2 ms·
I don't think your example is indicative of what he opposed. If you can't effectively train something from existing data then cherry picking results according
by nonethewiser 4y ago
I don't think your example is indicative of what he opposed.
If you can't effectively train something from existing data then cherry picking results according to different values isnt going to fix it. Your example has quietly shifted from facial recognition of different races to speech about different races. I cant even be sure of what you're talking about other than the fact that you will oppose criticism of imparting political bias into models.
- magicalist 4y ago> If you can't effectively train something from existing data then cherry picking results according to different values isnt going to fix it. Given the variance in the utility of copilot's suggestions, this doesn't seem true on it's face. Define "effectively" here and I think cherry picking would definitely fall within its range.
- mlyle 4y ago> then cherry picking results according to different values isnt going to fix it. Again: "merely a refusal to return results in an area where the model has proven problematic." > Your example has quietly shifted from facial recognition of different races to speech about different races. Again, three points: * First, no matter how you feel about gender: bias in AI is a problem, as evidenced by issues with recognizing black faces. * Second, there's some obvious cases where we can all agree that using past training data could result in things that are currently offensive. There are pieces of language we pretty much all agree we should use differently now to avoid offense (e.g. mongoloid). * Third, I believe that gender is one of these cases. Social mores are evolving. Using conventions from the past when our collective norms are changing on the span of months basically guarantees offense.