2 ms·
I know nobody wants to do the "software engineers vs engineers" debate again, but even if we are going come down on the "programmers are software engineers" sid
by bee_rider 4y ago
I know nobody wants to do the "software engineers vs engineers" debate again, but even if we are going come down on the "programmers are software engineers" side of that debate, a site which exclusively serves software engineers shouldn't advertise itself as for engineers generally. I was excited to see what EE's would be chit-chatting about. :(
As a suggestion -- it might make sense to put a link to your demo page right near the top of your main 'jointaro' site somewhere, it did a good job of showing what the value proposition is.
- ryanSrich 4y agoYeah I agree. Even though I do work in software, when I read the post title I thought general engineering (civil, mechanical, electrical, etc.). In fact, I didn't even initially think software engineering at all.
- rpandey1234 4y agoAgreed that there's an important distinction between engineers generally vs software engineers. Hard to fit everything in the 80 characters for the title -- I hope the first line makes it clear. Thanks for the suggestion on surfacing the demo page more prominently, we definitely want to do better with embedding the actual content in the landing page.
- dang 4y agoWe could change the title to say "Software engineer" but then we'd have to drop the word "Private" and people would probably start complaining that they didn't expect it to be a closed community.
- bee_rider 4y agoIt isn't a huge deal really. But I think Launch HN: Taro (YC S22): Private software engineer career growth community or Launch HN: Taro (YC S22): Private career growth community for software engineers would fit, I think. IMO the latter is more clear anyway.
- dang 4y agoOk let's go with the latter. I was going to say "80 chars on the nose" but I had to mess with the punctuation—or rather, you did (with the double colon). Thanks!