6 ms·
>My wide-open Verizon cell-phone number is my least preferred method of contact by far, due to the fact that I cannot trust that unknown numbers are high-value
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
>My wide-open Verizon cell-phone number is my least preferred method of contact by far, due to the fact that I cannot trust that unknown numbers are high-value incoming calls.
I thought it was a legal requirement for phone network operators to leave phone numbers accessible to all, and hence their inability to effectively fight spam.
Otherwise, what would stop the situation from becoming like email, where email is more likely to be delivered if sent from a big player and less likely from a small player.
- cr1895 4y agoWhat does “accessible to all” mean in this context? Why do I in Europe get almost zero spam calls or text while in the US it seems like a plague?
- katbyte 4y agoIn Canada and while I do get some it’s fairly rare. Maybe 1 a month.
- Ensorceled 4y agoI get 4-5 a week on Bell, my SO gets 1-2 a day on Rogers.
- katbyte 4y agoHave you signed up for the national do not call list?
- Ensorceled 4y agoYes, of course I have. But the “CRA”, Duct Cleaners, and the women who speaks only Chinese all ignore that list.
- katbyte 4y agoI really wonder what the difference is between numbers, I’m on telus and I don’t think they make any attempt to block them? And I’ve had my number for 20 years, with both bell and Rogers in the past. and made no effort to keep it secret. Thou I occasionally answer the calls when I’m bored and waste them time.
- happyopossum 4y agoAnecdotes do not constitute data. My family in Canada gets tons of robocalls and spam calls, to the point that nobody answers unrecognized numbers unless they're expecting a call...
- Scoundreller 4y agoThings seem to be improving: I’m getting fewer and fewer “neighbourhood” calls. I suspect the vector is moving away from VoIP systems and more toward buying masses of prepaid plans and stuffing them into various contraptions that hold hundreds of sims to blast out messages/calls. https://m.aliexpress.com/item/1005004095035108.html https://m.aliexpress.com/item/1005004095035108.html
- katbyte 4y agoHave they signed up for the national do not call list or renewed it? as it expires iirc. My friends in the same boat often never signed up like I did.
- enlyth 4y agoUK here, we get tons of scam robocalls to the point where I leave my phone on airplane mode with Wi-Fi enabled like 95% of the time.
- pdpi 4y agoYou mean you haven’t been in an accident that wasn’t your fault?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoAccessible to all meaning the rules for being part of the public switched telephone network: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_switched_telephone_network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_switched_telephone_netw... Again, I am not sure and very well may be wrong, but I think I recall reading or maybe just assuming that the FCC or maybe a global agreement bars individual network operators from not accepting calls from others within the network. I imagine this gets very hairy due to international jurisdictions and things like caller ID spoofing. See section on Legal Considerations: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caller_ID_spoofing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caller_ID_spoofing An interesting conversation that came up in my research about this topic for why a telco might be barred from blocking against certain numbers: https://www.techdirt.com/2007/03/16/can-a-telco-block-phone-calls-to-a-number-they-dont-like/ https://www.techdirt.com/2007/03/16/can-a-telco-block-phone-... I have no idea why European numbers might not get spam calls with the same frequency as American. Maybe the spammers are looking for English speaking people, or Americans are richer or easier to scam?
- Scoundreller 4y agoDepends on the country. I think it comes down to availability of cheap labour for call-based vectors. French numbers can get tons of spam calls, because there’s no shortage of impoverished French speakers in the world.
- kmacdough 4y agoEU may be stricter about enforcing, but I've also experienced it's very person-dependent. People who need to answer unknown callers for business reasons (small business owners, sales, etc.) get put on lists of "known active numbers" and may get multiple spam calls a day. Folks like me who can just ignore any unknown number & respond only if they leave a real voicemail, get FAR fewer (maybe 1 a month on avg). We tend to complain less about the issue (even if it is annoying & I still treat all unknown calls as spam by default). Also, if you own a google device, they're very good at IDing spam callers. I recently switched from Google to Samsung and get far more.
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoBecause you have a functioning government.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoWhen you target Americans, you can use a single language to hit 239 million people with their native/first language. You can't do that in Europe.
- cptskippy 4y agoIn the US, one of the loopholes in rules requiring STIR/SHAKEN and other protections was that smaller carriers, usually serving rural or under served markets, were exempt. This became a profit center for them as they became one of the only means for these spam calls, which originated in overseas call centers, to connect to US callers. Thus the smaller carriers were incentivized by profit to connect the calls.
- MiddleEndian 4y agoNow that STIR/SHAKEN is supposedly a thing, is there a way in Android that I can block calls that go through those carriers?
- cptskippy 4y agoUnfortunately it's carrier to carrier and not data we're privy to. Carriers get paid arbitrage fees for carrying or connecting calls, so they really have no incentive to stop these calls other than legal liability.
- MiddleEndian 4y agoThen they really dropped the ball on SHAKEN/STIR. At a minimum they should pass the customer all the hops so we can block shit we don't want (international calls, VOIP calls, known spammers, known bad companies etc.) on our end.
- cptskippy 4y agoTelecommunications is interesting in that everything strives to be backwards compatible and will accommodate the lowest common denominator to connect a call. It's very much like Microsoft Windows, in that backward compatibility is both a strength and a common source of problems. Government mandates don't usually go beyond borders, so carriers have to accommodate international operators. And any new features or technologies often introduce or expose problems. When Caller ID was introduced, there was a huge backlash around privacy. Callers were upset about having the number they were calling from being exposed. If a doctor called a patient it could expose his direct or home number instead of the office number. In the age of phone books, a phone number could be associated with an address. The ACLU sued to block Caller ID until it was possible to disabled it. Because large call centers operated hundreds of numbers and wanted a way for them to all appear as the same business entity. Carriers later implemented ways for these customers to spoof Caller ID so that the carrier wasn't responsible for maintaining it. Carriers connecting calls had to trust the originating carrier's caller ID info as well. All these requirements allowed for a bad actor to spoof Caller ID and for it to just be trusted. Carriers use to have star codes you would use for certain features like disabling Caller ID, disabling Call Waiting, and, famously, calling back a number that called you. These are similar to the AT codes you can issue to the modem in your cellphone via the dialer. Kids today will never appreciate REM's Star 69. When digital cellphones arrived, they presented some odd challenges too like the fact that call information was transmitted digitally to the carrier and not via analog tones. Because number presses on your cellphone didn't equate to analog tones over the line, cellphone users couldn't interact with IVR menu systems (e.g., "Press 1 for English..."). Character limits in SMS messages come from the fact that they occupied the null space in beacon messages transmitted between cell towers and phones. Before MMS was a thing you couldn't send longer messages or if your phone broke them up into chunks, they might be delivered out of order or not at all.
- toast0 4y agoUS has a larger market with a single language, and our regulators demanded calls to mobile phones to be on an equal footing for callers. You never needed to pay more to call a cell phone than a land line from the same rate center; the cell phone user has to pay any additional cost to carry the call over the air. Additionally, inter-carrier rates are regulated and set to approximate costs, which is now pretty much zero. This makes bulk calling and texting inexepensive (less than a penny per message or minute). In (most of?) Europe, callers have to pay for the privilege or calling a cell phone, and the numbers are in different ranges, and it's not cheap, 10 cents or more per minute or message at bulk rates; even though the underlying cost is probably similar to the US, near zero.
- onetimeusename 4y agoOver the last few years the FCC rules on carriers were relaxed so that they can discriminate against calls originating from domestic networks. Previously they could not block calls even if it was obvious it was a scam call. However, it's not always obvious which robo calls are legitimate and which aren't. The bigger issue though is not about domestic origin calls, it's about foreign originated calls that the FCC has no power over. The domestic carriers had to forward these calls. There is traction gaining to require that calls that originate overseas verify their identity to US based networks. Domestic carriers can reject calls that don't verify (spoofed numbers that originate offshore). That still may not stop all the spam calls but it will slow it down. The problem here is really that telephony became extremely cheap and accessible to the whole world.
- kabdib 4y agoI never, ever get legitimate calls from overseas. Just turn those calls off for my phone. Well, perhaps callbacks from helpdesks located in other countries, in which case give me time-boxed control over foreign calls, and perhaps a passcode that I can communicate along with my callback number. There are billions of dollars at stake, of course. This is a solvable problem, and the FCC doesn't even need to get involved. The carriers care more about the money than their customers (so what else is new?)
- bluGill 4y agoThe problem is someone from overseas can claim to be from a US number. The number you see on your phone can be anything the caller wants it to be. A fair number of robocalls are from overseas but looks to you like they come from your country.
- kabdib 4y agoThat's precisely what the carriers need to solve. They're not interested.
- cuteboy19 4y agoCan't all of this be done locally on the phone? Why does the phone app not have an option to simply ignore all garbage calls
- brk 4y agoThere is nothing preventing them from providing users with more granular call-rejection controls. Their networks need to be "accessible" on the incoming call side, but that does not mean as a customer I should be forced to have every call intended for my number to be routed through to my phone. An iptables concept with a user friendly UI would address much of this problem, particularly if we could filter on useful call origination data, or lack thereof.
- nightski 4y agoThe major carriers have this but charge for it. Like $5/mo. It's pretty sad.
- phkahler 4y ago> I thought it was a legal requirement for phone network operators to leave phone numbers accessible to all... If only they were required to use caller ID to reliably tell us who is calling...
- lotsofpulp 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caller_ID_spoofing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caller_ID_spoofing
- 300bps 4y agoI thought it was a legal requirement for phone network operators to leave phone numbers accessible to all Is it a legal requirement to allow spoofed caller ID from bad actors? Spoofed IP addresses used to be a much bigger problem on the Internet than they are today (many examples but see Smurf Attack). We collectively implemented security to reduce the threat. Phone companies could do the same for spoofed caller ID for companies that consistently abuse it.
- toast0 4y ago> Spoofed IP addresses used to be a much bigger problem on the Internet than they are today (many examples but see Smurf Attack). Most of the large DDoS attacks are UDP reflection, the attacker spoofs the victims address and sends to chargen[1] servers or whatever. So spoofing is still alive and well. [1] yes really, the worst ones are people who install Microsoft's Services for Unix and enable the chargen server to the public... It sends a 64k fragmented response. Thanks Microsoft.
- 300bps 4y agoHow long have you been on the Internet? I ask because I started an ISP in 1996 and IP address spoofing used to be soooo much worse. Today’s situation is the product of literally 2.5 decades of encouraging and/or shaming Internet-connected networks into properly configuring their routers to drop spoofed packets egressing from their network with a spoofed IP address not from their network.
- toast0 4y agoApproximately forever, although while I worked at an "ISP" in 1999, it was a two T1 ISP; one for modems, one for upstream; and then we outsourced all the modem stuff to MegaPath when something weird happened to our modem T1, but I was never trained on how that T1 worked, all just magic to me. I kind of sort of get the idea today, but ... I poked at the RADIUS server, and setup webhosting for customers. I never worked for a real DDoS target until 10 years ago (and even then it was mostly people kicking the tires with 90 second DDoS services). I'm sure it's not as bad as it once was, but it's still probably easier to get a big DDoS with UDP reflection than through botnets directly hitting the target. Back to the topic of telco spam. STIR/Shaken should maybe get us actual caller-ids soonish, I think there's one more deadline for small carriers that service actual phone lines. OTOH, what are you going to do with a real caller id? I'm pretty sure phone companies just don't want to do it anymore, there's no money in voice calling, and it'll fall apart like landlines have.