13 ms·
Visa, Mastercard suspend payments for ad purchases on PornHub, MindGeek
- giarc 4y agoBill Ackman has been vocal on this issue and check out his Twitter for more commentary on this. He feels Visa's board is in big trouble here.
- sandworm101 4y ago>> He feels Visa's board is in big trouble here. Visa is too big to ever be in big trouble. They constantly have some class of customers that are "dangerous" to do business with. Once upon a time it was porn websites. Then it was VPNs. Then it was "filesharing" services. Eventually as these thing become normal and better-understood by the general public Visa relents. The only thing Visa really fears is some upstart payment system eating into their territory (paypal).
- giarc 4y agoIANAL but I believe the board can be held criminally liable in this situation, meaning they could serve jail time. I've, admittedly, only skimmed some articles, but I believe the issue is that PornHub (mindgeek) knowingly hosted child porn and even after Visa was made aware, continued to do business with them. I could be wrong though.
- sandworm101 4y agoThe danger too is a bit of the Streisand effect was ongoing. Footage that was taken down became more popular when re-uploaded. From the outside, it looked like Mindgeek was not implementing industry-standard protocols to prevent repeated uploads. And they were pulling "windfall" profits from those re-uploads. The situation looked too similar to the "Girls Gone Wild" and later fiascos involving non-professional pornographic content.
- stlewis6 4y ago
- elzbardico 4y agoDo we really want private companies to be in the business of law enforcement?
- treis 4y agoNo, but we probably don't want them profiting off of child pornography either.
- coldtea 4y agoNo, but if they could have state power they could. Private companies after a certain size (which Visa certainly qualifies) have to be forced to be open and neutral - they'd expand their power to anything they can given the chance. (Same goes for the government, but at least that you get to vote for).
- R0b0t1 4y ago> but at least that you get to vote for). Unbridled optimism.
- quest88 4y agoThey're trying to prevent the law from being used against them. From the article: A federal judge in California on Friday denied Visa’s motion to dismiss a lawsuit by a woman who accuses the payment processor of knowingly facilitating the distribution of child pornography on Pornhub and other sites operated by parent company MindGeek.
- nickff 4y agoThe real costs here are not from the expected outcome of the lawsuit (which is unlikely to succeed), but from the discovery and other legal costs. When large companies are defendants/respondents in lawsuits like this, the costs of going to trial are astronomical. I think Visa doesn't mind the law as much as the legal system.
- richbell 4y agoCredit card companies have an incredible amount of influence: they're effectively gate-keepers for monetization on the web. There's a long history of them blacklisting people and even using their influence to pressure companies from removing them.
- colpabar 4y agowhy don't they just build their own payment processor :^)
- commandlinefan 4y agoIronically, this move on the part of the payment processors will likely lead to adoption of alternative methods of payment for these sites... which will make it even harder to track down the truly illegal stuff.
- sandworm101 4y agoThat's how we got bitcoin. Wikileaks was dropped by Visa and other payment providers. Everyone then looked for an unblockable payment system, which moved bitcoin from a niche tool to the "cool" form of payment.
- carrotcarrot 4y agoAnd it terrified the federal government.
- DIARRHEA_xd 4y ago
- salawat 4y agoBy definition, if you don't do what VISA is doing, the regulatory state will declare you an illegal payment processor. Like it or not, part of the baggage of doing that service is being an extension of the long arm of the law. So "rolling your own" minus the regulatory baggage you don't like, isn't per se "making your own payment processor", but something else. Bit of a Catch-22, but how it works. Everyone just tends to leave the quiet part unsaid.
- joyfylbanana 4y agoPornhub is committing the crime here. Visa was just processing payments here - and isn't any more, since they stopped it. Why isn't everyone talking about pornhub and demanding them to ban that? Pornhub essentially is already their own payment processor, as it looks like they are processing cryptocurrency payments from the customers.
- DaveExeter 4y ago"Visa condemns sex trafficking, sexual exploitation, and child sexual abuse" What a brave stance. It's nice to see a card network that cares about the children.
- joffems 4y agoDo they care about the children or their reputation? The Financial Times released an 8 episode podcast titled Hot Money on who controls the industry. The podcast isn't appropriate for everyone, but is a great listen.
- athammer 4y agoI think they were being sarcastic. At least I’d hope so. Not sure any company that large actually cares
- smartbit 4y agohttps://www.ft.com/content/762e4648-06d7-4abd-8d1e-ccefb74b3244 https://www.ft.com/content/762e4648-06d7-4abd-8d1e-ccefb74b3...
- Clubber 4y ago"For the children," is often an excuse by organizations to do nefarious things, like the still ongoing and massively destructive drug war.
- carrotcarrot 4y agoPretty sure he was being sarcastic. Nobody uses the phrase "the children" unironically in current year.
- m00dy 4y agoAnother reason that we need a decentralised blockchain and a decentralised stable coin.
- jeromegv 4y agoBy definition, you can't have a coin be stable while at the same time not having a centralized instance that keep it "stable". Those are oxymorons. It's one, or the other. We can't just repeat any buzzword without thinking about what exactly does it actually mean in practice.
- smitop 4y agoDecentralised stablecoins, such as Dai, do exist, and the price of Dai does manage to maintain its peg pretty well. Not all decentralised stablecoins have done as well (most notably TerraUSD) though, it's definitely hard to design an algorithmic stablecoin that maintains its peg.
- ALittleLight 4y agoI think that commenter means it's logically impossible. In what sense is DAI "decentralized" if its value is set by the same centralized group that sets the value of a dollar?
- MitPitt 4y agoMind sharing where you got that definition from?
- joyfylbanana 4y agoThough bitcoin volatility has been going down along the years, it might be quite stable after 10 years or so.
- ehsankia 4y agoAnother win for the extremist anti-porn group Exodus Cry. They are just using a small handful of cases slipping through the cracks to make it look like PH is doing nothing to moderate this content. Their end goal was never to protect children, their goal is to eliminate all pornography from the internet.
- sashenka 4y ago
- ravenstine 4y agoMaybe Visa should also suspend card payments for the theaters and streaming platforms that enable major Hollywood studios to sweep the jailable crimes of their producers under the rug. But muh Marvel movies! /s
- malfist 4y agoYou know if porn bothers you....you could just not browse it. Leave it for the rest of us. It doesn't impact you.
- throwfh80h82 4y agoThat's really not true. We live in a society and interact with each other, we're not isolated, atomized robots (despite Silicon Valley's best efforts).
- mise_en_place 4y agoBut I thought we don't need VISA anymore? We can just use the latest crypto /s
- auggierose 4y agoWell, cases like that make me think we actually DO need crypto. We do need an equivalent of digital cash, because what some CEOs or board members think and do shouldn't influence whether you can pay your rent or not. It's really as simple as that. If you can learn to drive a car and not kill a massive amount of people in the process, you can probably also learn how to operate a crypto wallet safely.
- dangerboysteve 4y agoseriously, if you were Visa what would you do ? https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-62372964 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-62372964
- wollsmoth 4y agoWhat a mess. They started requiring age verification for the people in uploaded videos but maybe they should take it a step further and only accept content from approved accounts, like reputable studios that keep records.
- knaik94 4y agoOne of the reasons why pornhub is popular is that it lets individual users create a professional looking channel for themselves and has subscriptions which it takes a cut of. The approved accounts thing already exists and pornhub has already purged old/unverified content in the name of safety once, in December 2020. It removed removed around 10 million videos. Visa and Mastercard already went through this process with pornhub and other mindgeek-owned websites. https://www.theverge.com/2020/12/14/22173858/pornhub-videos-removed-user-uploaded-visa-mastercard-verified https://www.theverge.com/2020/12/14/22173858/pornhub-videos-...
- wollsmoth 4y agoYeah, I remember reading about that. Maybe visa needs better assurances that they aren't going to get nailed again by being their payment processor.
- Manuel_D 4y agoThey already are: Google for 2257 records keeping requirements.
- labrador 4y agoI believe that recent crackdowns are worse for people in the long run. Lets assume that most sexually active people look at porn now and then, which I think is a safe assumption, and that teens learn about sex from watching porn. These changes and age verification requirements have eliminated all the normal amateur sex scenes between regular consenting adults (On RedTube for example) and left the age-verified professional porn, which depicts unrealistic sex between adults who don't give a sh*t about each other, but have perfect bodies and big parts. Instead of showing wholesome normal sex, now all we get is porn shop slut/stud sex
- wollsmoth 4y agoStudio shot material is definitely a bit more exaggerated and more selective with their performers. However, I don't really have the impression that amateur shot stuff is "showing wholesome normal sex". Some studios do produce more realistic video but in my experience the amateur stuff is just worse lit and self shot. Still usually made by someone just trying to get a few quick bucks.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoI think the OPs point was that teenagers could start considering this the 'normal'. Personally I give them a little more credit. But it is a good point.
- wollsmoth 4y agoYeah. It's hard to control what teens see and what their interpretation is. I don't know if there are really great examples of what healthy sex lives should be like. Everything is just extremely graphic and widely available.
- sidlls 4y agoI don’t agree, based on at least my personal experience. My wife and I (40s) don’t engage in even a fraction of the acts I see commonly in porn. My bf (mid-20s) and I, on the other hand regularly do. He sees these acts as normal and expected. She definitely does not, and neither do I. Anecdotes aren’t data, to be sure, but my bf’s friend group has a similarly completely different view of what is “normal” with respect to sexual activity, and the same is true for others of similar age I’ve been involved with. I’m convinced porn definitely shapes the view of normal.
- pueblito 4y ago> As porn star Cherie DeVille explains, the story is, and has been, a lot weirder than that. Because Visa and Mastercard hold effective duopoly status all over the world — controlling 98% of credit transactions in the U.K., 80% in the E.U., and over 70% in the U.S. — no porn performer can afford to cross the rules for acceptable content the two companies have laid down. And those rules are beyond strange. “Women are allowed to squirt, but we’re not allowed to urinate,” DeVille says. “We can’t insert our panties into our vaginas anymore, because that’s an object. I tried to use a carrot-shaped dildo. That’s a problem because that’s an object, too, but a phallic-shaped dildo is apparently okay.” She shakes her head in amazement. “The rules are completely nonsensical.” https://taibbi.substack.com/p/meet-the-censored-cherie-deville https://taibbi.substack.com/p/meet-the-censored-cherie-devil...
- nicbou 4y agoThat meeting must have looked like a Monty Python sketch
- pixxel 4y agoForgive me, but I’m sat here wondering what “squirt” is in reference too. I don’t wish to google it. Diarrhoea related? So women can defacate but not urinate?
- JamesBarney 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_ejaculation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_ejaculation
- nsajko 4y agoLook here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_ejaculation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_ejaculation Note that both male and female ejaculation may be faked in a porn movie.
- aasasd 4y agoMore to the point, squirting in porn is pretty much guaranteed to be urination, simply due to the volume and strength of ‘gushing’ involved.
- Ekaros 4y agoCentral Bank currencies are starting to look better and better. At least then it is the government deciding. And that might be controlled by voters. Or violent revolutions.
- Nolandforme 4y agoHow is that a better option? The people pushing these anti-porn movements by dragging payment processors to court also have massive influence within the government, they would simply forbid any use of their currency on unapproved items.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoSection 230 rocks! I love watching an endless stream of porn with clearly unwitting female subjects. Visa needs to stay in their lane!
- BasilPH 4y agoThe relevant law here is called SESTA-FOSTA. It forces companies to ensure they don't host content that facilitates sexual exploitation. This has impacted full-service workers (i.e., prostitutes). Before SESTA-FOSTA, they could put up ads on specialized websites, chat with the clients and then have them come to a room they had rented. This arrangement gave them basic security. After SESTA-FOSTA, the pages hosting those ads folded, as they couldn't comply with the new rules. Many full-service workers are now walking the streets again and have to have sex in their clients' cars. It's obvious that this makes them much more vulnurable. It even goes further: Banks will close your account if they think your business has something to do with "sex", even if what you do is legal. If they feel you might be a risk, they freeze your account. This law has hurt many sex workers, often people already at the very bottom of society. On the other hand, it's unclear how many lives it saved from sexual exploitation. Sex workers are vulnerable, and many women are being abused. But the way this law was enacted, I can't help but think that pushing sex work further into illegality was a desired side-effect. Source: I know a couple of sex workers in NYC.
- AndyMcConachie 4y agoYou're right about SESTA-FOSTA being terrible, but I don't think it's the relevant law here. The relevant code here is 1591(a)(2). https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1591 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1591 The opinion of the court is that the defendents benefit monetarily from a commercial sex act involving someone below 18 years of age.
- jcranmer 4y agoIf you want to understand why this happened, read this recent court decision: https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cacd.823614/gov.uscourts.cacd.823614.166.0.pdf https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cacd.82... Basically, a court recently ruled that, since Visa is processing payments for ad purchases on Pornhub, Visa is a co-conspirator on all sex trafficking and child porn that Pornhub is involved with. Apparently Pornhub merely being alleged to have engaged in those activities is sufficient knowledge to constitute a "meeting of the minds" for Visa to become a participant in those activities. (As you might imagine, I vehemently disagree with that ruling. But as it's the ruling that stands, it's the situation that Visa finds itself in, and were I in Visa's shoes, I'd do exactly the same thing they're doing now. They really don't want to be a part of this--and they really shouldn't be a part of this, and dumping Pornhub's ad purchases is the fastest route they can take to not be a part of this, as problematic as it is.)
- savant_penguin 4y agoThat's an interesting take. Would other companies that support pornhub/across in any way also be considered participants? Water supply/electricity/ internet providers/whoever sells them dildos/food
- happyopossum 4y agoPayments are a pretty specific aspect of trafficking, and while it's feasible some of those other areas you mention could be problematic, Visa has to be much more worried than the caterer.
- jcranmer 4y agoThe argument specifically relies on the financial processing role: > MindGeek is being sued for knowingly monetizing child porn. Visa’s act of continuing to recognize MindGeek as a merchant is directly linked to MindGeek’s criminal act, as Visa’s act served to keep open the means through which MindGeek completed its criminal act knowing that that criminal act was being committed. At this early stage of the proceedings, before Plaintiff has had any discovery from which to derive Visa’s state of mind, the Court can comfortably infer that Visa intended to help MindGeek monetize child porn from the very fact that Visa continued to provide MindGeek the means to do so and knew MindGeek was indeed doing so. Put yet another way, Visa is not alleged to have simply created an incentive to commit a crime, it is alleged to have knowingly provided the tool used to complete a crime.
- dieselgate 4y agoIt’s hilarious to me that ads for porn are just more porn
- wollsmoth 4y agoA fierce competition for the people who might actually pay.
- seydor 4y agoGoogle does not allow anything that shows tits even if covered. And google gatekeeps advertising. But i remember decades ago, late night shows on TV which were almost soft porn had lots of ads, especially alcohol/cigarettes. We live in neovictorian times.
- root_axis 4y agoVisa only cares about money, just like every other megacorp. They will take as much money as they can for whatever they can, the only reason they're suspending payments is because they are facing legal liabilities. What other choice do they have?
- ivraatiems 4y agoI think legal porn (e. g. featuring consenting adults) is generally a-okay and shouldn't be illegal or banned... but I also don't need much convincing to believe MindGeek and Pornhub are bad actors. It simply isn't in their financial interest to protect people who need and deserve protecting, and so they didn't/don't. Anti-porn groups couldn't ask for more ideal enemies. Yes, I know that the vast majority of the content they post is perfectly fine and legal. But enough of it isn't, and they are lax enough in checking, that they kinda deserve punishment at this point. But I also don't think porn is going away. I hope whoever replaces them (looking at you, OnlyFans) is less scummy, so it is easier to defend them.
- cricalix 4y agoA timely podcast about some of this is Hot Money: Who Rules Porn. Pushkin Industries and the Financial Times. Dives into some of the history of the industry, payment processors, and so on.
- antonymy 4y agoI don't personally care one whit about the fortunes of Pornhub but this sets a very bad precedent for the internet. The payment processing duopoly is a huge problem, they are able to dictate way too much of what is allowed to exist on the internet. Today it's illegal pornography that everybody agrees is terrible, but that's how it always starts. The safe targets, the stuff nobody objects to, to establish precedent. Once they have this power to censor it is extremely hard to walk it back.
- markdown 4y agoThese card companies have too much power. Companies engaged in the kava trade (vendors, kava bars, etc) have a very hard time with payments processors and banks due to the strict rules of Visa and Mastercard despite kava being a legal dietary supplement in the US.
- simoneau 4y agoI recommend this podcast-miniseries "Hot Money: porn, power and profit" by the Financial Times: https://www.ft.com/content/762e4648-06d7-4abd-8d1e-ccefb74b3244 https://www.ft.com/content/762e4648-06d7-4abd-8d1e-ccefb74b3... It spends quite a bit of time explaining how the credit card companies became the de-facto regulators of porn on the Internet.
- seydor 4y agoAwaiting for when they will suspend payments to facebook , where a lot more child porn is uploaded. I hope visa is forced to expand this on all adult websites and even further. Maybe some of the cryptocurrencies will finally do what they were designed to do
- mrkramer 4y agoLeaving porn aside....Bitcoin FTW This is what Satoshi was talking about; "Commerce on the Internet has come to rely almost exclusively on financial institutions serving as trusted third parties to process electronic payments. While the system works well enough for most transactions, it still suffers from the inherent weaknesses of the trust based model[0]." So I need to trust and rely on Visa, MasterCard and other credit card companies not to cut me off their network? And they can do it anytime because they might not like my business, my business model or my business practices. If business is legal and up and running just let it be. [0] https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
- vlod 4y agoI've been thinking of what happened with the Canadian truckers. Irrespective of whether you believe their cause, the ability for the state (Canada) to freeze bank accounts is disturbing. With the general use of centralized crypto exchange, we just swapped two masters (Visa/Mastercard) with another (Coinbase). Of course with private wallets, we could technically avoid centralized exchanges, but the on/off ramps to crypto (fiat in/out) with the state KYC requirements, an authoritarian state could still go after the linked bank accounts. Welcome suggestions on the way forward. Maybe decentralized exchanges?
- LatteLazy 4y agoThese companies need to be regulated like any other utility. But no one will because they're hoping to use private companies to at morality police in a way governments are not allowed to.
- _8j50 4y agoIt should be a law to require human approval before any porn content is posted. I mean for obvious hints of minor presence. They can require government id for account creation as well. Moreover, "Teen (18+)", "barely legal" and similar content should not be allowed. You would think DRM would have been all about enforcing this instead of corporate greed.
- stereoradonc 4y agoI find it hard to believe Visa and Mastercard were unaware of what MindGeek does. Why reach to a situation which can be a PR disaster and avoid these companies altogether?
- erenyeager 4y agoWelcome to hear from. The damages of widespread available pornography and the child exploitation rings around them are outraging. These websites are a gateway into cam sites and shady kik group chats where adult men sext minors. This is my perspective, being a victim myself.
- zxcvbn4038 4y agoI think the trick here will ultimately be to add a layer of indirection. Mindgeek could launch a bazillion internet bodegas that sell gift certificates that happened to be redeemable at Pornhub and their other properties. They could operate their ad business over regular banking networks. Basically anything and everything ti make it more complicated for Visa and Mastercard to simply look up Mindgeek and block the account. It would also provide some relief to Visa/Mastercard since they could say truthfully that they don't do business with Mindgeek. You can also counter the bad propaganda by pointing out that Visa/Mastercard are still very active selling alcohol, tobacco, narcotics, gambling (half the US states allow you to buy lottery tickets with credit cards, all the casinos take credit cards), guns, and pretty much every other vice. Though I don't think their role in purchasing guns makes them accomplices to murder anymore then processing a payment for a porn site makes them an co-conspirator to anything related to that. But if they want to make the case that they are then that sets precedent they are co-conspirators for everything else as well.
- hda2 4y agoWow, finally a legitimate use case for cryptocurrencies! In all seriousness, this nonsense is exactly why I continue to support crypto to this day. Visa, Mastercard and some random court jurisdiction in some random country should not have a say in whom I transact with.