3 ms·
A corporation is made up entirely and exclusively of humans. Machines, buildings, vehicles, software - these are no more part of the corporation than your own c
by tsimionescu 4y ago
A corporation is made up entirely and exclusively of humans. Machines, buildings, vehicles, software - these are no more part of the corporation than your own car or phone is a part of you.
The legal definition of a person is very clear. Even the logical definition is actually quite clear: anything that can possibly exercise most of the rights of a human in a meaningful way can be considered a person.
Can a horse own a piece of land in the same sense that a human does? Not really, as a horse simply can't exercise the right to sue someone who would infringe on its property rights even if it were granted one. Sure, a small child or an adult in a coma may be in a similar situation, but the child may eventually grow up and become able to exercise such a right, and the adult may eventually wake up from that coma.
A machine of any kind that actually exists today is far farther from being able to recognize and exercise any human-like rights than the horse is, in fact. So it's even more absurd to assign copyright to a machine than to an animal.
- visarga 4y ago> A machine of any kind that actually exists today is far farther from being able to recognize and exercise any human like rights than the horse is, in fact. Tell that to Blake Lemoine. /s
- trasz 4y ago>The legal definition of a person is very clear. Indeed: “The reason for the term "legal person" is that some legal persons are not people” (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_person https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_person)
- cwillu 4y agoThe actual legal decision we're talking about was quite clear that a corporation being composed of humans was not relevant: “While these opinions addressed different questions – concluding that neither corporations nor sovereigns can be inventors – our reasoning did not depend on the fact that institutions are collective entities.” (A collective entity is a technical term that does carry the implication of being composed of humans)