2 ms·
> I get what you're trying to say, the point I was trying to make was your mode and manner of messaging has ostensibly changed in recent time. Sure—I came to t
by rayiner 4y ago
> I get what you're trying to say, the point I was trying to make was your mode and manner of messaging has ostensibly changed in recent time.
Sure—I came to the realization that my color blind upbringing in Republican Virginia isn’t something my kids will be able to enjoy. Instead they’ll be writing essays about how their grandfather grew up in a village in Bangladesh to persuade some admissions officer that they should get into college/get a job/etc. As Hilary Clinton might say, I’m resentful about that: https://www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/supreme-courts-roe-v-wade-opinion-sparks-racist-attacks-clarence-thoma-rcna36261 https://www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/supreme-courts-roe-v-w...
> E.g., just now way too casually you've in broad strokes implicated democrats to be behind duplicitous and conniving schemes in which they treat Hispanics and minorities as mere pawns in their games.
I think it’s ignorance and wishful thinking. Building a coalition is hard and nobody wants to compromise. It’s easier to assume that non-white people think like your Latinx friend from grad school, and changing demographics will make traditional politics obsolete.
There’s also a kind of neo-colonialism. No less than the British in the 1700s, progressive Democrats believe that their own culture is morally superior. They think white societies have evolved the correct views about human rights, gender roles, sexual morality, raising children, etc. They want and need Muslim immigrants and religious Black and Latino people to vote for them, but have no intention of compromising with those groups over the party’s social agenda. (An amusing illustration of this phenomenon recently was white liberals calling Clarence Thomas “Uncle Tom” for views on abortion and same sex marriage that are typical for a Black man from the south.)
> To win hearts and minds
I think we’re past that. I think progressives are in a quasi-religious thrall, and moderate liberals defenseless against them. I’m hoping for a decade in the wilderness-type collapse of the Democratic Party, like what happened with Reagan, or what’s happened recently with Labour in the UK.
- tptacek 4y ago"Defenseless against them"? We depantsed them in the last election cycle. I could say the same thing about the "Christian Nationalists" and jet-fuel-doesn't-melt-steel-beam-ism if your party. Come off it. The real world isn't Twitter.
- kasey_junk 4y agoWorse than that. While the out there wing of the Democratic Party is getting absolutely housed in their primaries and state elections, the Republican Party has leaned into the wilder edge of their party (e.g. Cheney being literally kicked out or Cruz saying more children would die if assault weapons were banned). As for identity politics, how can we talk about that without observing the normalization of paramilitary culture on the right? From the ubiquitous thin blue line flags to the 3 %er sheepdog culture, large portions of the right are gearing up for political violence, most of it directed at black people. The Republicans of my youth who stood for good governance, the rule of law, low taxes & strong civic engagement have been replaced at all levels by preppers, populists & grifters. I can understand being disgusted by the racial politics of the anarchy-socialist wing of the left but to take up with the republicans of 2022 over it seems like madness. It’s a lot easier for me to see a “coexist” bumper sticker than a “Hang all traitors, starting with the Democrats” one. But your mileage may vary.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pen2l 4y agoThe pendulum is swinging wide across the far-stretched expanses of the Overton window. The temperature is hot everywhere. There was an older gentleman I used to have conversations with in my teenage years when I was living in the midwest, an ardent NRA-supporter, Vietnam-war vet, an old-school American, good-hearted and sweet and wonderful to talk to, quite open to hearing out my then progressive-views and arguing against it. I met him again after a decade and saw that he was a full-on boisterous Trump supporter, unwavering in his belief that Jan6 was justified. Though it was tragic to see him go off in the deep-end, I could not in good conscience write him off, because I knew him and his history. I would like to believe that even the wave of paramilitary culture can be understood, lest we make a fundamental attribution error. Likewise I wish Rayiner would more often employ the principle of charity: engage not with views of people on Twitter, but with the views of the electorate that got Biden in the white house. My best reading tells me that frustrations, particularly of elderly folks, can be traced in some part to the unfair expectation of them to always be up with the latest revision of a social code prescribed and concocted in a place far removed from their dwellings, and when they're not up on it they're quickly cast aside and sometimes demonized. Of course the slighted will show their anger, of course the left-aside will want to rise again. The temperature is hot, and there isn't a moderating force in sight. Strange times. Worrying times.
- specialist 4y ago> ...progressive Democrats believe that their own culture is morally superior. They think white societies have evolved the correct views about human rights, gender roles, sexual morality, raising children, etc. That was absolutely true. Happily, those Boomers (and some Gen-X) are aging out of the party. > I think progressives are in a quasi-religious thrall Going to guess that you're referring to wokeness. In my observation and experience, the people making a fuss, about the latest wedge issue, are not the people getting things done. And they're rarely party members. The party (of whatever flavor) is about platforms, policy, and campaigns. It's a huge amount of work. Most of it really sucks. And the people doing this work don't have time for food fights on twitter and whatnot.