9 ms·
I grew up in a dense urban core and can’t imagine putting kids through it. Little to no green space, no riding your bikes down random streets until it’s get da
by refurb 4y ago
I grew up in a dense urban core and can’t imagine putting kids through it.
Little to no green space, no riding your bikes down random streets until it’s get dark. No exposure to nature. Cramped in tiny $1M apartments immersed in the rat race.
- tptacek 4y agoTiny $1MM apartments aren't the alternative to SFZ.
- bluGill 4y agoBe careful though. Until we fill all the demand of people who can afford to pay for those $1MM apartments nobody will be building cheaper stuff. That there is demand for tiny apartments says we have a problem with supply.
- pcwalton 4y agoThere are plenty of very livable US college towns with medium-density downtowns, condos for far less than $1M, plenty of green space, and streets I'd feel comfortable letting my kids (if I had any) ride their bikes around. Bloomington, Indiana, Madison, Wisconsin, and Davis, California (granted, that last one isn't as affordable as the others) come to mind among places I've been to. I imagine places like Ann Arbor, Michigan and Champaign, Illinois rank up there too.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- refurb 4y agoThose aren’t suburbs to you? Sure the main commercial street (maybe a few blocks total) isn’t, but Ann Arbor is 90% suburban single family homes. It’s like San Mateo. The Main Street is more dense but very few choose to live there. It’s mostly endless single family homes. Hell, I’d call a good part of SF “practically” suburban. Sunset is mostly block upon block of single family homes with maybe 1 corner store within a 10-15 min walk. Transit is easy on a narrow strip, otherwise you’re screwed without a car. I personally don’t see much difference between that and what people rail against as suburbs.
- presentation 4y agoYou mean American, crappily designed urban cores. Plenty of cities around the world that are safe, have plenty of green space, and are much more affordable than those in the US.
- refurb 4y agoYeah, no. I spent time in Singapore. Incredible transit system, carefully designed "Garden City" with plenty of outdoor areas, modern, efficient, affordable public housing. And what did people aspire to? Single family homes, with their own yard and a car. What HN sees as "people are forced to live in the suburbs", is in reality, people just choosing what they like best. Same in all the other countries I've lived in. Sure, 20-somethings love living in "hip" cities with "trendy" restaurants and "fun" bars to go and are willing to trade all that for tiny apartments. I don't deny that. But a very substantial part of the population don't want that. They want space, quiet neighborhoods and are willing to have to drive to get that.
- Sakos 4y agoI'm very confused. Singapore doesn't have the space for single family housing. The vast majority of homes there are flats/apartments. https://www.singstat.gov.sg/find-data/search-by-theme/households/households/latest-data https://www.singstat.gov.sg/find-data/search-by-theme/househ...
- Omniusaspirer 4y agoYes, but the most valuable are the freehold GCBs.
- thablackbull 4y agoI think what he means is that, given the choice, people there would opt for a good class bungalow (essentially your 'detached home', but most will never be able to afford it). That is an obvious statement, but the analogy breaks down a bit as in Singapore, whether you live in a GCB or in HDB (social housing), everything is relatively close by regardless. Hence, there isn't really much of a trade-off at all - living in a GCB just affords more space and privacy (at an exponentially inflated cost).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yardie 4y agoMy city had more dog parks than kid parks. As the lone parent raising a kid in the city when I can make it to the city planning meetings I’m usually drowned out by the dog park “lobby”. Living in the city is great; access to museums, art, culture, food, and transit is tops.
- bluGill 4y agoLike most cities, yours has pushed out parents and the concerns of kids. Suburbs are more welcoming to kids in general because here we have more parks for kids than dogs. Here we don't have museums - but we don't miss them because we know from experience our kids can only stand being in one for about 10 minutes before they start doing that will get us kicked out if we don't leave first. A good portion of your art not kid friendly. Culture is everywhere, we don't get the "high culture" of the cities, but we have our own culture that works for us. We do a lot more cooking at home as we can't afford eating out as much, but I will grant when we do go out there is a lack of choices. All you really have that we would even use is much better transit. It doesn't have to be that way. I'm told NYC is still welcoming to kids. Most cities though are not places where they have things for family.
- gommm 4y ago> Here we don't have museums - but we don't miss them because we know from experience our kids can only stand being in one for about 10 minutes before they start doing that will get us kicked out if we don't leave first. A good portion of your art not kid friendly. As a kid, I loved going to the natural history museum and the science museum. There's plenty of museums that caters to kids and that are really great with kids (not sure in the US to be honest but at least that's true in Europe). Museums doesn't mean art only. Likewise for theater plays, that's the kind of things that are only available in bigger cities but can be tons of fun with kids.
- frumper 4y agoWe have kids museums in the US too. As a new parent I just discovered 2 nearby that have been here for decades. They have old donated vehicles like a police car, city bus, ambulances, or science stations, things like that. Things like plays exist, but it rural places they tend to be limited productions, either school or a traveling group. It may not make financial sense to have a play offered 6 nights/week all year in a small town, but a couple weekends throughout the year is common.