3 ms·
> I think the most reasonable approach is definitely the one mentioned by this activist: “The most privileged people should be the ones who start sacrificing fi
by gruez 4y ago
> I think the most reasonable approach is definitely the one mentioned by this activist: “The most privileged people should be the ones who start sacrificing first,” Huber told Motherboard. “It’s unfair to ask the poorest people to give up polluting activities first if the richest don’t have to give up anything.”
No, the most reasonable solution is for everyone to be responsible for their own pollution. If you generate 15 tons of co2, you need to either eliminate those emissions or find some way of offsetting them. Who cares if you're a global jet setter generating hundreds of tons of co2, if you're properly sequestering them? "Banning private jets" is how we go from something reasonable (ie. "you shouldn't be able to damage a shared resource") to moralizing (ie. "you should be prevented from doing something, even though it's not harming others").
- rurp 4y agoI agree with the principle here, but worry that carbon offsets will always be a lossy abstraction. My prior is that any metric that is hard to measure, while having strong financial incentives to game, will be heavily gamed. Offsets are hard to track and measure accurately and we've already seen a lot of dishonest behavior in this area. This is not to say that banning private jets is the answer, but I think the actual solution (if we get to one) will have to be a messy hodgepodge of approaches.
- TremendousJudge 4y ago>Who cares if you're a global jet setter generating hundreds of tons of co2, if you're properly sequestering them "Sequestering" carbon is, right now, complete science fiction. Nobody can actually do it. The most that can be done is paying to maybe prevent other people from emitting -- but the emissions always go up. So if one day proper carbon capture technologies exist, this argument can be made. Right now, it can't.
- gruez 4y ago>Nobody can actually do it They can. https://www.cnbc.com/2021/07/23/these-companies-are-sucking-carbon-from-the-atmosphere.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/07/23/these-companies-are-sucking-...
- TremendousJudge 4y agoI should have made it clearer -- by "actually" I mean "in a net negative way". Otherwise it's useless. It's not clear at all from the article, or from any other of these carbon capture schemes I read about (just yesterday there was one in the front page of HN -- and in fact, _that_ article[0] said that this method literally burned gas for heat), how they achieve this. Because the country this is installed in uses fossil fuels for its electricity. Not to mention all the logistics equipment (trucks) necessary to have this plant in operation. And burning fossil fuels to pull carbon out of the atmosphere is never going to make sense due to thermodynamics -- even at 100% efficiency, you'll only break even. Which makes me very suspicious that the biggest investors are always oil companies, as though they can burn all the fuel they extract from the ground and also capture all the carbon it emits. Which is not possible, but maybe they hope that with enough sleight of hand nobody will notice. [0] https://spectrum.ieee.org/carbon-capture-2657738131 https://spectrum.ieee.org/carbon-capture-2657738131
- gruez 4y ago>It's not clear at all from the article, or from any other of these carbon capture schemes I read about (just yesterday there was one in the front page of HN -- and in fact, _that_ article[0] said that this method literally burned gas for heat), how they achieve this. Is this specific enough for you? It seems to avoid all the pitfalls you mentioned. https://climeworks.com/co2-removal https://climeworks.com/co2-removal
- suoduandao2 4y agoWhat is your criticism of this technology? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Z75A_JMBx4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Z75A_JMBx4
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Supermancho 4y ago> No, the most reasonable solution is for everyone to be responsible for their own pollution. I think you are incorrect. 2 issues with this make it less reasonable than other alternatives. 1. Traditionally, costs are externalized to lower economic tiers (corporate socialism), in capitalistic countries. The wealthy charter isn't responsible for the Carbon, because they aren't producing it. It's not their plane. The cost might be shared across the staff (possibly + passengers) or the organization funding it, etc. There are a multitude of easily accessible avoidance tactics. 2. Politically, this is a non-starter for the masses during economic downturns and a 50/50 during economic upswings. The tyranny of the masses would rather a percentage of higher economic tier members take on costs than themselves. These forces are a large part of why the movement for carbon neutrality has only been promoted (mostly voluntarily!) by big corporate PR announcements. Granted, mostly these are accounting tricks rather than true carbon sequestering, which is needed.