5 ms·
I would suggest that it’s a bad idea for liberals to actually drink their own Kool Aid, or they’re going to overlook the facts on the ground. https://theliberal
by rayiner 4y ago
I would suggest that it’s a bad idea for liberals to actually drink their own Kool Aid, or they’re going to overlook the facts on the ground. https://theliberalpatriot.substack.com/p/whats-going-on-with-hispanic-working https://theliberalpatriot.substack.com/p/whats-going-on-with.... And standing around complaining that brown people are “voting against their own interests” is not a good look.
I’m an immigrant from a Muslim country who used to be a Democrat, and now I vote Republican, in part because I think the way Democrats view race is bad for minorities, and also consciously or unconsciously a pretext for consolidating cultural power in the hands of white elites: https://contexts.org/blog/who-gets-to-define-whats-racist https://contexts.org/blog/who-gets-to-define-whats-racist. Moreover, I’ve been all around the country, the Midwest and the south, and I’ve never met anybody that is “against who I am.” What I’ve met is people who are concerned about cultural change, in the same way people from my home country would be if the shoe were in the other foot.
- tptacek 4y agoYou've been a self-identified conservative since before you signed up for HN, so the liberalism you're implying you had here must have been confined to your very early 20s, before you were "the token conservative" at law school. :) (I'm not dunking on you; you've gotten, uh, pretty strident in the last year or so, but your conservatism is one of the things I appreciate about your presence here.)
- nec4b 4y agoI can't remember when was the last time I read an original comment from you that wasn't a snipe at rayiner. It's too bad, because you used to have insightful ideas.
- tptacek 4y agoNothing I said here is a snipe at Rayiner. If you'd like to read comments of mine that aren't directed at Rayiner, click my name above the comment you're reading, then "Comments".
- pen2l 4y agoNo, he was a staunch liberal about 10'ish years ago. Often linking to NYTimes/Paul Krugman to substantiate his points, being a firm advocate for AA programs, touting city-life and public transportation when he used to live in New York city. It's actually remarkable how much of a one-eighty he did. And as someone who looked up to him, and would often be convinced by the carefully thought-out rationale he'd provide for his viewpoints, very articulately so, I think I veered toward conservatism myself with him. But in the last year, the luster has been a little bit lost. His take on things once used to be the decidedly adult-in-the-room take, despite being a lawyer, what he wrote never came off as slimey, slight-of-hand lawyerly drivel, no, it was intellectual, rigorous, and a pleasure to read. But something has changed in the recent months. What's going on Rayiner?
- tptacek 4y agoNone of these things are incompatible with conservatism. But we shouldn't litigate this; my comment was light-hearted.
- rayiner 4y agoIn the past decade, Democrats tried to replace their working class white “blue wall” voters with immigrants and minorities. That gave rise to (1) an ugly and manipulative racial politics, seeking to unify unrelated “people of color” with oppression narratives, and (2) emboldened white progressives, who thought they wouldn’t have to moderate to keep Hispanics in Arizona in the fold the way they used to have to do for working class whites in Ohio.
- pen2l 4y agoI get what you're trying to say, the point I was trying to make was your mode and manner of messaging has ostensibly changed in recent time. E.g., just now way too casually you've in broad strokes implicated democrats to be behind duplicitous and conniving schemes in which they treat Hispanics and minorities as mere pawns in their games. Uh okay mayyybe someone at the DNC or a blue think-tank thinks like this and has said something along these lines to their fellow counter-part, but it's not how the regular run-of-the-mill liberal on the street or the average liberal on HN is thinking. To win hearts and minds either here in this little corner of the internet or out there in meat-space, it's not worthwhile or productive to say such a thing, if you do then in their view you're making a strawman so you lose a potential sympathetic ear and indeed the chance to win hearts and minds. Maybe qualify your statements differently, say "the heads at the DNC" instead of using indiscriminately general labels like "Liberals" or "Democrats" which tends to make the message start sounding adversarial. By the by, is running for any political office in the stars for you? (I pose the same question to you, Thomas. Frankly I wish both of you would consider it).
- dctoedt 4y ago> I’ve never met anybody that is “against who I am.”" That's because in the era of mass- and social media, many racists have become quite skilled at encoding their views in dog whistles. I went the opposite direction from you — formerly a pretty-conservative, reliably-Republican voter, now a Yellow Dog Democrat for the time being; formerly a Nozickian, now largely a Rawlsian. A major milestone was visiting the National Civil Rights Museum at the Lorraine Motel in Memphis, where MLK Jr. was assassinated. I've always been well-read in history, but the matter-of-fact exhibits on slavery and Jim Crow had me fighting back tears; a couple of times I came close to sobbing. (And yes, I know the Dems and GOP have switched places on that subject since Reconstruction.) Generational head starts make a difference. If you haven't watched this YouTube video (kids doing a foot race but some being given big head starts), you should: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8vvHWAjh3Ks https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8vvHWAjh3Ks
- specialist 4y agoOne last comment... TLDR: We know. Pundits like Ruy Teixeira treat (national) politics like k-means clustering along just two axis. (Cite Duverger's Law.) Plabum for political hobbyists. Axiomatic truths (meaning worthless) worthy of the NYT op-ed page I absolutely guarantee you that Democrats know that Latinos, for instance, are culturally more conservative than college educated whites. Further, I absolutely guarantee you that campaigns work very hard to the thread the needle, accommodating a very diverse coalition. The (national) coalition of Democrats is most simply defined as "not Republican". Inspiring, right? (Whereas the Republican coalition is simply defined as anti-majoritarian, pro-wealth, and reactionaries.) Given the Biden Admin's policy successes, and Republican's self-own with the SCOTUS, hopefully Democratic messaging will become affirmative (what we're for), not just what we're against. You said it yourself. Coalition building is hard. And "big tent" left-wing coalitions are so much harder than the right-wing coalitions. Along with the structural disadvantages, and normal organizational dysfunction, it's a wonder that Democrats ever win at all. Knowing a bit about how this stuff works (but mostly doesn't), whereas most laypersons and pundits whinge about Democrats, for or against, I marvel whenever something good gets done.