) Of course that's not to say that they've necessarily made the ideal choice every time, and maybe if they raised prices they would make more money overall. But how does the fact that them literally disappearing would set back the industry make this more or less likely to be the case?
- amelius 4y agoRead the rest of my comment. The point is that TSMC could do much more to optimize their market position.
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoWhy are you convinced your armchair strategy is superior to decades worth of analysis by one of the most successful companies in the world? TSMC has no desire to become Apple because they already capture so much of Apple's revenue. I guarantee you they have put enormous thought into the exact optimal price point, as building fabs is extremely capital intensive.
- swores 4y agoI stand by my comment - I could write the exact same response to the paragraph you added as to your original one (with minor tweaks from "changing prices" to "entering new business areas").
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> why doesn't TSMC crank up its prices? They can make more by selling higher volumes at a lower margin. > Or why don't they build a consumer brand? They could fade out Apple if they start building their own consumer products. There is a lot more going to Apple's products than TSMC's fabs? To say nothing of their business with MediaTek, AMD, Qualcomm, Broadcomm, Nvidia, Sony and others [1]. This is the same failure Intel fell into, compounded tenfold. (If we build best, we should eat the designers' cake too.) [1] https://www.gizmochina.com/2021/12/15/tsmc-top-10-customers-revealed-apple-accounts-for-quarter-of-revenue/ https://www.gizmochina.com/2021/12/15/tsmc-top-10-customers-...
- amelius 4y ago> They can make more by selling higher volumes at a lower margin. Higher margins are made closer to the consumer. > (If we build best, we should eat the designers' cake too.) Apple is eating software developer's cake ... (well, 30% of it). The greatest businesses on the planet all rely on brand recognition. TSMC has none and relies only on its technological expertise which at some point might be surpassed by a competitor. There is a reason why Apple wants to own the entire supply chain, and they are smarter about it because they start at the other end (close to the consumer) where margins are larger.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Higher margins are made closer to the consumer Which is consistent with and irrelevant to making “more by selling higher volumes at a lower margin.” Higher margins are made by Michelin-starred restaurants than TSMC. That doesn’t mean they should expand into fine dining. Chasing margins at the expense of profits is bad business. Cannibalising Apple would mean losing volume, from Apple and others, which in turn undermines TSCM’s scale-based advantage.
- amelius 4y agoThis isn't about Michelin restaurants versus McDonald's. This is about McDonald's versus farmer joe who makes the best potatoes which are essential to McDonald's business. If tsmc were run by Apple's board, we would all be paying 30% of our income for the privilege of using modern computers. A much better strategy, just look at Apple's balance (and Apple products aren't even as exclusive as tsmc's).