7 ms·
> can be an order of magnitude more productive per hectare for sunlight-to-protein than growing crops in fields. But what's the efficiency of converting Hydrog
by gus_massa 4y ago
> can be an order of magnitude more productive per hectare for sunlight-to-protein than growing crops in fields.
But what's the efficiency of converting Hydrogen (and CO2) to carbohydrates? Pulling number out of thin air, I'll be very happy if it's 10% or 20% [1]. So from solar to carbohydrates they get 20%*80%*¿20%?=3% that is the double of potatoes, not an order of magnitude better.
And the conversion to proteins is even harder. They need a microorganism that can fixate Nitrogen from the air (that is very costly for the microorganism) or use a fertilizer like ammonia nitrate (that use a lot of energy in an industria plant).
[1] For an easy, one step organic reaction in the lab, the efficiency is like 60%-70%. It varies a lot, but never expect something like 99%. In the lab, most reactions use a brute force approach like boiling it in acid, instead of using a specialized enzyme. On the other hand, the transformation form H2 and CO2 to carbohydrates has like 10 or 20 steps, and each step has a small lose. I'd be happy with a global 20% efficiency, but perhaps I'm too optimistic.
- sitkack 4y agoWould Alpha fold help genetically engineer new ways to efficiently process CHON into food-stuffs? https://alphafold.com/search/text/nitrogen https://alphafold.com/search/text/nitrogen I think the cool part of using solar panels to have an electrified process is that you can use non-farmland (Bill Gates is buying it all :), could use less water, also produces electricity. In the perfect future, we are all sucking on tubes of atmospheric liquid cheese product. From pipe to pipe.
- philipkglass 4y agoThis report finds 10% as a lower bound and 60% as an upper bound for the energy efficiency of hydrogen oxidizing bacteria: "The energy efficiency of carbon dioxide fixation by a hydrogen-oxidizing bacterium" https://sci-hub.ru/10.1016/j.ijhydene.2013.04.153 https://sci-hub.ru/10.1016/j.ijhydene.2013.04.153 The authors found a tradeoff between efficiency and growth rates. The highest efficiency came with the slowest growth rate. But they concluded that 50% efficiency was achievable at practical growth rates. Keep in mind also that potatoes only contain about 10% protein by dry weight while the bacteria cultivated to make single cell protein can contain 50% protein by dry weight. Soybeans are about 40% protein.