7 ms·
Space Force is scrapping the annual fitness test in favor of wearable trackers
- alldayeveryday 4y ago> U.S. Space Force leadership says the approach will prioritize the general wellness of service members beyond just one physical assessment each year. The annual tests have [spurred eating disorder symptoms] and other unhealthy behaviors in some military members. The article NPR links to, making the case that the annual physical assessment tests have spurred eating disorder symptoms, links to another page (a study) which is the apparent underlying evidence of the claim. The study looked at Iraq and Afghanistan war era Veterans and examines the prevalece of what they are calling Atypical Anorexia Nervosa (AAN). Upon review, I see zero evidence in the study connecting the assessment test with the disease. The authors of the study make no such claim. When I see articles like the one linked by OP I am a bit perplexed. Is the NPR reporter/author intentionally misleading the reader? Are they just too lazy or unintelligent to sufficiently research the topic they are writing about?
- science4sail 4y ago> U.S. Space Force leadership says the approach will prioritize the general wellness of service members beyond just one physical assessment each year. The annual tests have spurred eating disorder symptoms and other unhealthy behaviors in some military members. It seems like one of the driving reasons for the change is a concern about people gaming the annual test. Couldn't fitness trackers also be gamed? For example, someone could put a pedometer into a motorized cradle to fake walking/running.
- capableweb 4y agoFitness trackers can measure more than just steps. I'm assuming (hoping maybe) they'll go by data like active/resting heartbeat rate and similar things, instead of just distance/steps.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoYeah. Step counting is bogus. Heart rate counting is much better but it's still flawed--it can end up reading repetitive arm movement as your heart rate and I've also seen cold conditions cause a substantial under-read. It didn't surprise me that my wife's Fitbit could easily overcount 10,000 steps/day but I was really puzzled by heart rates as high as 180 (which is way above acceptable max given her age) until I found out about the problem of reading motion as heartbeat. I at least partially understood the evening my Garmin was showing a heart rate around 80 when 120 would have been more like it--it was cold but I didn't have far to go and I didn't consider stopping to layer up and killing my night vision in the process to be worth it. (I had enough moonlight that my headlamp was still in my pack, but I would have had to use it to ensure I didn't drop anything and that would have meant being annoyed by all the bugs that would keep flitting around.)
- nradov 4y agoActually max heart rate has very little relationship to age, at least for people who are in decent condition. If you're thinking about the infamous "220 - Age" formula, be aware that it's bogus and not well supported by actual data. There is a huge variance in max heart rates across the population. For example, that formula underestimates mine by 27 bpm. So a heart rate of 180 could be plausible for your wife at a high exertion level. Optical heart rate sensors on the latest Garmin watches are usually pretty accurate. But they can give false readings if the band is too lose or the sensor is dirty. For any real workout or fitness test it's best to use a separate wireless heart rate strap paired to the watch.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoI don't understand the mechanics of how my Garmin was fooled that evening but it definitely corresponds to the period that I was feeling cold. As for 180 being possible for my wife--nope. We aren't youngsters and she was carrying on a conversation at the time. It was reading her arm movement, not her heart. I got myself a separate heart rate strap but Fitbit doesn't support them and she's just wearing it for the bonus the insurance company gives. (Which is set to such a ridiculously low threshold that you would have to be awfully sedentary to not reach it--in practice it translates to wear a fitness tracker, get $10/month.)
- rasz 4y agowearable trackers on your military personnel tasked with Satellites and shit, what could possibly go wrong here?
- tzs 4y agoFitness tracking doesn't necessarily imply location tracking. Even if a device does have a GPS (one of the ones they are testing does not, one does) that doesn't necessarily mean it stores location history. Most fitness tracking just needs to know you movements over the last few minutes. Also, as you note it is people who deal with satellites. Isn't that almost all done at fixed bases in friendly areas? If a satellite operation is being conducted to support something like a covert mission in hostile territory for example, the people running the satellites are back in some control center quite possibly back in the USA. It's not like if special forces had trackers that an enemy could use to see where they are heading for a mission. For the satellite guys all missions are the same from a tracker's view: drive to the office and work your normal shift then go home.
- rasz 4y agoYou reference "Fitness app Strava lights up staff at military bases" https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-42853072 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-42853072 :) >drive to the office and work your normal shift then go home or to your lover, furry convention, abortion clinic. Grindr was Chinese owned for a reason. All accessible from single database without the need to dispatch agents on foreign soil.
- aerostable_slug 4y agoThese are satellite weenies. They're going to be tracked to the game store where they play Magic: The Gathering with some other satellite weenies and then home where they'll binge-watch "Space: Above & Beyond" and wait for DoorDash to show up. Now, you may have a point re: the furry convention... Kidding aside, the article says the data portal will be Space Force only, and while it's not beyond the realm of possibility a Chinese asset might get a CAC card and reveal where Sgt. Spacemarine secretly plays Magic: The Gathering, we're talking about people who work shifts at big giant bases everyone knows about (Schriever, Buckley, Vandenberg, etc.), not SOF forces.
- count 4y agoOr just...test every month. But that wouldn't get cool news articles about digital transformation!
- remarkEon 4y ago> The annual tests have spurred eating disorder symptoms and other unhealthy behaviors in some military members. If someone is developing eating disorder symptoms they need to be chaptered and removed from military service. I don’t get why we would change the performance standards here. We’ve had fitness requirements in the military since forever. This isn’t a charity or a social club in college.
- nradov 4y agoWhat kind of physical performance standards should satellite communications technicians have?
- remarkEon 4y agoMinimal, but non-zero. There are minimum standards you have to maintain regardless of MOS.
- Asraelite 4y agoWhy? What's the concrete benefit?
- remarkEon 4y agoYou mean, beyond maintaining the discipline and health of a military branch?
- Asraelite 4y agoThose can be tested for separately. Given a candidate that's otherwise already disciplined and healthy enough to work at a desk job, what benefit is there in specifically requiring fitness for its own sake?
- remarkEon 4y ago>Those can be tested for separately. These things are highly, highly correlated - especially so in the military. >Given a candidate that's otherwise already disciplined and healthy enough to work at a desk job Working a desk job negatively impacts ones health and fitness, that is a fact lamented on this very website quite often. Maintaining baseline fitness performance standards is as much about maintaining a fighting force able to actually engage in combat (unless you, for some reason, think that certain roles should just assume they never have to actually fight - Ukrainians might have something to say about that) as it is about ensuring your people are healthy. It's not "for it's own sake". Fitter people have more energy, are able to maintain higher levels of alertness, able to stay up for more hours in high stress jobs. All of which a satellite operator would be required to do.
- midislack 4y agoPretty cool, that strela data leak was enabled by this type of policy.
- everybodyknows 4y ago> Until then, Guardians still have to complete one more Air Force fitness test — a timed 1.5 mile run and one minute each of pushups and situps. Sit-ups, aka curl-ups! Did the AF brass miss the news? > In fact, curl-ups have been linked to an increased risk of creating or aggravating lower back injuries. https://www.navy.mil/Press-Office/News-Stories/Article/2420180/the-navys-new-fitness-test-is-here-what-you-need-to-know/ https://www.navy.mil/Press-Office/News-Stories/Article/24201... https://rotcconsulting.com/navy-marine-corps-switch-plank-fitness-test/ https://rotcconsulting.com/navy-marine-corps-switch-plank-fi... Or is some other service's way always wrong, if it's not already the AF way of doing things?
- greenhearth 4y agoSo do they actually go into space? Or just more tax $ for Garmin and other "contractors?"