3 ms·
Is it an excuse or an acknowledgement of reality? I think everyone agrees that in principle, all else being equal, it would be good for uniformed Space Force Gu
by nradov 4y ago
Is it an excuse or an acknowledgement of reality? I think everyone agrees that in principle, all else being equal, it would be good for uniformed Space Force Guardians to maintain high fitness standards. But the reality is that the service has to recruit from a population that's becoming steadily less fit. Military leaders don't have the ability to reverse that trend in the civilian population, so in order to maintain force levels at a politically acceptable funding level they have to make hard choices and compromise standards somewhere. So would you prefer that they keep fitness standards high but take recruits with lower ASVAB scores or less education or criminal records? Something has to give.
The concerns about a sudden enemy or terrorist attack seem a little silly. We're talking about people who spend all day staring at screens, and don't even have weapons issued or close combat training. Base security will still be provided primarily by Air Force Security Forces (or civilian employees), and no one is proposing reducing fitness standards for them.
https://www.spaceforce.com/military-careers https://www.spaceforce.com/military-careers
- remarkEon 4y ago>it would be good for uniformed Space Force Guardians to maintain high fitness standards I'm literally not asking for that. I'm advocating for baseline levels of fitness. It isn't some herculean effort to do 30 push ups, some ab exercises, and shuffle step for 1.5 or 2 miles (or whatever the AF standard is) without passing out. If you can't do that yet, that's totally fine! That's what basic training is for, and no one should feel ashamed for not being able to do that as a civilian. You don't show up day zero and are expected to max your PT test. >The concerns about a sudden enemy or terrorist attack seem a little silly. We're talking about people who spend all day staring at screens, and don't even have weapons issued or close combat training. Base security will still be provided primarily by Air Force Security Forces (or civilian employees), and no one is proposing reducing fitness standards for them. Again, while it's likely that the facilities these people are operating in are far from the battlefield, and will be/are hardened, I don't see how saying "don't worry no war will find you, at least physically" is relevant to the other points I've made. You say that these people are rare, and their technical skills highly important to national security. And I agree with you, which is why the military should make sure they stay in shape, for their health and for them to be able to do their jobs better. It sounds like we're maybe making different arguments, and what you're really saying is that the Space Force should be mostly civilians, or people who feel like they're civilians but just wear a uniform 9-5, M-F. I disagree with this perspective, and I apologize if you aren't advocating for this. To address this question: >So would you prefer that they keep fitness standards high but take recruits with lower ASVAB scores or less education or criminal records? Something has to give. I prefer a draft.
- mrguyorama 4y agoThe military is an at-will organization. If you don't want to do pushups then don't join the military.
- nradov 4y agoYes, and the push-ups requirement is one of several reasons why the military has been unable to meet target personnel levels in some critical non-combat jobs. Do you have a constructive, practical suggestion for fixing that problem?
- alldayeveryday 4y agoMake physical fitness a key component of the educational system, as it once was. The public education system should focus more on nurturing the character of youth, with physical health being intrinsic to mental health, and less on useless propaganda that is jammed down their throats in the current system. We need to expel the poison inflicting the minds and bodies of our youth.
- nradov 4y agoThat's a really vague rant. What are you suggesting specifically? The public schools in my district all have required PE classes, and there are after school sports for students who want to participate. So physical fitness is still a key component of the educational system. What more do you want schools to do? Should they cut history class so that students can spend more time doing push ups? I haven't seen much propaganda in the curriculum.
- alldayeveryday 4y ago> I haven't seen much propaganda in the curriculum. Did you attend the public educational system in the US? And if so, you didn't see much propaganda in the curriculum?